Do institutional dimensions matter at different stages of the entrepreneurial process? A multi-country study

Claudia Alvarez,Tatiana Lopez,David Urbano,Lopez, Tatiana,Urbano, David
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11187-024-00920-4
IF: 7.096
2024-03-28
Small Business Economics
Abstract:Entrepreneurs should navigate through different stages from the conception of an idea until the business is operational. According to these stages, we expected that the context has a different impact on an individual's decisions. This paper analyses the role of institutional dimensions (regulative, normative, and cultural-cognitive) in the entrepreneurial process (potential, nascent, and new entrepreneurship), using data from the Global Entrepreneurship Monitor and Heritage Foundation, with a sample of 99 countries for the period 2001–2017. Through panel data, the main findings show that (a) regulations regarding new business creation have a stronger influence on new entrepreneurship, (b) social norms have more influence on potential entrepreneurs and individual perceptions regarding their self-capacity and experience to start a new business, and (c) the cultural-cognitive dimension has a stronger influence on nascent entrepreneurship. Policymakers could consider these results to promote and generate target group policies that effectively encourage entrepreneurial activity, which is also distinguished by the level of development among countries.
economics,business,management
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the paper attempts to solve This paper aims to explore the influence of institutional dimensions (regulation, norms, and cultural cognition) in different entrepreneurial stages. Specifically, the author hopes to answer the following questions by analyzing the roles of these institutional dimensions in the three stages of potential entrepreneurship, nascent entrepreneurship, and new - venture creation: 1. **How do different institutional dimensions affect different stages of the entrepreneurial process?** - Does the regulatory dimension (such as regulations related to the establishment of new enterprises) have a stronger impact in the new - venture creation stage? - Does the normative dimension (such as society's attitude and expectation towards entrepreneurship) have a greater influence in the potential entrepreneurship stage? - Does the cultural - cognitive dimension (such as shared beliefs and values) have a stronger influence in the nascent entrepreneurship stage? 2. **How can policymakers formulate more effective policies to promote entrepreneurial activities based on these findings?** - How to design targeted policy measures according to the development levels and specific needs of different countries? ### Research background - **Entrepreneurial process**: Entrepreneurship is a dynamic process. From the generation of entrepreneurial intentions to the actual operation of enterprises, it needs to go through multiple stages. Each stage faces different environments and challenges. - **Institutional theory**: Institutional theory believes that the regulatory, normative, and cultural - cognitive dimensions together constitute the stability and meaning of social life. These institutional dimensions have an important impact on individual decisions and behaviors. - **Limitations of existing research**: Although existing research has shown that institutional conditions can explain the differences in entrepreneurship rates among different countries, most research has not distinguished different stages of entrepreneurship, which has led to a simplified understanding of the institutional impact. ### Main contributions 1. **Theoretical contributions**: - Explained the different mechanisms of institutional dimensions in different stages of the entrepreneurial process. - Provided empirical evidence of the inter - relationships among institutional dimensions and analyzed their impacts on new - venture creation in different stages. 2. **Policy recommendations**: - Informed policymakers that they need to develop specific projects for each entrepreneurial stage. - Pointed out which institutional characteristics are necessary for the transition from one stage to another. ### Methods - **Data sources**: Used data from the Global Entrepreneurship Monitor and the Heritage Foundation. The sample includes 99 countries, and the time range is from 2001 to 2017. - **Analysis methods**: Through panel data analysis, explored the impacts of different institutional dimensions in each stage of the entrepreneurial process. ### Main findings - **Regulatory dimension**: Regulations related to the establishment of new enterprises have a greater impact on the new - venture creation stage. - **Normative dimension**: Social norms have a greater impact on potential entrepreneurs, especially on individuals' perception of their own abilities and experiences. - **Cultural - cognitive dimension**: Shared beliefs and values have a greater impact on the nascent entrepreneurship stage. ### Conclusion By analyzing the roles of different institutional dimensions in each stage of the entrepreneurial process, policymakers can better understand how to formulate effective policy measures according to the needs of different stages, thereby promoting the development of entrepreneurial activities.