Abstract:In this paper, we seek to contribute to debates into new modalities of power within project-based organizations (PBOs), and specifically architectural practices. Using a targeted ethnography, we explore specific episodes within the workflow of an architectural practice. Here, we explore how imperatives for creativity and collaboration are reconciled alongside those for control and authority through specific relations of power. In contrast with other critical accounts of power in PBOs, we explicitly examine the influence of embodied and material registers of practice. This approach draws inspiration from studies across the social sciences, not least those of architectural practice, which have revealed how embodied and material practices shape organizational life. Our research reveals that despite an overt attempt to play down hierarchical modes of organization, management control and authority is still apparent, albeit it in a form that is highly embodied and intertwined with material relations. Thus, power is not manifest in social relations per se, but plays out across embodied and material registers, from the layout and use of office space to the actions and emotions of individuals within a meeting. The research importantly reveals that power in architectural practices, and other PBOs, is likely multiple: ‘hierarchy’ enables decisions to be made, responsibility to be apportioned and disputes to be settled, while ‘heterarchy’ encourages creativity, co-learning, motivation and communication. Thus, the paper argues that if we can understand power in PBO in more nuanced and positive terms, then we can better understand how work is done and through what techniques. This could lead to deeper theoretical insights into project-based forms of organizing, not least architectural practice.

Framing under power asymmetries: A cross-level examination of the early-stage product design process

From Layout to System: Early Stage Power Delivery and Architecture Co-Exploration

Association change and its relationship with designs in context and form: how product evaluation is affected by negative framings

A novel cross-layer framework for early-stage power delivery and architecture co-exploration.

An Analysis of Temporal Framing Effect During Knowledge Worker Team's Decision-making Process

Risk management on joint product development with power asymmetry between supplier and manufacturer

Preliminary Study on Students’ Experiences in Design-Based Interdisciplinary Learning

Concrete Versus Abstract: How Innovators’ Language of Framing Impacts Public Resource Acquisition?

Digital reframing: The design thinking of redesigning traditional products into innovative digital products

Co-Creating a Framework to Integrate Sustainable Design into Product Development Practice: Case Study at an Engineering Consultancy Firm

Information Framework In Product Design Prophase Analysis

Framing Open Design through Theoretical Concepts and Practical Applications: A Systematic Literature Review

Deep thoughts and shallow frames: on the susceptibility to framing effects

A Collective Intelligence Oriented Three-Layer Framework for Socialized and Collaborative Product Design.

Rational framing effects: A multidisciplinary case

A Blockchain and Modified Best-worst Algorithm Enhanced Blackboard Model for Stranger Collaboration Based Social Product Design

An Optimization Framework For Product Design

Consumers’ Preference for User-Designed Versus Designer-Designed Products: The Moderating Role of Power Distance Belief

Scale framing, benefit framing and their interaction effects on energy-saving behaviors: Evidence from urban residents of China

AutoFrame: A Novel Procedure to Auto-Convert Architectural Massing Models into Structural Simulation Models to Streamline Embodied- and Operational-Carbon Assessment and Daylight Evaluation in Early Design

Understanding power within project work: the neglected role of material and embodied registers