Abstract:Most on-farm diversification strategies to enhance ecosystem services, such as insect pest control and yield, have focused on expanding crop species diversity. While polycultures often provide valuable services, logistical constraints with planting and harvesting can hamper implementation on large scales. An alternative diversification strategy is to increase within-field intraspecific crop diversity through the use of crop varietal mixtures. Here, we evaluate an interdisciplinary body of research to determine the potential for crop varietal mixtures to support food security by providing ecological, economic, and nutritional services. Previous literature has synthesized the link between varietal mixtures and yield and insect pest suppression services. We expand on prior analyses by considering hypotheses generated from species-level research and assessing whether they also provide a useful framework for predicting how varietal mixtures affect crop productivity and insect pest suppression. In addition, we evaluate the potential for varietal mixtures to increase farm resilience and growers' profits. While there is a growing effort to quantify the economic value of ecosystem services provided by agrobiodiversity in terms of enhanced yield or revenue, much less attention has been given to quantifying the production costs associated with diversification schemes. Consequently, we know little about the effect of diversification practices on farm profitability, the metric of ultimate importance to farmers. We address this issue by evaluating the ability of varietal mixtures to reduce production costs associated with other types of agrobiodiversity and outline areas for future research to better understand the profit implications of varietal mixtures. Further, we review evidence that varieties of some crop species differ in phytochemical content—a functional trait important for insect pest suppression and human dietary diversity—suggesting that varietal mixtures could be designed to simultaneously support insect pest control and human nutrition services. Given that little research has explicitly addressed the capacity for varietal mixtures to support human nutrition, we outline predictions for where we would expect to see the greatest nutritional impact of mixtures, providing a foundation for future human nutrition research. Taken together, our review suggests that varietal mixtures are a promising and logistically feasible strategy that could simultaneously support multiple services.

Missing markets and crop diversity: evidence from Mexico

Do Wealth and Market Access Explain Inconsistent Relationships between Crop Diversity and Dietary Diversity? Evidence from 10 Sub-Saharan African Countries

A gap analysis modelling framework to prioritize collecting for ex situ conservation of crop landraces

Indigenous or Exotic Crop Diversity? Which Crops Ensure Household Food Security: Facts from Tanzania Panel

Agroecological management with intra- and interspecific diversification as an alternative to conventional soil nutrient management in family maize farming

Trade-off between market and ecosystem services drives settlement decisions among smallholder ranchers in Baja California Sur, Mexico

Eco-Symbiotic Complementarity and Trading Networks of Natural Resources in Nahua Communities in Mountain Regions of Mexico

Crop Diversity in Agroecosystems for Pest Management and Food Production

Genetic diversity and selection signatures in maize landraces compared across 50 years of in situ and ex situ conservation

Agrobiodiversity Conservation Policies: Insights from an Integrated Micro-macro Economic Model in Ethiopia

Planting Hybrids, Keeping Landraces: Agricultural Modernization and Tradition Among Small-Scale Maize Farmers in Chiapas, Mexico

Joint environmental and social benefits from diversified agriculture

Diverse approaches to crop diversification in agricultural research. A review

Multi-country evidence that crop diversification promotes ecological intensification of agriculture

Spatial Analysis of the Ecogeographic Diversity of Wild Creeping Cucumber (Melothria pendula L.) for In Situ and Ex Situ Conservation in Mexico

Crop diversification practices in Europe: an economic cross-case study comparison

Ecological and evolutionary effects of crop diversity decrease yield variability

Crop Varietal Mixtures as a Strategy to Support Insect Pest Control, Yield, Economic, and Nutritional Services

Unveiling Peru's Agricultural Diversity: Navigating Historical and Future Trends in a Post-COVID-19 Context

Different strategies of crop diversification between poor and non-poor farmers: Concepts and evidence from Tanzania

Reallocating crops raises crop diversity without changes to field boundaries and farm-level crop composition