The Role of the Micronutrients ; Vitamin A , Vitamin B 12 , Iron , Zinc , Copper Levels of Children with Lower Respiratory Tract Infections

A. Kara,Cihangul Bayhan
Abstract:I read the article by Fidancı İ. et al. (1) “The Role of levels of Vitamin A, Vitamin B12, Iron, Zinc and Cooper in Lower Respiratory Tract Infections in Children” with great interest (1). Micronutrients are necessary for an effective immune system. These contribute to the natural defense system of the body through physical barrier support, provision of cellular immunity and antibody growth. Micronutrient deficiency causes sensitivity towards infections by pressurizing the patient’s immune response. Micronutrient deficiency is increased through the hindrance of their use as a result of the loss of food intake and increases in losses (2, 3). I would like to congratulate the authors for highlighting the deficiency of micronutrients in lower respiratory infections that are the important causes of morbidity and mortality in children especially in a developing country like Turkey. I would like to emphasize the following points in the article: 1. The importance of respiratory tract infections (LRTI) in children below 5 years old has been emphasized in the article. As the deficiency of micronutrients such as vitamin A, zinc (Zn), copper (Cu), iron (Fe) and vitamin B12 may trigger these infections, it was stated that the authors aimed to determine the level of these micronutrients in children with lower respiratory tract infections. For this purpose, it was stated that 98 children diagnosed with LRTI and 47 healthy children in the control group were included in the study. It was concluded that there were no differences between the patient and control groups regarding age and gender (1). I am of the opinion that it should be stated and statistically demonstrated whether there is a difference between the two groups regarding the anthropometric measurements and malnutrition assessment between the two groups as they will affect the micronutrient levels. 2. It was stated in the article that the vitamin A level and Fe level in the patient group was significantly lower in comparison to control group, and no significant difference was found between the two groups although the Zn level in the patient group was lower. Table 3 presents the statistical analysis through the average micronutrient levels between the two groups (1). I am of the opinion that it will be more appropriate to determine the limit level of micronutrients level and that it should be revealed whether there is a difference between the groups below this limit level (for instance, vitamin A deficiency exists/does not exist). Serum vitamin A level will be lower in the protein energy and zinc deficiency. Besides, as the retinol binding protein is a negative acute phase protein, the serum retinol level may be found lower during the infection (4). Therefore, I think that examining the micronutrient levels after the disease will contribute to the assessment of the definition of deficiency. Similarly, it is stated that the serum Zn level is not sensitive enough to demonstrate Zn deficiency, but measurements on the tissue level will produce more sensitive results (5). In conclusion, this study is important as it highlights the deficiency of micronutrient levels in children with LRTI. However, I am of the opinion that future prospective randomized controlled LRTI studies will help us to be better informed about the micronutrient support in LRTIs.
Medicine
What problem does this paper attempt to address?