Quantitation of Risk Reduction of E. coli Transmission after Using Antimicrobial Hand Soap

Umesh Adhikari,Elaheh Esfahanian,Jade Mitchell,Duane Charbonneau,Xiangyu Song,Yang Lu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/pathogens9100778

IF: 3.7

2020-09-23

Pathogens

Abstract:Handwashing with soap is an effective and economical means to reduce the likelihood of Escherichia coli infection from indirect contact with contaminated surfaces during food preparation. The purpose of this study was to conduct a quantitative microbial risk assessment (QMRA) to evaluate the risk of infection from indirect contact with fomites contaminated with E. coli after hand washing with antimicrobial hand soaps. A Monte Carlo simulation was done with a total of 10,000 simulations to compare the effectiveness of two antimicrobial and one control (non-antimicrobial) bar soaps in reducing the exposure and infection risk compared to no hand washing. The numbers of E. coli on several fomites commonly found in household kitchens, as well as the transfer rates between fomites and onto fingertips, were collected from the literature and experimental data. The sponsor company provided the E. coli survival on hands after washing with antimicrobial and control soaps. A number of scenarios were evaluated at two different exposure doses (high and low). Exposure scenarios included transfer of E. coli between meat-to-cutting board surface-to-hands, meat-to-knife surface-to-hands, and from a countertop surface-to-hands, kitchen sponge-to-hands, hand towel-to-hands, and dishcloth-to-hands. Results showed that the risks of illness after washing with the control soap was reduced approximately 5-fold compared to no handwashing. Washing with antimicrobial soap reduced the risk of E. coli infection by an average of about 40-fold compared with no handwashing. The antimicrobial soaps ranged from 3 to 32 times more effective than the non-antimicrobial soap, depending on the specific exposure scenario. Importance: The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention indicate the yearly incidence rate of Shiga Toxin producing E. coli infections is about 1.7/100,000, with about 10% of cases leading to life-threatening hemolytic uremic syndrome and 3–5% leading to death. Our findings confirm handwashing with soap reduces the risks associated with indirect transmission of E. coli infection from contact with fomites during food preparation. Further, in these exposure scenarios, antimicrobial soaps were more effective overall than the non-antimicrobial soap in reducing exposure to E. coli and risk of infection.

microbiology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper aims to solve is to evaluate the effect of using antibacterial hand sanitizer compared with ordinary hand sanitizer (non - antibacterial) in reducing the risk of infection through indirect contact with surfaces contaminated with Escherichia coli in the kitchen. Specifically, the study compared the effectiveness of two antibacterial soaps and one ordinary soap in reducing the risk of infection caused by oral ingestion after the hands are exposed to Escherichia coli during food preparation through the Quantitative Microbial Risk Assessment (QMRA) method. The study considered multiple exposure scenarios, including the bacterial transfer processes from meat to cutting boards, from knives to hands, from countertops to hands, from kitchen sponges to hands, from towels to hands, and from rags to hands.

The main purposes of the study are:
1. **Quantify the risk**: Through Monte Carlo simulation, quantify the potential exposure doses of Escherichia coli transferred from various surfaces in the kitchen to the hands and then from the hands to the mouth under different hand - washing methods.
2. **Evaluate the effectiveness**: Evaluate the difference in the effectiveness of using antibacterial soap compared with ordinary soap in reducing Escherichia coli exposure and the risk of infection.
3. **Provide scientific basis**: Provide a scientific basis for public health policies and household hygiene practices, emphasizing the importance of hand - washing in preventing food - borne diseases.

Through these analyses, the study hopes to provide the public with specific suggestions on how to effectively reduce the risk of Escherichia coli infection, especially during food preparation.