A Revised Picture Fuzzy Linguistic Aggregation Operator and Its Application to Group Decision-Making

Xue-yang Zhang,Jing Wang,Jian-qiang Wang,Jun-hua Hu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12559-020-09728-2
IF: 4.89
2020-08-15
Cognitive Computation
Abstract:The complexity of decision environments poses challenges for individuals engaged in decision-making proceedings. Picture fuzzy linguistic sets (PFLSs) are an effective tool for depicting the inherent subjective nature of human cognition. Aiming for the promotion of a general theory on PFLSs, we conduct a critical research to identify some limitations of a recent publication in Cognitive Computation [2018, 10(2), 242–259]. This published article is a meaningful and interesting study that initiates the PFLS as well as introduces the corresponding operations and the Archimedean picture fuzzy linguistic weighted arithmetic averaging operator. Unfortunately, we have carefully analyzed these operations and found that they may not be appropriate to all situations within picture fuzzy linguistic environment, which would result in the violation of human cognition. To eliminate this limitation, we explore and suggest novel operational laws and an aggregation operator for PFLSs from a modified version, so as to support further study on picture fuzzy linguistic group decision-making. Furthermore, a comparative and illustrative example is presented to validate the advantages of our modified operations. <a href="http://dict.cnki.net/dict_source.aspx?searchword=towardly">Towardly</a>, the research outcome will be of significant benefit to promoting the development of picture fuzzy linguistic decision-making theory. Accordingly, our contribution to improving the current research on PFLSs makes their application in solving realistic problems feasible and practical.
computer science, artificial intelligence,neurosciences
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper attempts to address the issue that in the decision-making process under a picture fuzzy linguistic environment, existing operational rules (especially addition and multiplication operations) have certain limitations. These limitations may lead to calculation results that do not align with human cognition, thereby affecting the effectiveness and accuracy of decisions. Specifically, the paper points out the following issues: 1. **Limitations of existing addition operations**: In certain special value cases, existing addition operations may not correctly reflect the actual opinions of decision-makers, leading to calculation results that lose practical significance. For example, when the support, neutrality, or opposition of some members are at extreme values, existing addition operations may produce meaningless results. 2. **Limitations of existing multiplication operations**: Existing multiplication operations do not fully consider the rationality of two extreme cases, which may lead to calculation results that exceed the basic conditions of PFLN, violating the closure of operations. 3. **Inadaptability of existing operations**: Existing operational rules may not meet the needs of all situations when dealing with complex and fuzzy decision information, limiting the development and application of picture fuzzy linguistic decision theory. To overcome these issues, the paper proposes new operational rules and an improved picture fuzzy linguistic weighted arithmetic average (PFLWAA) operator to better support group decision-making in a picture fuzzy linguistic environment. These new operational rules and operators can more accurately reflect human cognition and improve the flexibility and practicality of the decision-making process.