Statistical Optimization of Hydrazone-Crosslinked Hyaluronic Acid Hydrogels for Protein Delivery

Esther A Mozipo,Alycia N Galindo,Jenna D Khachatourian,Conor G. Harris,Jonathan Dorogin,Veronica R Spaulding,Madeleine R Ford,Malvika Singhal,Kaitlin Fogg,Marian Hirushika Hettiaratchi
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3tb01588b
IF: 7.571
2024-02-06
Journal of Materials Chemistry B
Abstract:Hydrazone-crosslinked hydrogels are attractive protein delivery vehicles for regenerative medicine. However, each regenerative medicine application requires unique hydrogel properties to achieve an ideal outcome. The properties of a hydrogel can be impacted by numerous factors involved in its fabrication. We used design of experiments (DoE) statistical modeling to efficiently optimize the physicochemical properties of a hyaluronic acid (HA) hydrazone-crosslinked hydrogel for protein delivery for bone regeneration. We modified HA with either adipic acid dihydrazide (HA-ADH) or aldehyde (HA-Ox) functional groups and used DoE to evaluate the interactions of three input variables, the molecular weight of HA (40 or 100 kDa), the concentration of HA-ADH (1-3% w/v), and the concentration of HA-Ox (1-3% w/v), on three output responses, gelation time, compressive modulus, and hydrogel stability over time. We identified 100 kDa HA-ADH 3.00 HA-Ox 2.33 as an optimal hydrogel that met all of our design criteria, including displaying a gelation time of 3.7 minutes, compressive modulus of 62.1 Pa, and minimal mass change over 28 days. For protein delivery, we conjugated affinity proteins called affibodies that were specific to the osteogenic protein bone morphogenetic protein-2 (BMP-2) to HA hydrogels and demonstrated that our platform could control the release of BMP-2 over 28 days. Ultimately, our approach demonstrates the utility of DoE for optimizing hydrazone-crosslinked HA hydrogels for protein delivery.
materials science, biomaterials
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to optimize the physicochemical properties of hyaluronic acid (HA) hydrogels for efficient protein delivery, especially bone morphogenetic protein - 2 (BMP - 2) for bone regeneration. Specifically, the authors systematically studied the effects of multiple input parameters on the performance of hydrogels by the design of experiments (DoE) method and established a mathematical model to predict the best and worst hydrogel formulations. ### Main problems 1. **How to optimize the physicochemical properties of HA hydrogels**: In order to achieve the desired protein - delivery effect, multiple properties of the hydrogel need to be optimized simultaneously, such as the compressive modulus, gelation time, and mass change over a four - week period. 2. **How to efficiently screen the best hydrogel formulation**: The traditional "one - factor - at - a - time" method is time - consuming and costly, so a more efficient optimization method is required. 3. **How to ensure that the hydrogel can effectively control the release of BMP - 2**: The hydrogel not only needs to have good physicochemical properties but also needs to be able to stably release BMP - 2 over a long period to promote bone regeneration. ### Solutions 1. **Statistical optimization using DoE**: The authors selected three input variables - HA molecular weight (40 kDa or 100 kDa), HA - ADH concentration (1 - 3% w/v), and HA - Ox concentration (1 - 3% w/v), and generated 15 different hydrogel formulations through D - optimal design. These formulations cover different combinations of input variables to comprehensively evaluate their effects on the performance of hydrogels. 2. **Establish a mathematical model**: Based on the experimental data, the authors used a multilinear regression model to fit the relationship between each response variable (gelation time, compressive modulus, and mass change) and the input variables. The factors that significantly affect the performance of hydrogels were determined by ANOVA analysis, and the validity of the model was verified. 3. **Verify model predictions**: According to the model predictions, the best and worst hydrogel formulations were prepared and experimentally verified. The results showed that the optimal formulation (100 kDa HA - ADH 3.00% w/v and HA - Ox 2.33% w/v) had a gelation time of 3.7 minutes, a compressive modulus of 62.1 Pa, and maintained the minimum mass change within 28 days. 4. **Protein - delivery verification**: By coupling the BMP - 2 - specific affibody to the HA hydrogel, the controlled release of BMP - 2 was achieved, demonstrating the potential of this platform in bone regeneration applications. ### Conclusion Through the DoE method, the authors successfully optimized the physicochemical properties of HA hydrogels, enabling them to effectively deliver BMP - 2 and achieve controllable release. This research provides important references and guidance for the development of new hydrogel platforms for regenerative medicine.