Tobacco control policy and regulation from diverse perspectives and contexts

Hefler,M.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/tc-2024-058662
IF: 6.953
2024-03-19
Tobacco Control
Abstract:This issue brings together studies providing different perspectives of tobacco regulation and policy for cigarettes, heated tobacco products (HTPs), waterpipe tobacco, e-cigarettes and other products. Taxation is cost-effective for governments while reducing smoking prevalence. Ngo et al provide evidence for the underused potential of this policy lever.1 Using the Tobacconomics scorecard and drawing on 2014-2020 data, they show that modest improvement in tax policy scores globally reduced cigarette consumption by 3.27%, but this could have been reduced by 20.74% with optimal tax policies. Low-income and middle-income countries stood to gain even more, with the potential to reduce consumption by 28.05%. In contrast to cigarettes, waterpipe tobacco taxes are under-researched. Jawad et al address this by modelling waterpipe taxes for Jordan, Lebanon and Palestine.2 They highlight the need for context specific modelling, noting that waterpipe smoking in cafes has a high industry mark-up which reduces the...
public, environmental & occupational health,substance abuse
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to explore the effects of tobacco control policies and regulations from multiple perspectives and their application in different global contexts. Specifically, the paper covers the following aspects: 1. **Tax Policies**: - The paper analyzes the effects of tax policies in reducing tobacco consumption, particularly the potential impact on low- and middle-income countries. The study indicates that a moderate increase in tobacco taxes can significantly reduce smoking rates and generate additional revenue for governments. 2. **Waterpipe Taxation**: - The research explores the current status and potential impact of waterpipe taxation, especially in places like Jordan, Lebanon, and Palestine. The study shows that increasing waterpipe taxes can not only increase government revenue but also reduce premature deaths. 3. **Relationship Between Tobacco Prices and Smoking Rates**: - By analyzing data from eight sub-Saharan African countries, the research finds that tobacco prices are the only significant policy predictor affecting smoking rates and smoking intensity. Research in Vietnam also supports this view, indicating that raising tobacco prices can reduce smoking rates among young people, but has limited effect on quitting among existing smokers. 4. **Comprehensive Tobacco Control Policies**: - The research emphasizes the importance of policy enforcement, noting that even with strict smoke-free laws, poor enforcement can lead to high violation rates. Additionally, the study explores the effectiveness of tobacco advertising bans and the methods tobacco companies use to circumvent these bans. 5. **Heated Tobacco Products (HTPs) and E-cigarettes**: - The paper analyzes the impact of the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) authorization of heated tobacco products and e-cigarettes on consumer perception, and how these authorizations are used to oppose comprehensive bans in certain regions. The study points out the need for stronger regulation of these products to prevent misleading advertising. 6. **Menthol Tobacco Products**: - The research explores the regulatory challenges of menthol tobacco products, including potential substitutes like menthol cigarettes and e-cigarettes, and their usage in different markets. 7. **Other Nicotine-Related Products**: - The paper also discusses the regulatory challenges of other nicotine products, such as nicotine pouches and tobacco-free cigarette papers, which are difficult to classify within existing product categories but may need to be included in regulatory frameworks. Overall, this paper aims to provide policymakers with multi-faceted evidence and recommendations to help them more effectively regulate the tobacco industry and its products, thereby reducing tobacco consumption and associated health risks.