Wind can reduce storage-induced emissions at grid scales

Mo Li,Yi Yang,Timothy M. Smith,Elizabeth J. Wilson
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apenergy.2020.115420
IF: 11.2
2020-10-01
Applied Energy
Abstract:<p>Energy storage provides many benefits that can improve electric grid performance but has been shown to increase overall system emissions. Yet, how energy storage might interreact with renewables in existing grids and how these interactions affect overall emissions remain unclear. Here, we estimate emissions induced by battery energy storage in two regions of the United States with very different levels of wind penetration using high-resolution, both spatially and temporally, locational marginal prices and hourly marginal emission factors. We find that the emission intensity of carbon dioxide, sulfur dioxide, nitrogen oxides, and mercury is 4264% lower in the high wind penetration grid (28%) than in the low wind penetration grid (&lt;5%). This is due in part to a significant share of wind dispatched as marginal fuel in baseload hours when battery storage charges from the grid, reducing storage-induced emissions. Our study suggests that more wind generation can favorably pair with storage and reduce the air pollution burdens otherwise caused by storage.</p>
energy & fuels,engineering, chemical
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper attempts to address the issue of how the interaction between large-scale grid energy storage systems and renewable energy (particularly wind energy) in the existing grid affects emissions caused by storage. Specifically, the study aims to evaluate the operating patterns of storage systems and their impact on emissions of pollutants such as carbon dioxide, sulfur dioxide, nitrogen oxides, and mercury in two U.S. grid regions with different wind energy penetration rates. ### Main Issues 1. **Role of Storage Systems in the Grid**: Storage technology can improve grid reliability, peak shaving, and facilitate the integration of renewable energy, but it does not produce emissions itself. However, the charging and discharging processes of storage systems are influenced by the fuel mix of the power system, which can indirectly lead to changes in emissions. 2. **Emission Differences Under Different Wind Energy Penetration Rates**: The study explores the role of wind energy in the charging and discharging processes of storage systems by simulating the deployment of storage systems in grids with high and low wind energy penetration rates, and how this role affects overall emissions. 3. **Marginal Emission Factors**: The study uses high-resolution locational marginal prices and hourly marginal emission factors to estimate the impact of storage systems' charging and discharging patterns on emissions at different times. ### Research Background - **Development of Storage Technology**: With the promotion of federal and state policies, the application of storage technology in the U.S. power system is becoming increasingly widespread. - **Focus on Emission Issues**: There is a growing global focus on reducing the health and climate impacts of power systems, but the impact of storage systems on overall emissions remains unclear. - **Dispatchability of Wind Energy**: Due to improvements in dispatch control systems, real-time forecasting technology, and changes in power market rules, the dispatchability of wind energy and other renewable energy sources in the grid has significantly increased. ### Research Methods - **Selection of Study Areas**: The study selected the North and Central regions of the Midcontinent Independent System Operator (MISO), which have similar generation fuel mixes but significantly different wind energy penetration rates (approximately 30% in the North and 5% in the Central region). - **Data Collection and Processing**: The study used high-resolution real-time locational marginal price data from 2015 to 2018 for the MISO North and Central regions. - **Storage Model and Optimization**: An optimization model was developed to simulate the revenue-maximizing operation mode of storage systems participating in the MISO real-time wholesale market. - **Estimation of Emission Factors**: Marginal emission factors were calculated using linear regression methods, and total emissions were estimated by combining these factors with the charging and discharging patterns of storage systems. ### Main Findings - **Charging and Discharging Patterns**: In both study regions, storage systems charge when electricity prices are low and discharge when prices are high, which typically corresponds to periods of low and high demand. - **Marginal Fuel Types**: Wind energy contributes significantly in the North region, while coal and natural gas are the main marginal fuels in the Central region. - **Emission Differences**: In the high wind energy penetration North region, emissions caused by storage systems are 42% to 64% lower than in the low wind energy penetration Central region. Specific reductions in pollutant emissions are: carbon dioxide 44%, sulfur dioxide 64%, nitrogen oxides 42%, and mercury 57%. ### Conclusion The study results indicate that high wind energy penetration can significantly reduce emissions caused by storage systems. This is mainly because wind energy serves as the marginal fuel during low load periods, reducing the use of high-emission fuels when storage systems charge. Therefore, increasing wind energy penetration can effectively mitigate the negative environmental impact of storage systems.