Abstract:The arguments made by Haynos et al in their editorial 'Not niche: eating disorders as an example in the dangers of overspecialisation' Reference Haynos, Egbert, Fitzsimmons-Craft, Levinson and Schleider 1 highly resonate with my personal experience as a patient with a longstanding and severe eating disorder. The authors make several pertinent points about the link between perceptions of eating disorders as a niche field within research and the amount of funding available for research and clinical innovation, highlighting some of the possible reasons why. In addition to stereotypical and gendered views about eating disorders and the unique medical risks they may involve, the lived experience of people like myself can provide additional insight into how this overspecialisation is experienced clinically, as well as further potential reasons why. In turn, a broader array of solutions can be alighted upon for addressing the key barrier to equitable understanding and care provision that overspecialisation represents. Haynos et al's focus on the interrelationship between eating disorders and other psychiatric concerns reflects the experience of people like myself who often have multiple co-occurring psychiatric conditions. In addition to the medical risks that the authors note, it is also worth stating explicitly that eating disorders are not disconnected from other medical concerns – and not just in terms of risks that result from the physiological consequences of eating disorder symptoms. Emerging research shows that there are many medical factors which may contribute to predisposing risk and development of eating disorders, or be in bidirectional relationship with them, ranging from genetic factors Reference Bulik, Coleman, Hardaway, Breithaupt, Watson and Bryant 2 and neurodivergence Reference Longhurst and Clark 3 to metabolic Reference Yu and Muehleman 4 and autoimmune conditions. Reference Hedman, Breithaupt, Hübel, Thornton, Tillander and Norring 5 In my lived experience as an individual who also has Ehlers Danlos Syndrome, I experience primary physiological problems as a result of my medical condition (such as gastroparesis) which have directly contributed towards the development and maintenance of anorexia and subsequently bulimia. It has been extremely frustrating to always have medical concerns seen as a secondary consequence or byproduct of the supposedly primary psychological problem – the eating disorder. I have often been told that 'there is no point' treating my physical health problems aside from in medical emergencies, as what is needed is to treat 'the real problem', which supposedly resides in my psychopathology. Yet, to take an example from my own experience, it is equally important to understand that features of malnutrition such as profoundly low potassium will change one's psychological state as it is to understand that psychological features may lead to eating patterns causing malnutrition. At worst, the primacy given to psychology is not just a theoretical problem but has real-world implications in care, whereby my physical health problems have been left undiagnosed and/or untreated as a result of diagnostic overshadowing – sometimes for decades. Reference Downs and Mycock 6 This denies opportunities to unlock treatment targets which may be important in the maintenance of illness, as has been the case for me – opportunities which are made more remote by the way in which patients experience care for different components of their condition as 'siloed' between multiple specialties which often do not communicate well, or share responsibility effectively and safely. Reference Branley-Bell, Talbot, Downs, Figueras, Green and McGilley 7 As such, the over-attribution of illness to psychopathology and understanding of eating disorders as situated within psychiatry alone might be usefully added to the harmful assumptions that Haynos et al rightly identify. The authors' action-focused and ambitious solutions can therefore be supplemented to include a paradigm shift towards a greater centrality of the role of biology in our conceptualisation of eating disorders – that they are even less niche than proposed. This will allow for a greater range of relevant treatment targets and opportunities for recovery for people like me, where progress has been unlocked by giving greater weight to biological features alongside psychological support and understanding. Lastly, although factors such as gender are important in understanding the harmful assumptions that confine eating disorders -Abstract Truncated-

Valuing patient perspectives in the context of eating disorders

The Loss of Autonomy in Eating Disorder Treatment: A Patient Perspective

Balancing Objective Markers and Subjective Experience in Eating Disorder Diagnoses: Commentary on Dang et al. (2024)

An open invitation to productive conversations about feminism and the spectrum of eating disorders (part 1): basic principles of feminist approaches

Experiences of eating disorders from the perspectives of patients, family members and health care professionals: a meta-review of qualitative evidence syntheses

Navigating the ethical complexities of severe and enduring (longstanding) eating disorders: tools for critically reflective practice and collaborative decision-making

Not niche: eating disorders as an example in the dangers of over-specialisation: commentary, Downs

Supportive Interventions in Managing Eating Disorders: A Review of the Evolving Medical Professional Landscape

The need for more inclusive measurement to advance equity in eating disorders prevention

Students' perspectives from co-designed, lived experience eating disorders education: A qualitative inquiry

A call to action for more rigorous research on compassion‐focused interventions for eating disorders: Commentary on Paranjothy and Wade (2024)

Expanded perspectives: integrating clinicians’ insights for comprehensive patient-reported outcomes in value-based healthcare

"It's like building a new person": lived experience perspectives on eating disorder recovery processes

Eating disorders among queer and trans individuals: Implications for conceptualization, assessment, and treatment

Exploring biologically oriented precision mental health initiatives for the care of patients with eating disorders: A narrative review

Peer support for eating disorders in Canada: program user perspectives

New understandings meet old treatments: putting a contemporary face on established protocols

Philosophical and Ethical Underpinnings of the Medical Decision-Making Process: A Focus on Patient Values and Preferences

Considering patient narrative-based and medico-scientific epistemologies in framing psychiatric care

Beyond the numbers: reimagining healing with psychedelics for eating disorders

The Perspectives of Patients, Parents and Clinicians