Ethnic Identity Protects and Internalized Racism Harms Health and Coping in Asian Americans Following COVID-19 Discrimination: A Mixed-Methods Study

Emily R. Nhan,Aisha R. Williamson-Raun,Rachel Chan,Joyce P. Yang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s40615-024-02000-5

2024-04-24

Journal of Racial and Ethnic Health Disparities

Abstract:Mechanisms underlying the link between COVID-19 anti-Asian racial discrimination and psychological health are underexplored. This mixed-methods study examined the moderating effects of ethnic identity and internalized racism on the relationship between COVID discrimination and behavioral health outcomes among Asian Americans. We hypothesized that individuals with lower ethnic identity and higher internalized racism levels would demonstrate more adverse outcomes, including worsened psychological trauma and identity-avoidant behaviors, post-discrimination. Asian American participants ( N = 215) responded to a Qualtrics survey, including qualitative and quantitative questions on COVID-related racism experiences, ethnic identity, internalized racism, trauma, and other subsequent effects. For qualitative analysis, participants were sorted into four subgroups defined by low- and/or high-ethnic identity and internalized racism scores, and we explored themes in participant reports of identity-related coping effects after racism. We additionally used hierarchical multiple regression analyses to quantitatively assess the moderating impact of ethnic identity and internalized racism on the relationship between COVID discrimination and trauma. Analyses revealed no moderating effects from the two identity variables. However, qualitative analyses identified themes of identity-promoting and identity-avoidant behavioral responses, and moderation analyses revealed that ethnic identity had a main effect on mitigating racial trauma, while internalized racism exacerbated both racial trauma and PTSD levels. This study identified ethnic identity and internalized racism as underlying causes to behavioral health outcomes for Asian Americans. Results offer mental health providers serving Asian clients insight into identity-related influences to help optimize culturally appropriate interventions and support initiatives of identity promotion to foster community engagement for this population.

public, environmental & occupational health

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper aims to explore the impact of racial discrimination against Asian Americans on their mental health during the COVID-19 pandemic, with a focus on the roles of ethnic identity and internalized racism.

Specifically, the paper seeks to answer the following questions:
1. **How do ethnic identity and internalized racism affect the psychological trauma of Asian Americans facing racial discrimination?**
- The study hypothesizes that individuals with low ethnic identity and high levels of internalized racism may exhibit more severe psychological trauma and behaviors that avoid ethnic identity after experiencing racial discrimination.

2. **How does the mental health status of Asian Americans change after experiencing COVID-19-related racial discrimination?**
- The paper uses a mixed-methods approach (qualitative and quantitative) to assess the impact of ethnic identity and internalized racism on mental health behaviors.

3. **Can ethnic identity and internalized racism serve as potential protective or risk factors affecting the mental health of Asian Americans?**
- The results show that ethnic identity helps to alleviate racial trauma, while internalized racism exacerbates racial trauma and PTSD levels.

In summary, this study aims to fill the research gap regarding the mechanisms of mental health among Asian Americans, particularly the specific impact of ethnic identity and internalized racism on mental health in the context of the pandemic.