The good, the bad and the ugly – a Swedish qualitative interview study about the landscape of meaning-imbued, exercise-related physical pain, as experienced by ‘normal’ gym-users

Pelle Pelters
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s12889-024-18623-6
IF: 4.5
2024-04-25
BMC Public Health
Abstract:Abstract Background The gym is a well-known place for health promoting or rehabilitating exercise whose availability to all is regarded significant for people’s personal health work and the public’s health. In this context, physical pain is usually discussed as something negative that people seek to dispose of. However, certain painful experiences appear to be an appreciated part of the gym experience. To investigate this seemingly contradictory landscape of meaning-imbued physical pain, the study aims to explore the different kinds of physical pain present at the gym and their significance for exercising, as experienced by ‘normal’ gym-users. Methods 24 semi-structured in-depth interviews with active, dedicated, reasonably healthy (= normal) adult gym-users have been analyzed using qualitative content analysis from a hermeneutical stance. Results Participants differentiate between three kinds of physical pain: the good pain of enhancement (often connected to muscle soreness and effort burn), the bad pain of impediment (primarily related to acute damage) and the composite, neutral pain of acceptance (potentially linked to all pains). Conclusion When pursuing the goal of personal health development, normal gym-users argue that exercising at the gym means to expose yourself to pain and to do so willingly, even longingly. Refusing to share this understanding may diminish people’s chances to occupy the gym space and, hence, reduce their chances to promote their health.
public, environmental & occupational health
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper primarily explores people's understanding and experience of different types of physical pain while exercising in a gym environment. The study aims to investigate the various types of physical pain encountered by regular gym-goers and their significance to exercise. ### Research Background - **Gym Culture**: Gyms are seen as important places for promoting health and are also symbols of a healthy lifestyle. They emphasize personalized fitness concepts and are closely associated with values such as youth, health, and beauty. - **Body Shaping**: In modern gym culture, people pursue not only muscle development but also overall body shaping to exhibit youth, vitality, health, and attractiveness. - **Swedish Gym Culture**: Although it has global characteristics, Swedish gym culture also shows some specific local features, such as the influence of gender equality concepts, with a higher proportion of women participating in fitness activities. ### Physical Activity and Pain - **Role of Pain**: In previous studies, pain is often seen as an obstacle to be overcome, but in the gym environment, pain also has its positive aspects. For example, muscle soreness is considered a sign of effective exercise. - **Research Gap**: Existing literature mostly focuses on pain experiences in body-building or extreme fitness environments, with less research on the pain experiences of regular gym-goers. ### Research Objectives - To explore the different types of physical pain experienced by regular gym-goers and their significance to exercise. - To extract different categories and meanings of pain from interview data through qualitative content analysis. ### Methodology - **Participants**: 24 active and healthy adult gym-goers, aged from 27 to 76. - **Data Collection**: Semi-structured in-depth interviews were conducted to explore participants' pain experiences in the gym. - **Data Analysis**: Qualitative content analysis was used to identify meaning units from the interview records and to code and categorize them. ### Summary of Results The study found that participants categorized pain into three types: 1. **Beneficial Pain** (such as muscle soreness and the burning sensation from intense training), which is usually associated with improvement and progress. 2. **Harmful Pain** (such as pain from acute injuries), which is seen as an obstacle and something to be avoided. 3. **Neutral Pain** (which may encompass all types of pain), which is accepted as part of the exercise but does not necessarily carry positive or negative emotional connotations. ### Conclusion The study reveals that regular gym-goers, in their pursuit of personal health development, are willing to actively face and even desire certain types of pain. Rejecting this perspective may reduce people's participation in the gym, thereby decreasing their opportunities to improve their health.