Can linear transportation infrastructure verges constitute a habitat and/or a corridor for vascular plants in temperate ecosystems? A systematic review

Hugo Mell,Vinciane Fack,Louise Percevault,Sylvie Vanpeene,Yves Bertheau,Aurélie Coulon,Frédérique Flamerie de Lachapelle,Eric Guinard,Arzhvaël Jeusset,Eric Le Mitouard,Dakis-Yaoba Ouédraogo,Marianne Vargac,Romain Sordello,Yorick Reyjol,Julien Touroult,Sébastien Filoche,Frédéric Hendoux
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s13750-024-00328-3
2024-03-17
Environmental Evidence
Abstract:Linear transportation infrastructures (roads, railways, oil and gas pipelines, powerlines and waterways) are recognized as important contributors to the fragmentation of species habitats. On the other hand, verges of linear transportation infrastructures (road and railway embankments, strips of grass under power lines or above buried pipelines, or waterway banks) form vast networks of continuous habitats. While the loss of natural habitats still poses a significant threat to biodiversity, verges can provide habitats or corridors in anthropogenic areas, although this potential for conservation remains controversial. The current paper is the first synthesis of evidence addressing this topic for vascular plants (except strictly aquatic species) in temperate ecosystems. We asked the following question: can linear transportation infrastructure verges constitute habitats and/or corridors for vascular plants in temperate ecosystems?
environmental sciences
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main issue this paper attempts to address is whether the edge zones of linear transportation infrastructures (such as roads, railways, oil pipelines, power lines, and waterways) can serve as habitats and/or corridors for vascular plants in temperate ecosystems. Specifically, the authors aim to evaluate the potential of these edge zones in biodiversity conservation, particularly in providing habitats and facilitating species migration, through a systematic review. ### Background The destruction and fragmentation of natural habitats by Linear Transportation Infrastructures (LTIs) have raised widespread concerns. Although these infrastructures lead to a reduction in biodiversity, their edge zones (such as road and railway embankments, grasslands under power lines, grasslands above buried pipelines, and riverbanks of waterways) may form continuous habitat networks, providing habitats and migration corridors for plants. However, this potential conservation role remains controversial. ### Research Objectives The main objective of this study is to determine, through a systematic review, whether the edge zones of linear transportation infrastructures can serve as habitats and/or corridors for vascular plants in temperate ecosystems. Additionally, the study aims to assess the impact of management measures (such as mowing) and surrounding landscape features on the potential of these edge zones as habitats and corridors. ### Key Questions 1. **Can the edge zones of linear transportation infrastructures serve as habitats and/or corridors for vascular plants?** 2. **How do management measures affect the diversity and dispersal of vascular plants in these edge zones?** 3. **How do surrounding landscape features affect the diversity and dispersal of vascular plants in these edge zones?** ### Methods The research team conducted a systematic literature search, collected relevant studies, and rigorously screened and evaluated these studies. Specific steps included: - **Literature Search**: Using two online databases, three search engines, professional websites, and soliciting literature from experts. - **Screening**: Screening based on titles, abstracts, and full texts to ensure the relevance and quality of the studies. - **Classification and Evaluation**: Classifying and critically evaluating the selected studies using six specific questions, covering the potential of edge zones as habitats and corridors, and the impact of management and landscape features. - **Data Synthesis**: Conducting narrative synthesis and quantitative analysis of the eligible studies. ### Conclusions - **Habitat Function**: The study found that the edge zones of non-highway roads can serve as habitats for vascular plants in certain cases, especially for alien species. However, there was no significant difference for native species and overall species diversity. - **Corridor Function**: Due to the insufficient number of relevant studies, no clear conclusions could be drawn about the edge zones serving as plant corridors. - **Management Measures**: Different management measures have varying impacts on plant diversity and dispersal, often temporarily altering the balance between native and alien plants. ### Significance This study highlights the need for further research on the role of linear transportation infrastructure edge zones as plant corridors, especially in the context of current ecological network construction. Understanding the potential role of these edge zones can help formulate more effective ecological conservation strategies, promoting biodiversity conservation and restoration.