Abstract:Background: Under-reporting and, thus, uncertainty around the true incidence of health events is common in all public health reporting systems. While the problem of under-reporting is acknowledged in epidemiology, the guidance and methods available for assessing and correcting the resulting bias are obscure. Objective: We aim to design a simple modification to the Susceptible - Infected - Removed (SIR) model for estimating the fraction or proportion of reported infection cases. Methods: The suggested modification involves rescaling of the classical SIR model producing its mathematically equivalent version with explicit dependence on the reporting parameter (true proportion of cases reported). We justify the rescaling using the phase plane analysis of the SIR model system and show how this rescaling parameter can be estimated from the data along with the other model parameters. Results: We demonstrate how the proposed method is cross-validated using simulated data with known disease cases and then apply it to two empirical reported data sets to estimate the fraction of reported cases in Missoula County, Montana, USA, using: (1) flu data for 2016-2017 and (2) COVID-19 data for fall of 2020. Conclusions: We establish with the simulated and COVID-19 data that when most of the disease cases are presumed reported, the value of the additional reporting parameter in the modified SIR model is close or equal to one, so that the original SIR model is appropriate for data analysis. Conversely, the flu example shows that when the reporting parameter is close to zero, the original SIR model is not accurately estimating the usual rate parameters, and the re-scaled SIR model should be used. This research demonstrates the role of under-reporting of disease data and the importance of accounting for under-reporting when modeling simulated, endemic, and pandemic disease data. Correctly reporting the "true" number of disease cases will have downstream impacts on predictions of disease dynamics. A simple parameter adjustment to the SIR modeling framework can help alleviate bias and uncertainty around crucial epidemiological metrics (e.g.: basic disease reproduction number) and public health decision making.

Theoretical and numerical study of case reporting rate with application to epidemiology

Refining Estimation of the Instantaneous Reproduction Number During Early Pandemic Stages: Addressing Case-Reporting Variability and Serial Interval Uncertainty

A simple modification to the classical SIR model to estimate the proportion of under-reported infections using case studies in flu and COVID-19

Understanding Theoretically The Impact of Reporting of Disease Cases in Epidemiology

Stability and Optimality Criteria for an SVIR Epidemic Model with Numerical Simulation

Data-driven Identification of Number of Unreported Cases for COVID-19: Bounds and Limitations

Theoretical and numerical analysis of COVID-19 pandemic model with non-local and non-singular kernels

Risk Estimate under a Nonstationary Autoregressive Model for Data-Driven Reproduction Number Estimation

Forecasting Epidemics Through Nonparametric Estimation of Time-Dependent Transmission Rates Using the SEIR Model

Dynamics of a stochastic epidemic model integrating unreported cases with a general contact susceptible function

Early real-time estimation of the basic reproduction number of emerging or reemerging infectious diseases in a community with heterogeneous contact pattern: Using data from Hong Kong 2009 H1N1 Pandemic Influenza as an illustrative example

Quantitative analysis of a fractional order of the $ SEI_{c}\, I_{\eta} VR $ epidemic model with vaccination strategy

A modeling framework for the analysis of the SARS-CoV2 transmission dynamics

Estimation of time-varying reproduction numbers underlying epidemiological processes: A new statistical tool for the COVID-19 pandemic

A modelling framework for the analysis of the SARS-CoV2 transmission dynamics

Improved estimation of the effective reproduction number with heterogeneous transmission rates and reporting delays

Optimal Control of General Impulsive VS-EIAR Epidemic Models with Application to Covid-19

Robust estimation of end-of-outbreak probabilities in the presence of delayed and incomplete case reporting

Joint estimation of the effective reproduction number and daily incidence in the presence of aggregated and missing data

Semiparametric inference of effective reproduction number dynamics from wastewater pathogen surveillance data

Temporal evolution of the Covid19 pandemic reproduction number: Estimations from proximal optimization to Monte Carlo sampling