Abstract:A core part of the international response to the financial crisis has been the adoption of a requirement to clear standardized swaps. Clearing extinguishes the original transaction, creating two identical transactions between the counterparties to the original trade and a central counterparty, usually referred to as a clearinghouse. The clearing mandate represents a significant intervention into derivatives markets. The net present value of cash flows due under outstanding instruments of the types subject to the clearing mandate rivals the U.S. gross domestic product. Policymakers have justified the clearing mandate as a mitigant of systemic risk. Scholarship, however, has challenged this justification arguing that the rerouting of payment flows through clearinghouses exacerbates systemic risk. This article adds to the debate, by examining how the clearing mandate affects trading behavior and how those changes affect systemic risk. Trading behavior will be altered by the clearing mandate through four pathways: • Greater costs of transacting under the clearing mandate reduce swap volumes. The net result of these reductions on systemic risk is uncertain. The reduction could decrease net transfers of risk into the financial system, and in particular, to major financial institutions that act as swap dealers. Alternately, the reduction could disproportionately affect hedging by the financial industry, trapping more risk within the financial system. • Attempts to evade the clearing mandate, as well as attempts to avoid being penalized under the anti-evasion provisions undergirding the mandate, will lead to less standardized documentation. As a result, documentation will become more customized and opaque, decreasing transparency and potentially increasing risk. • The interposition of clearinghouses will reduce behavior that exacerbates systemic risk during a crisis. In particular, transactions that are cleared will not set off cascades of attempts to assign and novate obligations, thus reducing the prompts for panic. Furthermore, transactions that are cleared can be unwound during a crisis without involvement of the initial counterparty thus enabling continued risk management throughout a crisis. • Clearing is a predicate to reducing systemic risk through disintermediating swaps markets. Clearing allows natural longs, natural shorts and other market participants to transact directly through execution platforms’ order books without using swap dealers to intermediate the flow of risk in the economy. Subject to sufficient liquidity being available in the market, clearing enables market participants to transact on dependable credit terms directly without the use of financial intermediaries. These observations lead to a reassessment of the clearing mandate, and identify new lines of research to pursue in evaluating the desirability of the regulations that have transformed swaps markets over the last five years.

Unintended Consequences of the Global Derivatives Market Reform

Transnationalism and Financial Regulation Change: A Case of Derivative Markets

Why Are the Prices of European‐style Derivatives Greater Than the Prices of American‐style Derivatives?

The demand for central clearing: To clear or not to clear, that is the question!

Compressing Over-the-Counter Markets

Financial regulatory arbitrage and the financialization of commodities

Innovation and deadlock in global financial governance: transatlantic coordination failure in OTC derivatives regulation

A Reassessment of the Clearing Mandate: How the Clearing Mandate Affects Swap Trading Behavior and the Consequences for Systemic Risk

The Network of Counterparty Risk: Analysing Correlations in OTC Derivatives

Central Counterparties in the OTC Derivatives Market from the Perspective of the Legal Theory of Finance, Financial Market Stability and the Public Good

Currency Mispricing and Dealer Balance Sheets

Derivatives Do Affect Mutual Fund Returns: Evidence from the Financial Crisis of 1998

The Impact of Macroeconomic Risk Factors, the Adoption of Financial Derivatives on Working Capital Management, and Firm Performance

Arbitrage Opportunities in CDS Term Structure: Theory and Implications for OTC Derivatives

Consumer protection and firm valuation: A study of overdraft protection and US banks

Don't move my cheese: Financial advice adaptation to regulatory change

Domesticating Foreign Finance

Structural Shifts on Derivatives Markets at the Time of Increasing Digitalization and Post-pandemic Transformation of the Market

Intraday Liquidity and Money Market Dislocations∗

Global Risk, Non-Bank Financial Intermediation, and Emerging Market Vulnerabilities

An Exploration of the Risk Management of Financial Derivatives in Chinese Commercial Banks