Research on the Quality Criteria of Street Space Affecting Children's Hierarchy of School Travel Needs
XU Shouheng,ZHUANG Weimin
DOI: https://doi.org/10.13791/j.cnki.hsfwest.20230207
2023-01-01
Abstract:The positive impact of active school travel（AST） on children’s well-being has received widespread attention and recognition in academic research, particularly in the areas of physical health, mental health, cognitive development, and social adaptability. Providing high-quality AST options for children has become a major challenge for urban planning, transportation, and public health sectors in China. This study aims to achieve two objectives: firstly, it aims to integrate the evidence provided by relevant literature and generate the quality criteria of street space（QCSS） that affect children’s hierarchy of school travel needs（HSTN）; second, to reveal the specific impacts of the sub-items and indicator factors related to the QCSS on children’s HSTN.Children’s AST needs can be summarized into four levels: safety, accessibility, comfort,and enjoyment. This is based on a comprehensive analysis of their AST behavior characteristics,Maslow’s hierarchy of needs, and Alfonzo’s hierarchy of walking needs. In the process of AST for children, necessary, spontaneous, and social activities often intersect. High-quality street space should therefore simultaneously meet the safety and accessibility needs of children’s AST, and become a potential guarantee for their comfort and enjoyment needs during their growth process.The extraction of street space factors that affect the HSTN and the generation of new quality criteria are mainly based on the evidence provided by the literature system retrieval related to children’s travel and activities, public spaces, shared street spaces, and child-friendly streets/public spaces. Based on the China National Knowledge Infrastructure（CNKI） database, ten important domestic journals in the fields of architecture and urban planning were searched and classified statistically over the past five years（2017-2021）, and it was found that public space-related literature mainly focuses on vitality, health, measurement, and strategies, with less direct attention paid to quality criteria. A preliminary confirmation of 69 foreign articles was obtained through searches and screening in databases such as Web of Science, EBSCO, and ScienceDirect. They mainly revolve around 29 themes. Through full-text review and evaluation, 15 Chinese and foreign literatures were identified as the theoretical basis for the generation of QCSS that affect children’s HSTN, while other literatures served as evidence for the comprehensive analysis of relevant sub-items and their indicator factors.This text discusses a framework for QCSS that affects the HSTN, based on 12 public space quality criteria by Gehl and supplemented by Schulze + Grassov’s Copenhagen public space parameters. Other quality criteria and design features are integrated into the framework. The main categories include protection, accessibility, comfort, and enjoyment, along with 18 subitems. Through a systematic discussion of the interactive relationships within the framework and the specific HSTN, indicator factors for these sub-items were extracted, and a complete QCSS that affects children’s HSTN was constructed.Among them, the protection criteria determine the size of children’s autonomous activity areas,the length of outdoor stay time, and the level of sports activities. The accessibility criteria are based on meeting the time budget for children to travel between home and school, as well as their physical and perceptual proximity. The comfort criteria need to provide children with more opportunities for outdoor activities and social interactions, while the enjoyment criteria need to create attractive spatial environments that meet what children want or desire.There is a certain correlation between the attractiveness of street space for children and the survival advantages it embodies. Allowing and encouraging the existence of gathering places is crucial to supporting children’s ongoing social behavior. In other words, child-friendly street space is not only a physically safe and stable transportation space, but also a humane place for children to achieve public life, free interaction, and social inclusiveness. Its core value is to stimulate children’s fluid emotions, gradually establish space identity and place attachment. The generation of QCSS based on publicness, sharing,and sociality can serve as an auxiliary tool for the entire process of early planning, mid-term design, and post-evaluation intervention of street space around schools, and will play an important guiding and promoting role in the high-quality street space renewal, improvement, optimization, and creation. The current research is in the theoretical stage. Future research will expand on this basis in an orderly manner, with a focus on the following aspects:1)Testing the practicality of QCSS by evaluating changes in the environment before and after the intervention of street space planning around community schools and assessing its impact on children’s school travel, free play, and sports activities.2)Conducting longitudinal research on the changes in school travel behavior and its relationship with street space, taking into account the changing trends in children’s cognitive development and activity abilities with age.3)Collaborating with interdisciplinary teams and collecting big data to study the differences in perception between school-age children and their parents regarding street space.