Abstract:Critical reading is required for information literacy in the 21st century. However, how students read and process conflicting information regarding controversial issues is still not clear. Using eye-tracking technology, this exploratory study aimed to identify visual behavior patterns that characterized critical reading strategies when students processed conflicting information about socio-scientific issues, and to examine relationships among students' visual behavior, reading strategies, and reading task outcomes. Forty-eight undergraduate and graduate students participated and read conflicting texts about food-science issues. The conflicting texts were presented in the traditional Chinese language. Participants' eye movements were tracked during the entire reading process and their self-reported critical reading strategies, recall, and opinions on the issues were collected right after reading. Pearson's correlation analyses, lag sequential analyses, and content analyses were used to analyze the data. Results showed that participants with higher scores on self-reported critical reading strategies tended to pay more attention to reasoning information in conflicting reports and to include more judgments in their responses. Further, two significant visual behavior patterns were identified for critical reading: (1) after a pause for thinking or resting, critical readers' visual attention shifted directly back to reasoning information; and (2) critical readers' visual attention shifted between reasoning and data information. These two visual behavior patterns suggested that data inspection is important for critical reasoning about conflicting information. This study provided evidence for the applicability of eye-tracking technology in assessing critical reading strategies and relationships between eye-tracking data and self-reported critical reading strategies. Findings can contribute to the future design of adaptive learning systems and teaching of critical reading strategies.

Design criticism and eye movement strategy in reading: a comparative study of design and non-design students

An Eye Tracking Study: Positive Emotional Interface Design Facilitates Learning Outcomes in Multimedia Learning?

A Study on Product Materials Mental Imagery Perception of User Experience Design

What do critical reading strategies look like? Eye-tracking and lag sequential analysis reveal attention to data and reasoning when reading conflicting information

The influence of design proposal viewing strategy: design aesthetics and professional background

An Informatics System for Exploringeye Movements in Reading

Reading in the city: mobile eye-tracking and evaluation of text in an everyday setting

Perception Differences Between Students and Teachers of Undergraduate Industrial Design Core Courses.

Assessment By Psychophysical Methods For Design Courses Of Optical Discipline

A Review of Domestic Eye Movement Research in Design Psychology

The Role of Spatial Ability and Attention Shifting in Reading of Illustrated Scientific Texts: An Eye Tracking Study

Designers' perception during sketching: An examination of Creative Segment theory using eye movements

Can eye-tracking data be measured to assess product design?: Visual attention mechanism should be considered

Critiquing contemporary interior design students

Using Eye-Tracking to Demonstrate Children’s Attention to Detail When Evaluating Low-Fidelity Prototypes

What matters in design? Cultivating undergraduates’ critical thinking through online peer assessment in a Confucian heritage context

A Study on Design Psychology on the Thinking Action of Users: Focusing Case Study on the Principles of Design Psychology

Reading Behavior in Science Comics and Its Relations with Comprehension Performance and Reading Attitudes: an Eye-tracker Study

A Comparative Analysis of Student Perceptions of Recommendations for Engagement in Design Processes

Information discernment and online reading behaviour: an experiment

Visual Attention and Association: an Electroencephalography Study in Expert Designers