Abstract:Digitalization has expanded the scope of citizen participation. Nevertheless, there are no conclusive findings on online citizen participation and inclusive policymaking. This study adds in line with the discussion with a fresh perspective of institutional bias. It presents new evidence by examining the process, participants, policy agenda, and sentiments of public opinions from the government-led and Internet-empowered citizen participation regarding the 2017–2035 Shanghai Master Plan. Four findings are reported based on the in-depth case study with text and sentiment analysis. First, the government-led model provides institutionalized opportunities for citizen engagement throughout the policy process, while the Internet-empowered citizen participation is characterized by contingency and ad hoc. Second, the government-led model remains elite-dominated, while the Internet empowers a wider scope of stakeholders with an open and popularized participation platform. Third, the public opinion from the Internet-empowered model often goes beyond or even against the pre-defined official principles and goals. In contrast, the civic discussion in the government-led model influences policy by changing the sequence of policy agenda or providing focus within the official setting. Fourth, citizens, especially the experts, are more likely to give positive feedback in the government-led model than the Internet-empowered approach. These findings confirm and identify the remaining institutional bias that hinders inclusive policymaking in the Internet age. Theoretically, it reminds scholars to examine the institutional arrangements regarding citizen participation carefully. Practically, it indicates that the central government could facilitate inclusive policymaking at the local level by reducing the institutional bias of the government-led approach and utilizing text and sentiment analysis to urge the local government's response to Internet-empowered public opinion.

Determinants of citizen-generated data in a smart city: Analysis of 311 system user behavior

Citizen and Open Government: An Empirical Analysis of Antecedents of Open Government Data

Equity in 311 Reporting: Understanding Socio-Spatial Differentials in the Propensity to Complain

Unveiling citizen-government interactions in urban renewal in China: Spontaneous online opinions, reginal characteristics, and government responsiveness

Smart City with Chinese Characteristics Against the Background of Big Data: Idea, Action and Risk

The survey of the factors influencing the use of open government data in Taiwan: The preliminary findings

Influence of citizen relationship management system on citizen participation in Taiwan: A participatory politics perspective

Government-led and Internet-empowered Citizen Participation in China's Policymaking: A Case Study of the Shanghai 2035 Master Plan.

Exploring the Factors Influencing Online Civic Engagement in a Smart City: the Mediating Roles of ICT Self-Efficacy and Commitment to Community.

Diversions from policing as usual: A more caring city with Atlanta's 311PAD?

Structure of 311 service requests as a signature of urban location

Enhancing local governments’ environmental attention through open government data: evidence from China

Exploring Driving Factors of Digital Transformation among Local Governments: Foundations for Smart City Construction in China

Revisit the drivers and barriers to e-governance in the mobile age: A case study on the adoption of city management mobile apps for smart urban governance

Government Responsiveness and Public Acceptance of Big-Data Technology in Urban Governance: Evidence from China During the COVID-19 Pandemic.

Citizen-initiated interactions in urban water governance: How public authorities respond to micro-level opinions related to nature-based solutions

A Study on Determinant Factors in Smart City Development: An Analytic Hierarchy Process Analysis

Determinants of Smart City Technology Acceptance: Role of Smart Governance as Moderator

Effects of public data open on performance of government functions in China: the roles of digital economy and market economic system adopting the perspective of resource- based view

Can Open Government Data Improve City Green Land-Use Efficiency? Evidence from China

Analyzing the Critical Factors Influencing Post-Use Trust and Its Impact on Citizens’ Continuous-Use Intention of E-Government: Evidence from Chinese Municipalities