Abstract:This study considered the impact of data processing conditions on the task‐evoked modulatory effective connectivity (EC) using a stimulus–response compatibility task. Our study demonstrated that task‐evoked EC and parameter certainty were significantly impacted by the general linear model design and type of activation contrast as revealed by parametric empirical Bayes and Bayesian data comparison, respectively. Effective connectivity (EC) refers to directional or causal influences between interacting neuronal populations or brain regions and can be estimated from functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) data via dynamic causal modeling (DCM). In contrast to functional connectivity, the impact of data processing varieties on DCM estimates of task‐evoked EC has hardly ever been addressed. We therefore investigated how task‐evoked EC is affected by choices made for data processing. In particular, we considered the impact of global signal regression (GSR), block/event‐related design of the general linear model (GLM) used for the first‐level task‐evoked fMRI analysis, type of activation contrast, and significance thresholding approach. Using DCM, we estimated individual and group‐averaged task‐evoked EC within a brain network related to spatial conflict processing for all the parameters considered and compared the differences in task‐evoked EC between any two data processing conditions via between‐group parametric empirical Bayes (PEB) analysis and Bayesian data comparison (BDC). We observed strongly varying patterns of the group‐averaged EC depending on the data processing choices. In particular, task‐evoked EC and parameter certainty were strongly impacted by GLM design and type of activation contrast as revealed by PEB and BDC, respectively, whereas they were little affected by GSR and the type of significance thresholding. The event‐related GLM design appears to be more sensitive to task‐evoked modulations of EC, but provides model parameters with lower certainty than the block‐based design, while the latter is more sensitive to the type of activation contrast than is the event‐related design. Our results demonstrate that applying different reasonable data processing choices can substantially alter task‐evoked EC as estimated by DCM. Such choices should be made with care and, whenever possible, varied across parallel analyses to evaluate their impact and identify potential convergence for robust outcomes.

A cautionary tale on the effects of different covariance structures in linear mixed effects modeling of fMRI data

Experimental design modulates variance in BOLD activation: The variance design general linear model

Applications of multivariate modeling to neuroimaging group analysis: a comprehensive alternative to univariate general linear model

MULTIVARIATE VARYING COEFFICIENT MODEL FOR FUNCTIONAL RESPONSES

Selection of a Model of Cerebral Activity for fMRI Group Data Analysis

A Bayesian General Linear Modeling Approach to Cortical Surface fMRI Data Analysis

Analyzing asymmetry in brain hierarchies with a linear state-space model of resting-state fMRI data

Longitudinal regression of covariance matrix outcomes

Full Bayesian Modeling for fMRI Group Analysis

A whole‐brain modeling approach to identify individual and group variations in functional connectivity

A Conditional Granger Causality Model Approach for Group Analysis in Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging

Multivariate analysis of multimodal brain structure predicts individual differences in risk and intertemporal preference

Covariate-Dependent Clustering of Undirected Networks with Brain-Imaging Data

Impact of data processing varieties on DCM estimates of effective connectivity from task‐fMRI

Bayesian Varying-Effects Vector Autoregressive Models for Inference of Brain Connectivity Networks and Covariate Effects in Pediatric Traumatic Brain Injury

Reliability and comparability of human brain structural covariance networks

Complementary benefits of multivariate and hierarchical models for identifying individual differences in cognitive control

Transcriptomic and Macroscopic Architectures of Multimodal Covariance Network Reveal Molecular-Structural-Functional Co-alterations

Homogeneous-Multiset-CCA-Based Brain Covariation and Contravariance Connectivity Network Modeling

Multilevel testing of constraints induced by structural equation modeling in fMRI effective connectivity analysis: A proof of concept

Bayesian Modeling of Effective and Functional Brain Connectivity using Hierarchical Vector Autoregressions