Comparison of ML Algorithms and Neural Networks on Fault Diagnosis of a Worm Gear

Narendiranath Babu Thamba,Vinay Teja Vanapalli,Rama Prabha Duraiswamy,Nikesh Sonnathi,Sai Sandeep Illuri
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s42417-023-01256-1
2024-01-28
Journal of Vibration Engineering & Technologies
Abstract:PurposeOur main aim is to examine worm gearbox vibration analysis in order to find flaws. To do the vibration study, an experimental setup was created. Induced defects of various kinds occurred in the gearbox. For various defects in the gearbox, the vibration analysis was performed. The worm gearbox problems were automatically detected by artificial neural networks (ANN). From the result, when compared to other ML algorithms such as Support Vector Machine (SVM), Decision tree, Kernel Neural Networks (KNN), Random Forest, the Artificial Neural Networks (ANN) provides more accurate results.MethodsIn this work, we examined the performance of several machine learning models and ANN by training each model with the same data. Following the feature selection process, we have the necessary features for model training. In contrast, we are training four machine learning models and one artificial neural network.ResultsComparison of various Machine learning algorithms between the accuracy and training time of the models were studied. These training times may change based on computation resources. Based on this study we infer that ANN model is best approach to detect gear faults.ConclusionWe trained four machine learning models and one ANN model for gear fault detection. The simple workflow for using these models is to take the time domain and frequency signals for the gearbox and calculate 6 statistical parameters and provide these parameters to pre-trained models and then the model will identify the defect. All the models show the potential of identifying gearbox faults with great accuracy. In all cases classification accuracy of mechanical looseness was 100%. From the outputs of all models, we can find that the ANN has the highest accuracy and Decision Tree has the least accuracy. Decision tree is a computation intensive model. Based on the results we can say that ANN is the best model for classification because ANN models tend to get more accurate with more data.
engineering, mechanical,mechanics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?