Comparative Study of Cultural Landscape Perception in Historic Districts from the Perspectives of Tourists and Residents

Siyu Jiang,Jiang Liu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/land13030353

IF: 3.905

2024-03-10

Land

Abstract:From a human-centric perspective, improving the spatial quality of historical districts is a key focus in achieving their refined governance. Based on a public survey performed in Zhangzhou Ancient City, we explored the differences in the perception of cultural landscape genes (CLGs) between residents and tourists with different individual characteristics, utilizing non-parametric tests and box-plot analysis methods. The findings indicate the following: Tourists have a stronger perception of CLGs related to site layout and architectural features than residents, while residents have a stronger perception of cultural customs. Gender-related differences in the perception of CLG are only significant among tourists, with females showing a higher level of CLG perception than males. Residents of different age groups show a "U-shaped" distribution in their perception of CLGs related to site layout, whereas senior tourists have a lower cognitive perception level. People with lower educational backgrounds among residents tend to perceive cultural customs more significantly, whereas tourists with diverse educational backgrounds do not perceive them as having a significant impact. Residence location, visit frequency, duration of residence, and residence nature are key positive factors affecting the perception of CLGs. Our study highlights the significance of considering the users' characteristics in enhancing the refined governance of historical districts.

environmental studies

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper discusses the differences in the perception of cultural landscape genes (CLGs) in historic districts from the perspectives of tourists and residents, based on a public survey in the ancient city of Zhangzhou, Fujian. Non-parametric tests and boxplot analysis methods were used to explore the differences in perception of CLGs among residents and tourists with different individual characteristics (such as gender, age, and education background). The study found that tourists have a stronger perception of CLGs related to site layout and architectural features, while residents have a more significant perception of cultural customs. In addition, factors such as gender, age, and education background affect the perception of CLGs by tourists and residents.

The research focuses on the following questions:
1. What are the differences in CLG perception between tourists and residents in historic districts?
2. How do social/demographic/behavioral characteristics affect the differences in CLG perception between tourists and residents?

The study aims to provide theoretical basis for the fine governance of historic districts from a people-oriented perspective, emphasizing the importance of considering user characteristics in improving residents' well-being and tourists' satisfaction. The paper also reviews the theory of cultural landscape genes, studies on individual factors, and relevant literature on the perception of historic districts. The research methods include an overview of the case study site - Zhangzhou Ancient City, the identification and evaluation of CLGs, as well as the use of questionnaire surveys and statistical analysis.