Abstract:If we are to use electronic plagiarism detectors on student work, it would be interesting to know how much similarity should be expected in independently written documents on a similar topic. If our measure is coarse, the answer should be zero, but a finer grained analysis (such as would be needed to detect inadequate paraphrasing) is likely to detect some background noise. How much background noise should there be? We would like to determine this, but it is hard to publish research based on analysis of student work, because we cannot know whether any particular pair of students worked completely independently or not, and in any case the results might attract unwelcome publicity. To get an estimate of an appropriate level of this background noise, we analysed submissions to an international conference using the Ferret plagiarism detector developed by Lyon et al. (2001). Ferret provides very fast and fine-grained similarity detection in moderately large collections of documents. This was an exercise intra-corporal or collusion detection rather than comparison to Web sources. For this purpose the Ferret algorithm is well suited. There were 483 files; scanning the files took about 50 seconds, and calculating the similarity statistics took about 10 seconds. There were 116403 file pairs. Of these pairs, only 116 (0.1%) had more than 99 common triples, and of these only 19 pairs (0.016% of the total) had over 200 matching triples (200 is about 10% of the typical size of the smaller files). There should be NO plagiarism here, as these are published conference papers, but in fact the top few are all pairs of papers with common authors, and they have re-used text. A simple MS Word file compare between one of the top ranking pairs is sufficient to make the similarities obvious (though Word does not highlight all the similarities by any means). Nevertheless, as expected, most document pairs showed very low similarity measures, and this was consistent across the vast majority of pairs. As noted, there was a surprisingly large degree of similarity in just a few cases. We accordingly investigated these pairs more carefully. The worst case was of an author who had submitted two papers. Each paper reported the results of a single experiment, but the background material for both experiments was very much the same and he had simply reproduced the same text in both papers. We present also the other cases where similarity was high, and ponder the implications for routine scanning of student work.

SIMILARITY COMPARISON APPLICATIONS BETWEEN DOCUMENT USING JARO Winkler DISTANCE algorithm TO DETECT SCIENTIFIC WRITING PLAGIARISM IN GUNADARMA UNIVERSITY

Anti Plagiarism Application with Algorithm Karp-Rabin at Thesis in Gunadarma University

Comparison of document similarity measurements in scientific writing using Jaro-Winkler Distance method and Paragraph Vector method

Similarity detection design using Winnowing Algorithm as an effort to apply green computing

Similarity Check to Detect Text Data Plagiarism

The Hybrid of Jaro-Winkler and Rabin-Karp Algorithm in Detecting Indonesian Text Similarity

The Effectiveness of Plagiarism Checker Implementation in Scientific Writing for Vocational High School

Plagiarism Detection on Electronic Text based Assignments using Vector Space Model (ICIAfS14)

DocCompare: An Approach to Prevent the Problem of Character Injection in Document Similarity Algorithm

Detection of Plagiarism in Students' Programs Using a Data Mining Algorithm

The Struggle with Academic Plagiarism: Approaches based on Semantic Similarity

Automatic Detection of Plagiarism in Writing

Source-code Similarity Detection and Detection Tools Used in Academia

Text similarity in academic conference papers

Using Sentence Similarity Measure for Plagiarism Detection of Arabic Documents

Features Based Text Similarity Detection

THE PLAGIARISM CHECKER USING MACHINE LEARNING

Detecting Similar Repositories On Github

Measuring the Level of Plagiarism of Thesis using Vector Space Model and Cosine Similarity Methods

Design and Implementation Plagiarism Checker Application with DetectGPT using Scheduler Algorithm

Design and Implementation of Code Plagiarism Detection System