Evaluating User Experience in the Context of Cultural Heritage Dissemination Using Extended Reality: A Case Study of the Dacian Bronze Matrix with Hollow Design

Călin Neamțu,Radu Comes,Dorin-Mircea Popovici,Elena Băutu,Mateescu-Suciu Liliana,Adrien Syrotnik,Matei-Ioan Popovici

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1145/3639933

2024-01-10

Journal on Computing and Cultural Heritage

Abstract:Cultural institutions are increasingly prioritizing the utilization of diverse mixed reality technologies to enrich the visitor experience during their physical exhibitions. These institutions are actively integrating virtual assets to enhance interactivity and facilitate immersive storytelling experiences. The use of extended reality technologies in cultural heritage dissemination has become a common solution to improve the perception on cultural heritage of their visitors. The objective of the proposed research is to conduct a comparative analysis of three distinct extended reality applications used in cultural heritage experiences. The proposed workflow integrates advanced 3D scanning technology and additive manufacturing techniques to produce tangible replicas which are further enhanced using extended reality technologies, such as Augmented Reality, Desktop Virtual Reality, and Immersive Virtual Reality. To evaluate the developed extended reality applications, we have conducted various System Usability Scale tools to assess applications' usability while also trying to identify the most appropriate application that can be integrated within the museum exhibition. From a utility point of view we found no notable differences in the user perceptions between proposed solutions, while from a usability and satisfaction point of view, the most preferred solution was the Augmented Reality one. The workflow is presented in sufficient detail to ensure the replication of the results.

computer science, interdisciplinary applications

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper mainly aims to address the following issues:

1. **Comparative Evaluation of Different Interaction Modes**: The study aims to explore the different ways museum visitors interact with digital cultural heritage content and their potential impacts through three different Extended Reality (XR) applications.

2. **Enhancing User Experience**: Utilizing Extended Reality technologies (including Augmented Reality, AR, Desktop Virtual Reality, VR, and Immersive Virtual Reality, Immersive VR) to enhance user engagement and immersion in cultural heritage experiences.

3. **Comparing Different Solutions**: The paper develops three different XR applications and compares their differences in terms of user experience, usability, and satisfaction to determine the most suitable type of application for museum exhibitions.

Specifically, the paper attempts to answer the following research questions:

- RQ1: What are the most common user interaction modes and experiences in the context of cultural heritage dissemination using Extended Reality applications?
- RQ2: Can the use of Extended Reality (AR/VR) applications enhance visitors' engagement and cultural immersion?
- RQ3: Are there significant differences between the implemented solutions?

To achieve these goals, the paper adopts the following methods:

- **Digital Data Collection and Processing**: Using 3D scanning technology to obtain accurate 3D models of cultural heritage items (such as the Dacian bronze matrix).
- **Development of XR Applications**: Developing three XR applications based on 3D models, including AR, Desktop VR, and Immersive VR applications, to support user interaction with cultural heritage.
- **User Experience Evaluation**: Using tools such as the System Usability Scale to evaluate the developed XR applications to understand user perceptions and preferences.

In summary, the core of this paper lies in exploring how to better utilize these technologies to improve the museum visitor experience by comparatively analyzing the application effects of three XR technologies in cultural heritage dissemination.