Abstract:In the study of women in academia, the focus is often particularly on women's stark underrepresentation in the math-intensive fields of natural sciences, technology, and economics (NTE). In the non-math-intensive of fields life, social and behavioral (LSB) sciences, gender issues are seemingly less at stake because, on average, women are well-represented. However, in the current study, we demonstrate that equal gender representation in LSB disciplines does not guarantee women's equal opportunity to advance to full professorship-to the contrary. With a cross-sectional survey among N = 2,109 academics at mid-level careers (i.e., assistant and associate professors) in the Netherlands, we test the hypothesis that in LSB (more than NTE), female academics perceive to hit a "thicker" glass ceiling-that is, they see a sharper contrast between the high representation of women at the lower compared to the top levels. We test whether this predicts female academics' lower estimated chances to reach full professorship relative to men in LSB (but not NTE). We introduce a novel perceived glass ceiling index (GCI), calculated based on academics' perceptions of the share of women and men in their direct work environment minus their perceptions of gender ratio among full professors in their field. Results confirm that the perceived glass ceiling is thicker in the non-math-intensive LSB compared to math-intensive NTE fields. Furthermore, only in LSB (but not NTE), women perceived a thicker glass ceiling than men. Moreover, only among female academics, the thicker the perceived glass ceiling, the lower their estimated chances to become full professor 1 day. Combined, a moderated mediation showed that for women only, a thicker perceived glass ceiling in LSB compared to NTE disciplines predicted their lower estimated chances to advance to full professor level. No such mediation occurred for men. We conclude that women's higher numerical representation in LSB disciplines does not negate a male-dominant normative standard about academic leadership and success. Paradoxically, the perceived odds for female academics to reach the top of their field are lower in fields where they are relatively highly represented, and this may pose unique barriers to women's perceived opportunities for career success.

Inequalities faced by women in access to permanent positions in astronomy in France

Commission Femmes et Astronomie de la SF2A: Women participation in French astronomy

Gender and Precarity in Astronomy

Women in Italian astronomy

The Selection of Tenured Astronomers in France

The domestic basis of the scientific career: gender inequalities in ecology in France and Norway

Impact of discrimination on training and career of radiation oncologists in France

Gender Systematics in Telescope Time Allocation at ESO

Status of Women in Astronomy: A need for advancing inclusivity and equal opportunities

Weak Presence of Women in Microelectronics: Analysis and Suggestions of the French Training Network to be More Attractive

Cultural Barriers to Women's Progression in Academic Careers: A France‐Brazil Comparison Through the Lens of the Queen Bee Phenomena

Women of the Future in the Royal Astronomical Society

From the Dining Room to the Coll{è}ge royal: The Scholarly Spaces of the Female Collaborators in Astronomy of J{é}r{ô}me Lalande

The Gender Breakdown of the Applicant Pool for Tenure-Track Faculty Positions at a Sample of North American Research Astronomy Programs

Women in Physics: Scissors Effect from the Brazilian Olympiad of Physics to Professional Life

Equal Representation Does Not Mean Equal Opportunity: Women Academics Perceive a Thicker Glass Ceiling in Social and Behavioral Fields Than in the Natural Sciences and Economics

Careers in astronomy in Germany and the UK

“Navigating” through a scientific career: A question of private and professional configurational supports

Socio-demographic study of the exoplanet direct imaging community

The future of astronomy PhDs in France

Gender inequality in culture industries: Women and men writers in film and television