Abstract:Scope and purposeThe guideline addresses effective strategies for preventing and managing dental decay in the preschool child. The nature of dental decay, its diagnosis and its epidemiology are reviewed. Methods for prevention and management of the disease at an individual and population level are reviewed and identification of children at increased risk of developing dental disease is discussed.MethodologyThe guideline was synthesised following the SIGN methodology (see www.sign.ac.uk/guidelines/fulltext/50/index.html). Searches were devised in collaboration with members of the guideline-development group. Searches for guidelines used Embase and Medline for the period 1996–2003 and a range of websites. Searches for systematic reviews, meta-analyses, randomised controlled trials (RCT) and observational studies were carried out with the Cochrane library, Embase and Medline (1990–2003, with a final update in June 2004). The definitions of the types of evidence and the grading of recommendations used in this guideline originate from the US Agency for Health Care Policy and Research1 and are set out in Tables 1 and 2.Statements of evidenceIaEvidence obtained from meta-analysis of RCTIbEvidence obtained from at least one RCTIiaEvidence obtained from at least one well-designed controlled study without randomisationIibEvidence obtained from at least one other type of well-designed quasi-experimental studyIIIEvidence obtained from well-designed nonexperimental descriptive studies, such as comparative studies, correlation studies and case studiesIVEvidence obtained from expert committee reports or opinions and/or clinical experiences of respected authoritiesRCT, Randomised controlled trial.Grades of recommendationsARequires at least one RCT as part of a body of literature of overall good quality and consistency addressing the specific recommendation (evidence levels Ia, Ib)BRequires the availability of well-conducted clinical studies but no RCT on the topic of recommendation (evidence levels IIa, IIb, III)CRequires evidence obtained from expert committee reports or opinions and/or clinical experiences of respected authorities. Indicates an absence of directly applicable clinical studies of good quality (evidence level IV)GPPGood practice points: recommended best practice based on the clinical experience of the guideline development groupRCT, Randomised controlled trial.Review and updatingThe guideline was published in November 2005 and will be considered for updating in 3 years.Clinical recommendationsFor summary, see Table 3 below.Clinical recommendationsDiagnosisGPPAs thorough a caries diagnostic examination should be performed as the child's level of cooperation permitsDThe use of bitewing radiography for caries diagnosis should be considered for preschool children attending for dental care, particularly if they are assessed as being at increased risk of dental caries. The timing of subsequent radiographic examinations should be based on the individual's caries risk statusBCaries should be diagnosed as early as possible to allow management before cavitation and pulpal involvement, and to identify caries-active patients and those at increased risk of caries in the futureCPractitioners should receive training in clinical and radiographic caries diagnosisPredicting caries riskCA dental practice-based caries risk assessment should be carried out on individual preschool children and should include the following risk indicators: evidence of previous caries experience; resident in a deprived area; healthcare worker's opinion; oral mutans streptococci counts (if available)BChildren whose families live in a deprived area should be considered as at increased risk of early childhood caries when developing preventive programmesToothbrushing with fluorideAChildren should have their teeth brushed with fluoride toothpaste containing 1000 ppm (±10%) fluorideCChildren should have their teeth brushed, or be assisted with toothbrushing by an adult, at least twice a day, with a smear or pea-sized amount of fluoride toothpasteCToothbrushing should commence as soon as the primary teeth eruptAChildren should be encouraged to spit out excess toothpaste and not rinse with water post-brushingAChildren's teeth can be brushed with either manual or powered toothbrushesDiet and nutritionBPregnant women should be advised that there is no benefit to the child of taking fluoride supplements during pregnancyCMembers of the dental team should support and promote breastfeeding according to current recommendationsGPPParents and carers should be advised that soya infant formulae are potentially cariogenic and should be used only when medically indicatedGPPParents and carers should be advised not to put children to bed with a bottle or feeder cupBParents and carers should be advised that foods and confectionery containing free sugars should be minimised, and if possible restricted to meal timesCParents and carers should be advised that drinks containing free sugars, including natural fruit juices, should be avoided between meals, and should never be put in a feeding bottle. Water or milk may be given insteadCParents and carers should be advised that confectionery and beverages containing sugar substitutes are preferable to those containing sugarsBParents and carers should be advised that cheese is a good high energy food for toddlers as it is noncariogenic and may be actively protective against cariesGPPParents and carers should be assured that sugar-free snacks are unlikely to be cariogenicPractice-based managementDPrimary teeth with caries progressing into dentine should be actively managed with a preventive, or a preventive and restorative, approach as appropriate with the child's ability to cooperateBIf complete caries removal from a vital primary molar is not possible an indirect pulp capping technique should be consideredBWhen preparing a Class II cavity, care must be taken to avoid iatrogenic damage to adjacent proximal tooth surfacesBUse of the ART (Atraumatic Restorative Treatment) approach for cavity preparation in carious primary teeth should be considered as an alternative, where appropriate, to conventional cavity preparation techniquesAAmalgam, composite, resin-modified glass-ionomers, compomer or preformed metal crowns should be used as restorative materials for Class II cavities in primary molars. Conventional glass-ionomer should be avoided, where possible, for Class II cavity restorationPractice-based preventionBThe dental health team should deliver caries prevention strategies in conjunction with physical prevention techniques such as the use of fluorideBParents and their preschool children should receive oral health education from their dental team. This should include oral hygiene instruction, the appropriate use of fluoride toothpaste and the provision of fluoride agents such as toothpasteBTopical fluoride varnish should be applied to the dentition at least twice yearly for preschool children assessed as being at increased risk of dental cariesCommunity-based preventionACommunity or home-based oral health promotion interventions should use fluoride containing agents such as fluoride toothpasteACommunity-based toothbrushing programmes should include toothpaste with a concentration of 1000 ppm fluorideBToothbrushing programmes should be undertaken in community-based settings such as nurseries, and with parents to create a supportive environment for oral health behaviourDOral health promotion programmes to reduce the risk of early childhood caries should be available for parents during pregnancy and continued postnatallyCProgrammes for young children should be initiated before the age of 3 years. The oral health of young children should be promoted through multiple interventions and multisessional health promotion programmes for parentsCTeachers, community workers and lay or peer educators can be effective in delivering health promotion interventions and their role should be considered in the development of oral health promotion programmesCProfessionals should ensure oral health messages are relevant and applicable to communities and lifestylesBCaries prevention measures should target ‘at-risk’ populations and individuals to reduce oral health inequalitiesDFluoride supplements should only be prescribed by dental practitioners on an individual patient basisResearch recommendationsDuring the identification and critical appraisal of evidence for this guideline, it became apparent that there is limited evidence from high-quality, rigorous and methodologically sound research, and that the evidence currently available is often poor and incomplete. The guideline development group recommended that research should be carried out evaluating the benefits, and potential risks of fluorosis, of a community-based water fluoridation scheme in the current environment in Scotland,determining the relationship between oral health and health inequalities,exploring how dental services should be provided in areas of deprivation to minimise inequalities,evaluating community-based prevention programmes, including the involvement of health visitors,ascertaining the most effective combination of preventive, or preventive and restorative, interventions for different caries-risk groups, with different levels of deprivation, in different settings,examining the relationship between age and caries experience in the preschool child,describing the caries experience of preschool children with special needs,completing RCT to investigate the apparent caries-reducing effect of sugar-substituted sweets,investigating the effect of breast- and bottle-feeding on the development of early childhood caries in studies that control for other dietary factors,identifying effective interventions to improve the diet at weaning and preschool age,examining the effectiveness of structured nursery toothbrushing programmes,determining the optimum age at which to commence brushing children's teeth,exploring the effect of one-to-one dental health education on health outcomes,evaluating the effectiveness of dental health education programmes promoting the use of fluoride outside a structured programme,examining the effects of maternal use of xylitol in preventing caries in young children,identifying specific barriers to the implementation of oral health strategies, and how to overcome them,assessing the effectiveness of preventive advice delivered by the dental team in the dental practice environment,determining the effectiveness of fluoride and chlorhexidine varnishes, and fissure sealing in the primary dentition,conducting RCT in primary care to investigate the relative efficacy of conventional restorative management of carious primary teeth including the role of general anaesthetic compared with alternative techniques, and with a prevention-only approach,establishing the effect of remuneration on quality of dental care and availability of dental practitioners.

A scoping review of guidelines on caries management for children and young people to inform UK undergraduate core curriculum development

Are we practising what we preach and are we all singing from the same hymn sheet? An exploration of teaching in paediatric caries management across UK dental schools

European core curriculum in cariology for undergraduate dental students

Prevention and management of dental decay in the pre-school child

The knowledge and practice of pediatricians in children’s oral health: a scoping review

The Core Curriculum in Cariology: Fiction or Reality? Challenges about Implementation

Knowledge of undergraduate dental students regarding management of caries lesions

A European Core Curriculum in Cariology: the knowledge base

Molar incisor hypomineralisation: Teaching and assessment across the undergraduate dental curricula in the UK

Recommended procedures for managing carious lesions in primary teeth with pulp involvement-a scoping review

A multi‐faceted construct to guide geriatric dental education: Findings from a scoping review with consultation

Oral and maxillofacial surgery and dental health education in undergraduate medicine: a systematic review

Mapping Systematic Reviews on the Management of Dental Caries in Primary Teeth: A Meta-Research

Early childhood caries, primary caregiver oral health knowledge and behaviours and associated sociological factors in Australia: a systematic scoping review

Development of Tooth Brushing Recommendations Through Professional Consensus

Comprehensive review of caries assessment systems developed over the last decade

Mapping Evidence in Teaching Palliative Care in Undergraduate Curriculum of Healthcare Professionals Qualification: A Systematic Scoping Review Protocol

Methodological quality of evidence-based clinical practice guidelines in cariology

Prevention and control of dental caries and periodontal diseases at individual and population level: consensus report of group 3 of joint EFP/ORCA workshop on the boundaries between caries and periodontal diseases

Interventions with pregnant women, new mothers and other primary caregivers for preventing early childhood caries