Does the Environmental Regulation Intensity and ESG Performance Have a Substitution Effect on the Impact of Enterprise Green Innovation: Evidence from China

Fengyang Wang,Ziyuan Sun
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph19148558
IF: 4.614
2022-07-01
International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health
Abstract:Against the background of green and sustainable development strategy, it is an effective way to carry out green innovation to cope with the increasing intensity of government environmental regulation for enterprises. Nevertheless, the regulatory role of ESG performance has been ignored. Based on panel data from Chinese listed companies from 2010 to 2019, this paper mainly studies whether the environmental regulation intensity and ESG performance have a substitution effect on the impact of green innovation by constructing a double fixed effect model. The empirical results showed that first, positive ESG performance is conducive to promoting green innovation. Second, there is a U-shaped relationship between the intensity of environmental regulation and high-quality green innovation, which reflects the effect of “offset before compensation”. With the increasing intensity of environmental regulation, high-quality green innovation tends to crowd out low-quality green innovation, which further improves the practical test of the “Porter Hypothesis”. Third, the positive ESG performance showed a negative regulatory effect between environmental regulation intensity and enterprise green innovation, which means that environmental regulation intensity and ESG performance have a substitution effect, and the effect is heterogeneous in different enterprises. This paper makes a beneficial exploration on how environmental regulation intensity and ESG performance affect enterprise green innovation, and demonstrates the regulatory role of ESG performance between environmental regulation intensity and green innovation, which reveals the impact of macro environmental policies on the green innovation behavior of micro subjects, and contributes to the further improvement of ESG concept and green innovation theory.
Environmental Science,Economics,Medicine
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problems that this paper attempts to solve are: 1. **The relationship between environmental regulation intensity and corporate green innovation**: Research on the impact of environmental regulation intensity on green innovation, especially whether this impact shows a U - shaped relationship. That is, in the early stage of environmental regulation, enterprises may reduce their investment in green innovation due to increased costs. However, as the regulation intensity further increases, enterprises will invest more in green innovation to cope with higher environmental costs. 2. **The impact of ESG performance on corporate green innovation**: Explore whether the environmental, social and governance (ESG) performance of enterprises has a positive promoting effect on corporate green innovation. 3. **The moderating role of ESG performance**: Analyze whether ESG performance plays a substitution effect between environmental regulation intensity and corporate green innovation. That is, whether enterprises with better ESG performance can better cope with the pressure of environmental regulation, thereby reducing their dependence on high - level environmental regulation. Specifically, the paper hypothesizes: - **Hypothesis 1a (H1a)**: The impact of environmental regulation intensity on green innovation shows a U - shaped relationship, reflecting the "first offset then compensation" effect. - **Hypothesis 1b (H1b)**: There is a U - shaped relationship between environmental regulation intensity and high - quality green innovation. - **Hypothesis 1c (H1c)**: As the environmental regulation intensity increases, low - quality green innovation gradually decreases. - **Hypothesis 2 (H2)**: Under the same other conditions, positive ESG performance is conducive to promoting green innovation. - **Hypothesis 3 (H3)**: ESG performance has a negative moderating effect on the impact of environmental regulation and green innovation. That is, there is a substitution effect between environmental regulation intensity and ESG performance, which jointly promotes green innovation. By constructing a two - fixed - effects model, the paper uses the panel data of Chinese listed companies from 2010 to 2019 to empirically test the above hypotheses and draw corresponding conclusions. These conclusions not only help to understand how environmental regulation and ESG performance affect corporate green innovation, but also provide references for the government to formulate precise environmental regulation policies.