Abstract:Objectives: Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis (MCDA) has gained increasing attention in supporting drug risk-benefit assessment, pricing and reimbursement, as well as optimization of clinical interventions. The objective of this study was to systematically collect and categorize evaluation criteria and techniques of weighting and scoring of MCDA for drug value assessment. Methods: A systematic review of the literature was conducted across seven databases to identify articles utilizing the MCDA frameworks for the evaluation of drug value. Evaluation criteria mentioned in the included studies were extracted and assigned to 5 dimensions including clinical, economic, innovative, societal and humanistic value. A descriptive statistical analysis was performed on the identified drug value evaluation criteria, as well as the weighting and scoring techniques employed. The more a criterion or technique were mentioned in articles, the more important we consider it. Results: Out of the 82 articles included, 111 unique criteria were identified to evaluate the value of drug. Among the 56 unique criteria (448 times) used to measure clinical value, the most frequently mentioned were "comparative safety/tolerability" (58 times), "comparative effectiveness/efficacy" (56 times), "comparative patient-perceived health/patient reported outcomes" (37 times), "disease severity" (34 times), and "unmet needs" (25 times). Regarding economic value measurement, out of the 20 unique criteria (124 times), the most frequently utilized criteria were "cost of intervention" (17 times), "comparative other medical costs" (16 times), and "comparative non-medical costs" (18 times). Out of the 10 criteria (18 times) for assessing innovative value, "a novel pharmacological mechanism" was the most frequently mentioned criterion (5 times). Among the 22 criteria (73 times) used to measure societal value, "system capacity and appropriate use of intervention" was the most frequently cited criterion (14 times). Out of the 3 criteria (15 times) utilized to measure humanistic value, "political/historical/cultural context" was the most frequently mentioned criterion (9 times). Furthermore, 11 scoring and 11 weighting techniques were found from various MCDA frameworks. "Swing weighting" and "a direct rating scale" were the most frequently used techniques in included articles. Conclusion: This study comprehensively presented the current evaluation dimensions, criteria, and techniques for scoring and weighting in drug-oriented MCDA articles. By highlighting the frequently cited evaluation criteria and techniques for scoring and weighting, this analysis will provide a foundation to reasonably select appropriate evaluation criteria and technique in constructing the MCDA framework that aligns with research objectives.

Customer value assessment of pharmaceutical marketing in Taiwan

Customer relationship management analysis of outpatients in a Chinese infectious disease hospital using drug-proportion recency-frequency-monetary model

A method of customer valuation score and implementation for marketing strategy

Integrated customer lifetime value models to support marketing decisions in the complementary and alternative medicine industry

Medical Market Segmentation of Based on Customer Value

Brand marketing for creating brand value based on a MCDM model combining DEMATEL with ANP and VIKOR methods

Segmentation of telecom customers based on customer value by decision tree model

Modeling patient's value using a stochastic approach: An empirical study in the medical industry

The Research of Economic Value of Innovative Business—Turn Health Care Food into Service

Data Mining Application in Customer Relationship Management for Hospital Inpatients

Customer Segmentation Based on RFM Analysis as the Basis of Marketing Strategy Case Study of PT Pertiwi Agung Pharmaceutical Industry (LANDSON)

Optimization of the marketing mix in the health care industry

Integrated customer lifetime value (CLV) and customer migration model to improve customer segmentation

A method of potential customer searching from opinions of network villagers in virtual communities

Factors Influencing the Use of Health Information Exchange by Physicians—Using the National Health Insurance PharmaCloud System in Taiwan

Application of Big Data Marketing in Customer Relationship Management

Healthcare market segmentation and data mining: A systematic review

Estimating Customer Lifetime Value using LRFM Model in Pharmaceutical and Medical Device Distribution Company

Indonesian pharmacy retailer segmentation using recency frequency monetary-location model and ant K-means algorithm

Unveiling the Dynamics of Consumer Attention: A Two-Stage Hybrid MCDM Analysis of Key Factors and Interrelationships in Influencer Marketing

The application of multi-criteria decision analysis in evaluating the value of drug-oriented intervention: a literature review