Abstract:The resources available for managing disease epidemics – whether in animals, plants or humans – are limited by a range of practical and financial constraints. This motivates study of where these resources should be allocated to maximise their impact. Optimal control has been widely explored for optimising management of epidemics. The most common approach assumes a deterministic, continuous model based on differential equations to approximate the epidemic dynamics. However, real systems are stochastic and so a range of outcomes are possible for any given epidemic situation and choice of control. The deterministic models are also known to be poor approximations in cases where the number of infected hosts is low – either globally or within a subset of the population – and these cases are highly relevant in the context of control. Hence, this work explores the effectiveness of disease management strategies derived using optimal control theory when applied to a more realistic, stochastic form of disease model. We demonstrate that solutions to the deterministic optimal control are not optimal in cases where the disease is eradicated or close to eradication. The range of potential outcomes in the stochastic models means that optimising the deterministic case will not reliably eradicate disease, even when it is possible. For effective eradication, the rate of control must be higher than optimal control as applied to the deterministic model would predict. Using Model Predictive Control, in which the optimisation is performed repeatedly as the system evolves to correct for deviations from the optimal control predictions, improves performance but does not fix the underlying issue and the level of control calculated at each repeated optimisation is still insufficient. To demonstrate this, we present several very simple heuristics to identify which sites to control which can outperform the strategies calculated by MPC when the control budget is sufficient for eradication to be possible. Our illustration uses examples based on stochastic simulation of the spatial spread of plant disease but similar issues would be expected in any deterministic model where infection is driven close to zero or targeted to remain below some critical value.

Optimal control problem for a general reaction-diffusion eco-epidemiological model with disease in prey

Optimal control of an infected prey–predator model with fear effect

Optimal Control of a Reaction-Diffusion Epidemic Model with Noncompliance

Optimal control problem for a general reaction–diffusion tumor–immune system with chemotherapy

Optimal control and dynamics of a nonlocal diffusion SVIR epidemic model

Dynamic Analysis of a Predator-Prey (Pest) Model with Disease in Prey and Involving an Impulsive Control Strategy

A new optimal cross-diffusive control for a class of spatio-temporal predator-prey models

Global dynamics and optimal control of a cholera transmission model with vaccination strategy and multiple pathways

Stability Analysis and Control Optimization of a Prey-Predator Model with Linear Feedback Control

Optimal Control Prevents Itself from Eradicating Stochastic Disease Epidemics

Global Solution and Optimal Control of an Epidemic Propagation with a Heterogeneous Diffusion

Optimal control of susceptible mature pest concerning disease-induced pest-natural enemy system with cost-effectiveness

Global behavior and optimal control of a dengue transmission model with standard incidence rates and self‐protection

Analysis of a chronological age-structured epidemic model with a pair of optimal treatment controls

Optimal control strategies for infectious diseases with consideration of behavioral dynamics

Optimal control and cost-effective analysis of an age-structured emerging infectious disease model

Global solution for a general cross-diffusion two-competitive-predator and one-prey system with predator-taxis

A Nonlocal and Time-Delayed Reaction–diffusion Eco-Epidemiological Predator–prey Model

Analysis and Optimal Control of a Two-Strain SEIR Epidemic Model with Saturated Treatment Rate

Control of Generalized Discrete-time SIS Epidemics via Submodular Function Minimization

Optimality for a diffusive predator-prey system in a spatially heterogeneous environment incorporating a prey refuge