Abstract:The thermodynamically stable phases of salicylic acid (SA) and 2,3-dihydroxybenzoic acid (23DHBA) have been determined experimentally in a T-X phase diagram from 25 °C to melting and in a ternary phase diagram with a solvent at 25 °C. Three crystalline solid solution (CSS) phases were obtained of which two belonged to two polymorphs of 23DHBA. The solid-state miscibility of SA was determined to be 0.9 mol % 23DHBA, whereas the solvus of Form II of 23DHBA was estimated to be around 22 mol % SA, at 25 °C. The CSS formation resulted in a thermodynamic coexistence domain where the two polymorphs of 23DHBA coexist indefinitely at all investigated temperatures up to the peritectic isotherm. A polymorphic stability shift is also in effect across a larger portion of the phase diagram at a higher content of SA. In this region, Form II of 23DHBA, which is metastable and largely inaccessible when chemically pure, is thermodynamically more stable than Form I. The underlying reason for the thermodynamic stability transitions is explained and conceptualized through the solvent solubilities of the corresponding CSS phases of 23DHBA and SA measured in 40 w% MeOH in H2O at 25 °C. This example negates surface adsorption as the underlying mechanism for stabilizing “metastable” polymorphs in the presence of structurally similar additives or impurities. In addition, two novel crystal forms were found and their crystal structures were resolved, showing an anhydrous polymorph and a hydrate of 23DHBA. Implications for chemical and pharmaceutical development are discussed.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper mainly discusses the thermodynamic stability transition and coexistence between two crystalline forms, salicylic acid (SA) and 2,3-dihydroxybenzoic acid (23DHBA), as well as their behavior in the crystalline solid solution (CSS) in the T-X phase diagram from 25°C to melting point. The influence of solvent in the ternary phase diagram is also considered by the researchers. They discovered three CSS phases, two of which belong to different polymorphs of 23DHBA. The solubility of SA in the solid state is determined to be 0.9 mol%, while the solubility limit of 23DHBA form II is approximately 22 mol%, both at 25°C. The formation of CSS results in a thermodynamic coexistence region, where both polymorphs of 23DHBA coexist indefinitely at all investigated temperatures. The study also reveals a polymorphic stability transfer, where 23DHBA form II (normally metastable and difficult to obtain in chemically pure state) is thermodynamically more stable than form I when the SA content is higher. The reason for this thermodynamic stability transition is explained by measuring the solvent solubility of the respective CSS in 40% methanol-water solution at 25°C. The paper indicates that surface adsorption is not the underlying mechanism for stabilizing the "metastable" polymorph, but rather a result of CSS formation. Furthermore, the researchers have discovered and analyzed two new crystal structures of 23DHBA, one being an anhydrous polymorph and the other being a hydrate. The paper discusses the implications of these findings for chemical and pharmaceutical development, including the importance of drug solubility, release, and bioavailability, and emphasizes the significance of understanding the role of CSS in purification processes and controlling impurities for improving drug quality. In conclusion, this paper addresses the thermodynamic stability of organic compound solid mixtures, particularly in pharmaceutical chemistry, and provides new insights into controlling polymorphic stability and purity.

Thermodynamic Stability Transitions and Coexistence of Two Polymorphs via Crystalline Solid Solutions: The T-X Phase Diagram of Salicylic Acid and 2,3-Dihydroxybenzoic Acid

Polymorphic Stability Shifts, Co-Crystals, and Crystalline Solid Solutions: The T-X Phase Diagram of Salicylic Acid–Salicylamide

Impurity-induced Acceleration of Polymorphic Conversion via Crystalline Solid Solutions and the T-X Phase Diagrams of Salicylic acid and 3-Hydroxybenzoic acid

Thermal analysis, structure, spectroscopy and DFT calculations of a pharmaceutical cocrystal of salicylic acid and salicylamide

X-Ray Diffraction and Theoretical Calculation-Supported Formation of Polymorphic Cocrystals Discovered Through Thermal Methods: A Case Study

Investigation of the solubility and thermodynamics of salicylic acid in 2-propanol and ethylene glycol/propylene glycol binary solvent mixtures at (293.15 to 313.15) K

Ternary phase diagram and investigation of slurry conversion of 1:1 sulfamethazine-acetylsalicylic acid cocrystal

Fundamental theoretical and practical investigations of the polymorph formation of small amphiphilic molecules, their co-crystals and salts

Solubility Determination and Modelling of Benzamide in Organic Solvents at Temperatures from 283.15 K and 323.15 K, and Ternary Phase Diagrams of Benzamide-Benzoic Acid Cocrystals in Ethanol at 298.15 K

Understanding the Polymorphic Behavior of Sibenadet Hydrochloride through Detailed Studies Integrating Structural and Dynamical Assessment

Crystallization from solution versus mechanochemistry to obtain double-drug multicomponent crystals of ethacridine with salicylic/acetylsalicylic acids

Solvent dependent 4-aminosalicylic acid-sulfamethazine co-crystal polymorph control

Solvent Induced Crystallization and Phase Transition of Syndiotactic Polymethoxystyrene Investigated Using In Situ Wide Angle X-ray Diffraction

Thermodynamic Investigation of Carbamazepine-Saccharin Co-Crystal Polymorphs

Simultaneous XRD-DSC identifies correct drug-polymer solubility and miscibility for enantiotropic solid forms

Crystal chemistry and solvent effects in polymorphic systems Sulfathiazole

Structural and therapeutic properties of salicylic acid solubilized Pluronic solutions & hydrogels

Comparative Studies On The Crystalline To Fluid Phase Transitions Of Two Equimolar Cationic/Anionic Surfactant Mixtures Containing Dodecylsulfonate And Dodecylsulfate

Crystal Structures and Binary Molten Solid–Liquid Equilibria of tert -Butylmethylphenol Isomers

Studying thermodynamic aspects of sublimation, solubility and solvation processes and crystal structure analysis of some sulfonamides

New Insights into the Crystallographic Disorder in the Polymorphic Forms of Aspirin from Low-Frequency Vibrational Analysis