Exploiting blood-based biomarkers to align preclinical models with human traumatic brain injury
Ilaria Lisi,Federico Moro,Edoardo Mazzone,Niklas Marklund,Francesca Pischiutta,Firas Kobeissy,Xiang Mao,Frances Corrigan,Adel Helmy,Fatima Nasrallah,Valentina Di Pietro,Laura B Ngwenya,Luis V Portela,Bridgette D Semple,Andrea L C Schneider,Ramon Diaz Arrastia,David K Menon,Douglas H Smith,Cheryl Wellington,David J Loane,Kevin Wang,Elisa R Zanier,the InTBIR Fundamental and Translational Working Group,Elham Abbasloo,Avinash Agrawal,Mehwish Anwer,Chidozie Anyaegbu,Karen Caeyenberghs,Lyndsey Collins,Frances Corrigan,Gill Cowen,Luis V Portela,Jennifer Cullen,Bernadette D'Alonzo,Valentina Di Pietro,Christopher Dirk Keene,Michael Esser,Sho Giersztein,Adel Helmy,Stuart Hoffman,Diego Iacono,Ruchira Jha,Victoria E Johnson,Jijo Stebin Justus,Christopher Dirk Keene,Brittney Lins,Spencer W Liebel,David Loane,Xiang Mao,Niklas Marklund,Michael McCrea,Declan McGuone,Abdalla Mohamed,Federico Moro,Richelle Mychasiuk,Gurueswar Nagarajan,Fatima Nasrallah,Peter Ngum,Laura B Ngwenya,Rockefeller Oteng,Anit Parihar,James Phillips,Francesca Pischiutta,Shantanu Prakash,Chiara Robba,Elham Rostami,Francesco Roselli,Bridgette Semple,Sandy Shultz,Doug Smith,Hailong Song,Marco Stefani,William Stewart,Ragini Verma,Kevin K Wang,Cheryl Wellington,Brent Winston,Elisa R Zanier
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/brain/awae350
IF: 14.5
2024-11-10
Brain
Abstract:Rodent models are important research tools for studying the pathophysiology of traumatic brain injury (TBI) and developing new therapeutic interventions for this devastating neurological disorder. However, the failure rate for the translation of drugs from animal testing to human treatments for TBI is 100%. While there are several potential explanations for this, previous clinical trials have relied on extrapolation from preclinical studies for critical design considerations, including drug dose optimization, post-injury drug treatment initiation and duration. Incorporating clinically relevant biomarkers in preclinical studies may provide an opportunity to calibrate preclinical models to identical (or similar) measurements in humans, link to human TBI biomechanics and pathophysiology, and guide therapeutic decisions. To support this translational goal, we conducted a systematic literature review of preclinical TBI studies in rodents measuring blood levels of clinically used GFAP, UCH-L1, NfL, t-Tau, or p-Tau, published in PubMed/EMBASE up to April 10th, 2024. Although many factors influence clinical TBI outcomes, many of those cannot routinely be assessed in rodent studies (e.g., ICP monitoring), thus we focused on blood biomarkers' temporal trajectories and discuss our findings in the context of the latest clinical TBI biomarker data. Out of the 805 original preclinical studies, 74 met the inclusion criteria, with a median quality score of 5 (25th-75th percentiles: 4-7) on the CAMARADES checklist. GFAP was measured in 43 studies, UCH-L1 in 21, NfL in 20, t-Tau in 19, and p-Tau in seven. Data in rodent models indicate that all biomarkers exhibited injury severity-dependent elevations with distinct temporal profiles. GFAP and UCH-L1 peaked within the first day after TBI (30- and 4-fold increases, respectively, in moderate-to-severe TBI versus sham) with the highest levels observed in the contusion TBI model. NfL peaked within days (18-fold increase) and remained elevated up to 6 months post-injury. GFAP and NfL show a pharmacodynamic response in 64.7% and 60%, respectively, of studies evaluating neuroprotective therapies in preclinical models. However, GFAP's rapid decline post-injury may limit its utility for understanding the response to new therapeutics beyond the hyperacute phase after experimental TBI. Furthermore, as in humans, subacute NfL levels inform on chronic white matter loss after TBI. t-Tau and p-Tau levels increased over weeks after TBI (up to 6- and 16-fold, respectively); however, their relationship with underlying neurodegeneration has yet to be addressed. Further investigation into biomarker levels in the subacute and chronic phases after TBI will be needed to fully understand the pathomechanisms underpinning blood biomarkers' trajectories and select the most suitable experimental model to optimally relate preclinical mechanistic studies to clinical observations in humans. This new approach could accelerate the translation of neuroprotective treatments from laboratory experiments to real-world clinical practices.
neurosciences,clinical neurology