Substrate Matters: Ionic Silver Alters Lettuce Growth, Nutrient Uptake, and Root Microbiome in a Hydroponics System

LaShelle Spencer,Blake Costine,Tesia Irwin,Anirudha Dixit,Cory Spern,Angie Diaz,Brittney Lozzi,Wenyan Li,Christina Khodadad,Trent Smith,Raymond Wheeler,Aubrie O’Rourke

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/microorganisms12030515

IF: 4.5

2024-03-04

Microorganisms

Abstract:Ionic silver (Ag+) is being investigated as a residual biocide for use in NASA spacecraft potable water systems on future crewed missions. This water will be used to irrigate future spaceflight crop production systems. We have evaluated the impact of three concentrations (31 ppb, 125 ppb, and 500 ppb) of ionic silver biocide solutions on lettuce in an arcillite (calcinated clay particle substrate) and hydroponic (substrate-less) growth setup after 28 days. Lettuce plant growth was reduced in the hydroponic samples treated with 31 ppb silver and severely stunted for samples treated at 125 ppb and 500 ppb silver. No growth defects were observed in arcillite-grown lettuce. Silver was detectable in the hydroponic-grown lettuce leaves at each concentration but was not detected in the arcillite-grown lettuce leaves. Specifically, when 125 ppb silver water was applied to a hydroponics tray, Ag+ was detected at an average amount of 7 μg/g (dry weight) in lettuce leaves. The increase in Ag+ corresponded with a decrease in several essential elements in the lettuce tissue (Ca, K, P, S). In the arcillite growth setup, silver did not impact the plant root zone microbiome in terms of alpha diversity and relative abundance between treatments and control. However, with increasing silver concentration, the alpha diversity increased in lettuce root samples and in the water from the hydroponics tray samples. The genera in the hydroponic root and water samples were similar across the silver concentrations but displayed different relative abundances. This suggests that ionic silver was acting as a selective pressure for the microbes that colonize the hydroponic water. The surviving microbes likely utilized exudates from the stunted plant roots as a carbon source. Analysis of the root-associated microbiomes in response to silver showed enrichment of metagenomic pathways associated with alternate carbon source utilization, fatty-acid synthesis, and the ppGpp (guanosine 3′-diphosphate 5′-diphosphate) stringent response global regulatory system that operates under conditions of environmental stress. Nutrient solutions containing Ag+ in concentrations greater than 31 ppb in hydroponic systems lacking cation-exchange capacity can severely impact crop production due to stunting of plant growth.

microbiology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the issue of using silver ions (Ag+) as a disinfectant in spacecraft drinking water systems and their effects on lettuce under hydroponic systems and growth conditions using bentonite substrates at different concentrations. Specifically, the study aims to determine at what concentration silver ion-treated water affects the growth, nutrient content, and rhizosphere microbial communities of space crops. By comparing the effects of silver ion-treated water at different concentrations (0 ppb, 31 ppb, 125 ppb, and 500 ppb) on lettuce, the study explores the mechanisms of silver ions in hydroponic systems and bentonite substrates and their impact on plant growth and microbial communities. The study found that under hydroponic conditions, even lower concentrations of silver ions significantly inhibited lettuce growth and affected its ability to absorb essential elements such as calcium, potassium, phosphorus, and sulfur. In contrast, in bentonite substrates, silver ions had no significant effect on lettuce growth and rhizosphere microbial communities. These results are of great significance for the optimization of crop production systems in future space missions.