L ‐ band SAR backscatter sensitivity to forest structure in semi ‐ arid environments : biomass retrieval error analysis at plot level

K. Lowell,A. García-Martín,J. Walker,R. Panciera,M. Tanase
Abstract:highlights:  The utility of L‐band synthetic aperture radar (SAR) backscatter data for estimating above ground biomass (ABG) in low biomass conditions (<100 t ha ‐1) and for different species composition was studied.  A water cloud type model was used to assess the relationships between field measured biomass and observed backscatter. Moreover, the retrieval errors were studied by biomass intervals using common empirical and semi‐empirical models.  Strong relationships were found between aboveground biomass and SAR backscatter at all sites. For areas with biomass levels below 30 t ha ‐1 the retrieval errors were as much as 250% of ground measured values due to the significant influence of surface backscatter. The estimation error decreased with biomass, being as low as 30% for the 50‐100 t ha ‐1 intervals.  This study shows that retrieval accuracy of forest biomass from L‐band SAR backscatter is highly variable within the range of forest biomass considered. In particular, larger errors were observed at both ends of the sensitivity interval. Low biomass levels (< 30 t ha ‐1) covered most of the dynamic range of the observed backscatter, indicating retrieval limitations when surface backscatter contributions are not accounted for. Extended Abstract: Many authors have studied the relationships between above ground biomass (AGB) and radar backscatter (Lucas et al. 2010; Luckman 1998; Santoro et al. 2006). However, only few studies provided detailed information on the accuracy of biomass retrieval that can be achieved through inversion of current empirical and/or physical models. Frequently no information on the retrieval accuracy is given, or only an average estimation error is provided for the entire biomass range. Most of the time the retrieved ABG intervals are much larger when compared to the range of ABG where L‐band observations exhibit sufficient sensitivity (0‐100 t/ha). In addition, very limited information on the retrieval accuracy by biomass interval is available. Such information could have significant impacts when modeling carbon storage for regions characterized by different biomass levels. This paper assesses the backscatter relationships for semi‐arid forests characterized by average biomass levels well below the L‐band saturation point (100 t/ha). The main objective was to evaluate the retrieval errors by biomass intervals
Environmental Science
What problem does this paper attempt to address?