Differences Between American and Chinese Classroom Teaching

郭凉燕

Abstract:Different teaching philosophies derive from different cultural background.There are many differences between American and Chinese teaching philosophies because of their different cultural background.Under the guidance of different philosophies,there are different teaching styles between American and Chinese Classroom teaching.

Philosophy,Psychology,Education

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Exploring the Association between Learning Approaches and Classroom Learning Behaviors Presented by Chinese and American Undergraduates

CHENG Hong-yu,GU Jian-min,GUAN Shu-yi

2013-01-01

Abstract:Currently,the phenomenon that American and Chinese students present different behavioral traits in the classroom has been intensively discussed. The present study hypothesized that Chinese and American students differ in the tendency of assuming a structure- oriented or a depth- oriented approach to learning,and their tendencies in learning approaches at least partly explain their behavioral differences in the classroom. Two measures assessing learning approaches and classroom learning behaviors were implemented to 281 Chinese undergraduates and 206 American undergraduates. The results indicated that American and Chinese students differed significantly on the learning behavior measure and on the learning approach measure,the structure- oriented learning approach was negatively and significantly related to classroom learning behavior,the depth- oriented learning approach was positively and significantly related to classroom learning behavior,and the structure- oriented approach partially mediated the relationship between cultural group and classroom learning behavior. It was suggested that the structure- oriented learning approach at least partially explains the behavioral differences in the classroom presented by Chinese and American students.
Analysis of Differences Between Chinese and American Teaching Methods

Siyu Ma

DOI: https://doi.org/10.54254/2753-7048/39/20240671

2024-03-04

Abstract:With the competition of various countries in the world in education, to further consolidate and improve national education, China and the United States are major countries with greater influence in the world, and both countries attach great importance to student education. Due to the differences in political and economic systems and ideological and cultural aspects, there are differences in the content, path and method of education between the two countries. This paper analyzes the different educational styles of China and America. In this paper, the Chinese and American classroom forms, assessment methods and the impact of different education methods on students are mentioned respectively, and finally some suggestions are given. Educational administrators should combine the excellent educational methods of the United States from various aspects to improve education, and to improve the competitiveness of education in the world, and people should also know the shortcomings of education in other countries to cope with the future development of education in country.
Difference of Teachers Teaching Objectives Between Chinese High School and American High School

Liuye Chen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.54254/2753-7048/48/20231625

2024-05-17

Abstract:In this paper, the researcher explored the factors associated with different teaching objectives of American and Chinese high school teachers. The semi-structured interviews were conducted with a group of teachers who have rich experience teaching in American or Chinese high schools to understand (1) their teaching objectives, (2) the educational goals of the school, (3) their teaching styles and (4) why they want to be a teacher. Results concluded three key factors: (1) the effect of the schools educational goals; (2) the importance of students reactions and classroom environment; (3) how personal values and interests influence teachers goals.
A Comparative Study of Pre-Service Teachers’ Views on Ethical Issues in Classroom Assessment in China and the United States

Xumei Fan,Robert Johnson,Jin Liu,Xuegang Zhang,Xiumei Liu,Tiejun Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11516-019-0015-7

2019-06-01

Frontiers of Education in China

Abstract:The purpose of this study was to compare pre-service teachers' views of ethical issues in assessment practices in the US and China. Focus group interviews were conducted among 16 pre-service teachers from the US and 15 pre-service teachers from China. Results indicated that the inclusion of effort in grading is a key issue for the pre-service teachers in both the US and China. American pre-service teachers have more consistent views with experts regarding using multiple assessment methods and Communications about grading. Pre-service teachers in both countries appeared to have consistent views with experts regarding the confidentiality and standardized test preparation. The findings of this study can help build guidelines regarding ethical issues in classroom assessment.
A Cross-cultural Study of the Relationship between College Teachers' Teaching Styles and Undergraduates' Classroom Behaviors

Hong-yu CHENG

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1006-6020.2014.03.006

2014-01-01

Abstract:The purpose of this study was to compare teaching styles of American and Chinese teachers in higher schools,and to examine the hypothesis that the style differences between American and Chinese teachers could at least partially explain the distinct learning behaviors presented by American students and Chinese students in the classroom. 185 Chinese undergraduates and 120 American undergraduates were asked to assess their teachers' teaching style and to rate on their own behavioral performances in the classroom. The results of data analyses indicated that Chinese and American teachers differ significantly in executive style, conservative style and global style; Chinese students and American students differ significantly in classroom activity participation, indication of understanding and independency in teacher-student relationship; multiple teaching styles are significantly related to students' classroom behaviors; teachers ' conservative style and global style can partially explain the behavioral differences in the classroom between Chinese students and American students.
A Study on the Differences of Teacher-student Relationship in Chinese and American University Classrooms

Qianzhi Zhai

DOI: https://doi.org/10.54097/ijeh.v6i3.4769

2023-01-11

International Journal of Education and Humanities

Abstract:The different cultural backgrounds of Chinese and American countries make the education of the two countries show great differences, and these differences permeate all aspects of education. A good view of teachers and students and a harmonious relationship between teachers and students affect the transmission of educational information between teachers and students, which is related to students' mental health and all-round development. By comparing the differences between the characteristics of teacher-student relationship between Chinese and American, this paper aims to help us to absorb the essence of teacher-student relationship in American schools, make up for our own shortcomings and make our school education work better. Try to find out some factors that can be used for reference to promote the healthy growth of Chinese students and further improve the quality of Chinese education.
Differences of Classroom Teaching:Educators of“Taking It for Granted”and“Unexpected”College Students---Construction of Teaching Quality in Colleges and Universities From the Perspective of“Learning”

JIANGXifeng,ZHOUYinxing,LIUXiaoqiang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1000-579X.2015.06.016

2015-01-01

Abstract:The survey shows that classroom teaching is not the main learning way of college students, nor is the way they like learning and the main channel for them to acquire knowledge. Thinking“teaching”from the perspective of“learning”demands us to establish the concept of“big teach-ing”,construct the system of“big teaching”,re-position the target and function of classroom teach-ing,and establish the learning support service system.
A Study of English Teaching Differences Between China and The United States

Yingjie Zheng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.54097/ehss.v23i.13939

2023-12-13

Abstract:According to the existing literature, the analysis of the teaching content, teaching method and assessment model in China and the United States has the same trend: Scholars generally believe that compared with the English language teaching system in China, the methods of English language education in the United States are more diverse, the educational goals are more realistic to life, and the evaluation criteria are more comprehensive. The factors cause this difference is worth investigating. This paper evaluates the applicability of these views in today's world through a questionnaire survey. Specifically, this paper attempts to assess whether the similarities and differences that scholars have found between the English language teaching systems in China and the United States still exist today or whether the development trends between the English language teaching systems of the two countries are trending in the same direction today. The study surveyed Chinese students in the U.S. - a target group with dual English learning experiences in China and the U.S. The results of the paper show that the effectiveness and applicability of the English teaching systems of the two countries need to be discussed in the cultural environment of the two countries, and there is no one-sided argument that either system is better.
Chinese and American EFL teachers’ beliefs about curricular and pedagogical practices: cross-cultural similarities and differences

Beth Clark-Gareca,Min Gui

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/14708477.2018.1456546

2018-04-10

Language and Intercultural Communication

Abstract:Instructional practices are fundamentally influenced by teacher beliefs. Cultural and pedagogical belief differences in EFL teachers can fuel a lack of professional understanding among teachers with contrasting perspectives about effective teaching practices. The present study examined the alignment between the beliefs of Chinese English teachers (CETs, n = 94) and American English teachers (AETs, n = 30) related to classroom practices in the English language classroom. Data sources included a questionnaire and one-on-one individual interviews with AETs and CETs. Results found many similarities in beliefs held by both groups. Notable differences were a preference for grammatical approaches and support for grammar translation method in teaching grammar and writing (CETs), and communicative approaches (AETs). Capacity for student-centeredness in large classes, more than about 25 students, was also an area of divergence among CETs and AETs. Future contexts of English use, either global or local, and the need to perform on EFL tests were both factors in shaping teacher beliefs about pedagogy for their students. With Chinese English learners increasing in number both in China and abroad, this study makes an important contribution to the cross-cultural understanding of practices and beliefs held by English teachers of Chinese learners.

linguistics
Comparing the Behavioural Differences of Teachers and Students in Learner-Centred Classrooms Between China and the USA

Cheng Hong-Yu,Tian Ru-Meng,Mei Xiao-Xue

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10212-021-00592-8

2022-01-01

European Journal of Psychology of Education

Abstract:This research was designed to examine how teachers and students from various cultures (China vs. USA) might present distinct behavioural features in learner-centred classrooms. The findings of the research would serve the purpose to answer the question regarding whether and how learner-centred instruction could better support the learning of students from non-Western cultures. Chinese students experiencing learner-centred instruction (the experimental group), Chinese students from traditional classrooms (the control group), and American students responded to measures assessing their perceived teacher behaviours, and their own learning behaviours along with other two highly relevant variables, namely academic motivation and self-efficacy. The results indicated that Chinese teachers and students in the experimental group presented certain distinct behavioural features in comparison to both control group and American group. It suggested that the implementation of learner-centred instruction brought certain behavioural changes for Chinese teachers and students. However, on the other hand, their behavioural changes were not completely consistent with expectations. For instance, Chinese teachers in the experiment group did not present better performance in empowerment and individualized instruction, and their students did not exhibit more autonomous and self-directed learning behaviours as expected. The implications of the research were discussed in the paper.
The Differences of Family Education Between China and America

Huihui Guo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3968/11910

2020-10-26

Abstract:Nowadays, children live in a more privileged life and are provided by family and society with more advantageous conditions. At the same time, social development needs children have high qualified talents to face such environment，then good family education is the key point to the high qualified talents. Because family is the first place that children receive education, which plays an important role in the intellectual development and the quality of the children. There are many types of family education in the world and each of them shows distinctive features and closely relate to its culture. And American family education is the most famous one among them. There are great differences in the concepts, methods and results of education between America and China. My paper will analyze those differences from the three aspects, especially the differences on cultivating children’s independence, creativity and relationships between children and parents of the two kinds of family education. I hope to find a satisfied family education method through comparing the differences between Chinese and American family education so as to provide a helpful way for Chinese family education.

Sociology,Education
An Analysis of the Reasons for Differences in Educational Modernization Between China and Japan

米红,赵琳琳

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1000-4076.2010.04.030

2010-01-01

Abstract:The present author analyzes the differences between China and Japan in educational philoso-phy,education of scholars,reform subjects,etc.during the process of educational modernization,and illus-trates the fundamental factors leading to the differences.The factors include different histories,cultural tradi-tions,geographic locations,social natures,etc.
Analysis of the Effects of Cultural Differences on Teaching and Learning Styles and the Impact on Teaching and Learning in China

Shu Qi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.54097/3v9yjf79

2024-02-01

International Journal of Education and Humanities

Abstract:Education is not just the transmission of knowledge, but also the embodiment of culture. In the era we live in, the globalization has brought about greater fluidity in the exchange of information, leading to increasingly frequent blending and collision of different cultural backgrounds. Consequently, the profound impact of cultural differences on teaching methods has emerged. Against this backdrop, understanding and analyzing how culture shapes educational practices holds significant importance for enhancing the quality of education and promoting cultural exchange. This article aims to explore how family and societal cultures influence the interaction between students and teachers, how values determine the selection of teaching methods and content, and subsequently, to analyze the differentiated impact of domestic and international cultures on teaching methods. Ultimately, this article will focus on the current situation in China, where the existing teaching methods are influenced by tradition and modernization, offering a new perspective and direction for educational reform in our country.
The Differences in Education between China and the Western World and English Teaching and Learning Reform in Colleges

Wei Shao

Abstract:It is a main steam to promote the progress of educational internationalization, to foster talents with international vision, transnational culture and strong ability to participate in international competition. The western developed countries pay much attention to teaching and learning reform of foreign language and make achievements to attract the world attention. We should learn the educational differences and compare with them to improve the English teaching level in our country.

Linguistics,Education,Political Science
Do they learn differently? An investigation of the pre-service teachers from US and China

Zhuran You,Fenran Jia

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tate.2007.11.007

IF: 3.782

2008-05-01

Teaching and Teacher Education

Abstract:Based on the hypothesis that learning preferences tend to vary over cultures, this study compared and contrasted the learning approaches and learning styles between Chinese and American pre-service teachers in an attempt to know more about the learning/teaching landscapes in these two countries as “teachers teach the way they learned” [Dunn, R., & Dunn, K. (1979). Learning styles/teaching styles: Should they...can they...be matched? Educational Leadership, 36, 243, 238–244]. The results showed significant differences between the two groups in deep and surface-learning approaches as well as kinesthetic and visual learning styles. The underlying cultural backgrounds and social–economic factors accounting for the differences were discussed and the implications for teaching and learning enhancement in teacher education were explored.

education & educational research
A Comparative Analysis of the Differences of Family Education between China and America

Huo aiqiao,Yuan Xinfa,Caiqiao Huo,Xinfa Yuan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.4236/ce.2015.612132

2015-01-01

Creative Education

Abstract:Family is the first place where children receive education, so family education has a great influence on one’s life. This paper is about the family education in China and America. It compares the differences from the aspects of methods, contents, objectives and results of family education be-tween China and America. Then, it analyses the reasons for the differences in family education. Finally, some suggestions for family education in China are provided.
Teachers’ cultural differences: case studies of geography teachers in Brisbane, Changchun and Hong Kong

Chi Chung Lam,John Lidstone

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/bf03029254

2007-08-01

Asia Pacific Education Review

Abstract:The primary purpose of this exploratory study is to identify variations in the ways in which individual teachers in different educational contexts interpret their curriculum and plan their lessons and in particular to explore the possibility that cultural differences as identified by Hofstede (1991) may be a contributing factor to understanding how teachers understand their work. “Educational reform” has become a catchphrase in the Anglo-American world, including the United States, Canada, Australia, and England and Wales, as well as in the Confucian Heritage Areas such as Mainland China, Singapore, Hong Kong, and Taiwan. Across the world, the educational reform measures being implemented are surprisingly similar. This paper describes a study of how geography teachers in Queensland, Australia, Hong Kong, and Changchun, China, plan their lessons and curriculum. From classroom observations and interviews with the teachers involved, we confirmed marked differences in each location regarding their cultural traits of power distance, individualist and collectivist preference and uncertainty tolerance, and that these traits appear to be highly influential in their curriculum planning. Despite the small scale of this study, we contend that there are good reasons for caution before national education systems import policies and curriculum reform initiatives from other countries for unthinking adoption.

education & educational research
Differences Between Chinese and Western Educational Models Based on the High-Low Context Culture Theory

Yifei Gao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.54097/car4cy75

2024-05-28

Abstract:With the continuous development of globalization and the building of a community with a shared future for mankind, countries are increasingly engaged in cultural exchanges and mutual learning in many fields for common development. In this process, education has always been a focus. Young people are the future and hope of the country, and the education of youth attaches great important to the development of the country, so China has been learning from foreign education systems in recent years to explore domestic education reform. Chinese and Western education models have their own advantages and disadvantages, and students in different education models show different characteristics. However, to trace the reasons for the differences between Chinese and western education systems, we should go back to different national cultures. Based on Hall's theory of high-low context culture, this paper examines the differences in educational models between China and the West, discusses the influence of context culture on differences, and sheds light on how cultural factors shape educational practices.
A comparison of Undergraduates’ experiences in Chinese and American Classes: A case study of teaching patterns in UCB and BISU

Yutong Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1145/3446590.3446610

2020-12-17

Abstract:For Chinese universities, American education patterns have been models to learn from. This research conducted a comparison of five Chinese undergraduates’ experiences in two different universities, University of California at Berkeley (UCB) in U.S. and Beijing International Studies University (BISU) in China. By using the qualitative method, semi-interviews, the research made efforts to find the differences of classroom models between UCB and BISU based on participants’ narrations about their feelings, opinions and reflections. The differences include five aspects: learning resources, classroom atmosphere, teaching methods, learning strategies and following up after class. Most participants prefer teaching patterns in UCB because they feel more independent, free and lively in UCB. This research can provide a micro view of comparison and reference for the reform of undergraduate education in Chinese universities.
Differences in Teachers' and Students' Perceptions of Quality Teaching:An Analysis Based on a Massive Survey Conducted at Fudan University

QIAN Hai-yan,XIAO Zhi-guo,CHEN Kan,DING Yan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1672-0059.2012.04.007

2012-01-01

Abstract:As a result of the paradigm shift in knowledge control,teachers are no longer the absolute authority in classroom settings.They need to change their teaching beliefs and assume new roles to adapt to the change.This paper attempts to investigate whether the change has taken place in reality rather than in rhetoric.Based on the data collected from a large-scale survey conducted among Fudan teachers and students,these questions are specifically explored:Do teachers and students share similar or different perceptions of teaching? How do Fudan teachers define quality teaching? How do students understand them? Any misalignment between them? On the basis of the analysis of the misalignments,the paper concludes with some suggestions on the type of professional development models required by teachers.

Differences Between American and Chinese Classroom Teaching

Exploring the Association between Learning Approaches and Classroom Learning Behaviors Presented by Chinese and American Undergraduates

Analysis of Differences Between Chinese and American Teaching Methods

Difference of Teachers Teaching Objectives Between Chinese High School and American High School

A Comparative Study of Pre-Service Teachers’ Views on Ethical Issues in Classroom Assessment in China and the United States

A Cross-cultural Study of the Relationship between College Teachers' Teaching Styles and Undergraduates' Classroom Behaviors

A Study on the Differences of Teacher-student Relationship in Chinese and American University Classrooms

Differences of Classroom Teaching:Educators of“Taking It for Granted”and“Unexpected”College Students---Construction of Teaching Quality in Colleges and Universities From the Perspective of“Learning”

A Study of English Teaching Differences Between China and The United States

Chinese and American EFL teachers’ beliefs about curricular and pedagogical practices: cross-cultural similarities and differences

Comparing the Behavioural Differences of Teachers and Students in Learner-Centred Classrooms Between China and the USA

The Differences of Family Education Between China and America

An Analysis of the Reasons for Differences in Educational Modernization Between China and Japan

Analysis of the Effects of Cultural Differences on Teaching and Learning Styles and the Impact on Teaching and Learning in China

The Differences in Education between China and the Western World and English Teaching and Learning Reform in Colleges

Do they learn differently? An investigation of the pre-service teachers from US and China

A Comparative Analysis of the Differences of Family Education between China and America

Teachers’ cultural differences: case studies of geography teachers in Brisbane, Changchun and Hong Kong

Differences Between Chinese and Western Educational Models Based on the High-Low Context Culture Theory

A comparison of Undergraduates’ experiences in Chinese and American Classes: A case study of teaching patterns in UCB and BISU

Differences in Teachers' and Students' Perceptions of Quality Teaching:An Analysis Based on a Massive Survey Conducted at Fudan University