How to survive a physics PhD

Pruthvi Mehta

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/2058-7058/37/02/27

2024-02-01

Physics World

Abstract:Achieving a doctoral degree, the highest academic qualification available, is a huge feat that can be a long and difficult journey. Having recently completed her own PhD in physics, Pruthvi Mehta shares her five top tips for surviving your doctoral studies.

physics, multidisciplinary

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Ph.D. in physics as a hurdle race, and the "glass hurdles" for women

Meytal Eran-Jona,Yosef Nir

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2007.02251

2020-07-05

Physics Education

Abstract:On their way to an academic career in physics, Ph.D. students have to overcome difficulties at many levels. Beyond the intellectual challenge, there are also psychological, social and economic barriers. We studied the difficulties experienced by physics Ph.D. students in the Israeli universities, with special attention to gender-related issues. Among the hurdles that are much more significant for women than for men -- that we call ``the glass hurdles" -- we find gender-related discrimination, sexual harassment, physiological and psychological health issues, and challenges related to pregnancy and parenthood. We make recommendations for ways to confront and remove these barriers in order to provide female physicists with an equal opportunity to succeed.
How to Be a Successful Graduate Student

Francis T. Cullen,Brenda Vose

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/1043986214541603

2014-10-05

Journal of Contemporary Criminal Justice

Abstract:Earning a PhD is an exciting but arduous process, marked by an attrition rate of about 50%. In this context, we provide advice—10 lessons—on how students can not only survive but also thrive in graduate school. A core message is that students must understand that doctoral education is a unique social world whose main function is to prepare trained academics. Toward this end, students should not expect to be taken care of but must be the architects of their own professional development. Thus, they need to develop research skills, learn how to teach, use unstructured time productively, and act in ways that will bolster their reputation and make faculty want to collaborate with them. Students’ most important challenge, however, is to become an independent scholar—to acquire the depth of expertise and genuine passion for the criminological enterprise necessary for subsequent professional accomplishment and fulfillment.

criminology & penology
Producing a successful PhD thesis

David Barrett,Alison Rodriguez,Joanna Smith

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/ebnurs-2020-103376

2020-12-14

Abstract:<p>All doctoral students strive for the day—after years of often all-consuming study—that their thesis is ready to submit. For both doctoral students and supervisors there is often trepidation about whether the thesis will meet the criteria to merit the award of a Doctor of Philosophy (PhD). As anxieties increase, doctoral students often ask what makes a good PhD, something we explored in a recent 'Research Made Simple' article,1 but perhaps the more important question is 'what makes a PhD student successful?' In this article we outline the core criteria on which PhD theses are judged and offer suggestions for achieving success.</p> How are PhDs assessed <p>Traditionally, a PhD involves 3 to 4 years of full-time study (or a longer part-time programme), which is assessed by the student submitting the work they have undertaken as a thesis or—less commonly—a portfolio of published papers and an associated narrative (sometimes...</p>
Surviving Early Career Research and Beyond in the Physics of Life: A concise user guide

Mark C Leake

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2204.13189

2022-04-27

Physics Education

Abstract:Early Career Researcher (ECR) development is a dynamic challenge that tensions the urge to perform ground-breaking research against an ultimate practical aspiration of establishing an acceptable level of job security. There is no typical career path for an ECR, least of all in the area of the Physics of Life or Biophysics/Biological Physics. Being explicitly interdisciplinary across the physical-life sciences interface presents more opportunities for a multiplicity of career trajectories through different home academic institutions and departments, as well as offering a broader range of alternative future career trajectories in non-academic sectors. That said, there are key common features, such as the transient nature of fixed-term postdoc contracts, the substantial research and domestic challenges that these present, and the often overwhelming pressures of the realities of competition in the job market. In this short article I outline the key challenges to ECRs in the Physics of Life and discuss simple strategies to manage and potentially overcome them.
Physics PhD student perspectives on the importance and difficulty of finding a research group

Mike Verostek,Casey W. Miller,Benjamin M. Zwickl

2024-02-07

Abstract:Joining a research group is one of the most important events on a graduate student's path to becoming an independent physics researcher and earning a PhD. However, graduate students' perspectives on the experience of finding a research group are not well-documented in the literature. Understanding these perspectives is crucial for evaluating whether departments are providing students with adequate support while they search for a research group, and how difficulties during this process contribute to attrition. Semi-structured interviews with N=20 first and second year physics PhD students reveal that incoming graduate students see joining a research group as a significant decision, and recognize that it may impact whether they will be able to complete the program. We found that students who struggled to find a group felt isolated and worried about falling behind their peers, whereas students who were able to immerse themselves in a positive group environment reported increased sense of belonging in their programs. The process of finding a research group often held differential importance for students identifying as women and non-binary, who at times reported having to deprioritize their preferred research topic in order to be part of a more inclusive working environment. Although incoming graduate students characterized joining a research group as a significant decision, they often felt unprepared to make it. Moreover, they perceived an overall lack of guidance and structure from their departments, and characterized coursework as a barrier to searching for a group. Our findings suggest that providing students with better support during their group search process could help improve retention, particularly for traditionally underrepresented students, and improve students' overall satisfaction in their graduate programs.

Physics Education
The academic career in physics as a "deal": Choosing physics within a gendered power structure and excellence as an extra hurdle for women

Meytal Eran-Jona,Yosef Nir

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2010.13115

2020-10-25

Physics Education

Abstract:The absence of women among academic staff in physics is in the focus of our research. To explore the causes of this gender imbalance, we conducted a nationwide representative survey among Ph.D. students and interviews with Ph.D. students and postdoctoral fellows. Studying both context factors and agency, we reveal the multiple and hidden ways in which gender operates as a power structure, putting up barriers to women's academic careers. This latent power structure influences women's decision-making and experiences in several ways. In the academic field, it produces unequal competition in a male dominated playground. In the social sphere, choosing a demanding academic career is seen as disrupting gender order. Within the family, women carry a greater burden of family work and give precedence to their partner's career and preferences. Within this social structure, women who decide to follow an academic career feel that they must excel. The demand for excellence acts as an invisible barrier within the gender power structure that prevents talented women from pursuing an academic career in physics.
On making physics relevant to society in general and to scientists in particular: Closing the epistemic gap

Jamal Mimouni

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2208.06728

2022-08-14

Abstract:Physics has a bad press: it is seen by a majority of people as a boring discipline ever since their High School days. There is no glamour to it, just toil and pain, and for many who engaged in it, the end sight is often unemployment. Could it be that physicists don't know how to communicate what their discipline entails to? I will be tackling the problematic of making physics relevant to society and to the scientists in general. I will also be dealing with the methodological and educational aspects of teaching and practicing physics, and the need to close the epistemic gap between physics teaching and the physicist's understanding ... By the way, do physicists understand physics?

Physics Education,History and Philosophy of Physics,Physics and Society
What PhD students really want

Minnie Mao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1006.4421

2010-06-23

Abstract:The road to becoming an astronomer is exciting, but often fraught with danger and conflicting messages. A PhD student is inundated with catch-phrases such as "publish or perish" and "it's not about the quantity, but the quality of work". How do we know which advice to follow? How can we publish copious amounts of quality work in only three years so as to maximize our success in the future? How do we even know what "good quality" really is? With only a short time to prepare ourselves for the big wide world of Astronomy, what is the best way for a PhD student to maximize their research and ultimately maximize their success as a real astronomer? The PhD students of today are the astronomers of tomorrow, but their journey depends on a positive work environment in which they can thrive and improve. Here I present the results of a survey of current PhD students on how they believe they can maximize their success in science. I find that PhD students in Australia expect to write more papers during their PhD than is expected by their supervisors, but that they are generally happy with the quality of their supervision. Above all, students love telescopes, and hands-on observations are an important part of acquiring the knowledge and culture necessary to becoming a real astronomer.

Instrumentation and Methods for Astrophysics
Progression in self-efficacy, interest, identity, sense of belonging, perceived recognition and effectiveness of peer interaction of physics majors and comparison with non-majors and Ph.D. students

Kyle Whitcomb,Alexandru Maries,Chandralekha Singh

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11165-022-10068-4

2023-04-13

Abstract:The importance of science beliefs such as self-efficacy, interest, identity, sense of belonging, perceived recognition and effectiveness of peer interaction in science education has been increasingly recognized in recent years. Here, we use five years of data from a validated survey administered to non-majors during their first year, physics majors throughout their undergraduate education, and first-year physics Ph.D. students at a large research university in the US. We find that physics majors in the first-year responded to the survey prompts more positively than their non-physics major peers who were in the same introductory courses, with the largest differences in perceived recognition, interest, and physics identity and somewhat smaller differences in self-efficacy, perception of peer interaction, and sense of belonging. Further, the average survey responses of physics majors for each belief remain largely constant over time from their first-year of the undergraduate curriculum through the last year and comparable to the Ph.D. students. This suggests that students are adjusting their interpretation of the survey items to match the current level of expertise expected of them. One exception occurs in the second year, when peer interaction and sense of belonging reach a minimum. Moreover, physics identity dips to the lowest value in the fourth year when many students are contemplating continuing in physics beyond their undergraduate years or switching fields. We also find that perceived recognition is the best predictor of physics identity for physics majors throughout their entire physics education, pointing to the importance of instructors making a concerted effort to recognize and affirm their students throughout their education.

Physics Education
How to enjoy and thrive in graduate school

Ramanujan S Hegde,Ramanujan S. Hegde

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tcb.2024.02.003

IF: 21.167

2024-02-01

Trends in Cell Biology

Abstract:Scientific research is an exploration of the unknown. The process is full of uncertainty, missteps, delightful surprises, painful lessons, and ultimately a measure of insight into nature. In this Science and Society article I suggest a few practical strategies that helped me navigate these challenges at the earliest stages of becoming a cell biologist.

cell biology
Modeling when and how physics PhD students search for a research group: the role of interests and prior research experiences in timely group integration

Mike Verostek,Casey W. Miller,Benjamin M. Zwickl

2024-08-21

Abstract:Studying the factors that influence the quality of physics PhD students' doctoral experiences, especially those that motivate them to stay or leave their programs, is critical for providing them with more holistic and equitable support. Prior literature on doctoral attrition has found that students with clear research interests who establish an advisor-advisee relationship early in their graduate careers are most likely to persist. However, these trends have not been investigated in the context of physics, and the underlying reasons for why these characteristics are associated with leaving remain unstudied. Using semi-structured interviews with 40 first and second year physics PhD students, we construct a model describing the characteristic pathways that physics PhD students take while evaluating interest congruence of prospective research groups. We show how access to undergraduate research and other formative experiences helped some students narrow their interests and look for research groups before arriving to graduate school. In turn, these students reported fewer difficulties finding a group than students whose search for an advisor took place during the first year of their PhD. Lastly, we identify two characteristic types of students at a higher risk of leaving their programs: students who enter graduate school with broad interests and struggle to find a group, and students who join a research group early based on research interest alone and subsequently encounter issues with a negative mentoring relationship. This work serves as a major step toward creating a comprehensive model of how PhD students find a research group, and opens the door for future work to investigate how factors such as group culture and working environment impact the search process.

Physics Education
Becoming a Physicist: The Roles of Research, Mindsets, and Milestones in upper-division student perceptions

Paul W. Irving,Eleanor C. Sayre

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevSTPER.11.020120

2015-05-29

Abstract:As part of a longitudinal study into identity development in upper-level physics students, a phenomenographic research method was used to examine students' perceptions of what it means to be a physicist. The results revealed four different categories of perception of what it means to be a physicist, with a clear distinction in the level of exclusivity students associate with being a physicist and differences of importance of research and its association with being a physicist. We find a relationship between students' perceptions of physicists and students' goal orientation. The paper highlights a need for faculty to not just emphasize the importance of research to students' academic development but also to further demonstrate and explain what research entails and the role it plays in a physicist's identity.

Physics Education
Attitude and Motivation towards Learning Physics

Ryan Manuel D. Guido

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1805.02293

2018-05-06

Physics Education

Abstract:Physics is considered as one of the most prevailing and problematic subjects by the students in the realm of science. Students perceived physics as a difficult subject during high school days and become more evasive when they reach college. Based on an investigation of 446 engineering and technology students, this study analyses and evaluates the relationship between attitude and motivation of engineering and technology students towards learning physics. It shows that there is no significant difference in the attitude and motivation of students towards learning physics. Furthermore, there is a negligible degree of relationship for attitude and motivation. The relationship between attitude and motivation is due to chance. This confides that most students found that is unlikely for them to enjoy learning physics because of their professor. Faculty should encourage students in drilling physics problems, students are found to like answering difficult physics questions in ever examination, expresses that they have a mathematical mind.
Beyond The Big Bang Theory: Revealing the everyday research lives of theoretical physics faculty

Mike Verostek,Molly Griston,Jesus Botello,Benjamin Zwickl

2023-04-27

Abstract:"So what do you do? I mean, what do you actually do?" This is one of the most common questions one theoretical physicist receives from her students, and is representative of a common curiosity among aspiring physicists. Students often misunderstand what different types of physicists actually do. For many, the term "theoretical physicist" likely conjures mental images of Einstein, Feynman, or Sheldon Cooper discerning the underlying operating principles of the universe, armed with only pencil and paper. Such imagery is representative of the "lone genius" stereotype many students ascribe to physicists. However, this common perception of physicists is known to discourage students, particularly underrepresented gender and racial groups, from pursuing it as a career. Moreover, students of all demographic backgrounds may avoid physics if they feel they do not understand what different kinds of physicists do on a daily basis. Therefore, providing students with an accurate depiction of the skills, practices, motivations, and daily routines in different types physics careers is essential for helping them make decisions about their future. In this article, we offer students a glimpse into what a career in theoretical physics is like. Through interviews with 11 practicing theoretical physics faculty, we reveal a variety of misconceptions theorists believe students hold about their work. Addressing these misconceptions will provide students with important details to consider as they navigate their career decision process.

Physics Education
The graduate school guide: How to prepare for the qualifying exam and assemble a thesis/graduate committee

Crystal D. Rogers,Annet Kirabo,Melanie McReynolds,Mariya T. Sweetwyne,Celestine Wanjalla,Jazmine Benjamin,Edith M. Williams,Jennifer A. Gaddy,Clintoria R. Williams,Steven M. Damo,Sandra A. Murray,Antentor Hinton,Antentor Hinton Jr.

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/jcp.31258

2024-04-10

Journal of Cellular Physiology

Abstract:Qualifying exams and thesis committees are crucial components of a PhD candidate's journey. However, many candidates have trouble navigating these milestones and knowing what to expect. This article provides advice on meeting the requirements of the qualifying exam, understanding its format and components, choosing effective preparation strategies, retaking the qualifying exam, if necessary, and selecting a thesis committee, all while maintaining one's mental health. This comprehensive guide addresses components of the graduate school process that are often neglected.

cell biology,physiology
The relationship between gender and academic performance in undergraduate physics students: The role of physics identity, perceived recognition, and self-efficacy

Ewan Bottomley,Antje Kohnle,Kenneth I. Mavor,Paula J. Miles,Vivienne Wild

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1361-6404/aca29e

2022-11-17

European Journal of Physics

Abstract:Studies focusing on physics undergraduate students have found that women tend not to identify as strongly with physics, compared to men. Recent research has examined potential factors that influence the experience of women in physics. Several of these factors, such as students' beliefs in their ability to complete physics-based tasks (i.e., self-efficacy) and students' belief that others perceive them as a physicist (i.e., perceived recognition), have been associated with physics identity in the context of introductory university physics courses in the United States (US). The current study extends this previous work, surveying students at all levels of the undergraduate degree at a research-intensive university in the UK. Students were asked about their physics identity, physics self-efficacy, and the extent to which they believed others perceived them as physicists. The survey responses were then matched with students' grades. Using matched responses from the start and end of an academic year from 169 students (110 men, 59 women), two analyses were performed. The first analysis found that average scores for women for physics identity, and self-efficacy were lower than for men both at the start and end of the academic year. The second analysis found that after controlling for the start-of-year scores in physics identity, self-efficacy, and perceived recognition, students' mid-year grades significantly predicted variance in their end-of-year scores for self-efficacy, perceived recognition, and (possibly also) physics identity. This study also found that the gap in perceived recognition between men and women increased over the academic year. The results contribute to understanding potential barriers for women in physics and have implications for instruction in terms of promoting students' physics identity, self-efficacy, and perceived recognition.

physics, multidisciplinary,education, scientific disciplines
Physics graduate student employment: what we can learn from professional social media

Erin M. Tonita,Ludmila Szulakowska,Joshua Baxter,Erin L. Flannigan,Naveena Janakiraman Narayanan,Jean-Michel Menard

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2106.04294

2021-06-08

Physics Education

Abstract:In this study, we investigated the employment status of recent University of Ottawa physics MSc and PhD graduates, finding that 94% of graduates are either employed or pursuing further physics education one year post-graduation. Our database was populated from the public online repository of MSc and PhD theses submitted between the academic years of 2011 to 2019, with employment information collected in 2020 from the professional social media platform LinkedIn. Our results highlight that graduates primarily find employment quickly and in their field of study, with most graduates employed in either academia or physics-related industries. We also found that a significant portion of employed graduates, 20%, find employment in non-traditional physics careers, such as business management and healthcare. Graduates with careers in academia tend to have lower online connectivity compared to graduates with careers in industry or non-traditional fields, suggesting a greater importance for online networking for students interested in non-academic careers.
Five Frequently Fatal Freshman Physics Fantasies

Michael Courtney,Norm Althausen,Amy Courtney

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.physics/0605152

2006-05-17

Physics Education

Abstract:This article describes five common student misconceptions about succeeding in college-level Physics courses: the miracle finish, the soft hearted professor, an extension of high school, weak areas won't be tested, and passing is more important than learning. These fantasies are unique to neither Physics nor freshman, but the challenge of learning Physics brings more certain negative consequences to students retaining these attitudes. Ascribing these student misconceptions to freshmen acknowledges that they diminish with increasing academic maturity.
Astro2020 APC White Paper: Enabling Terminal Master's Degrees as a Step Towards a Ph.D

Michael B. Lund,Savannah R. Jacklin,David Ciardi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1909.02103

2019-09-05

Abstract:Earning any advanced degree in physics or astronomy is an arduous process and major accomplishment. However, not every journey to the Ph.D. is paved equally. Every year, there are hundreds of students who earn terminal master's degrees in physics and astronomy in the United States. A master's degree on its own is sufficient qualification for many good careers, but for a portion of these students, the master's degree is not the final step in graduate education. When students with master's degrees decide to continue their education and are accepted to Ph.D. programs, they often find that their credits do not transfer and that they will be required to re-do large portions of their master's degree at their new Ph.D.-granting institution. Here we discuss the need for gathering more data to understand both the different pathways to a Ph.D. and the students that choose each route. We also discuss some of the challenges faced by students that earn a master's degree before beginning a Ph.D. program. As students in the physical sciences that complete a master's and a Ph.D. at different schools take over 2 years longer to reach a Ph.D. than students that get both degrees from the same school, we suggest steps that can be taken to help these students succeed in a timely manner.

Instrumentation and Methods for Astrophysics,Physics Education
The roots of physics students' motivations: Fear and Integrity

Ben Van Dusen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1502.04256

2015-02-14

Physics Education

Abstract:Too often, physics students are beset by feelings of failure and isolation rather than experiencing the creative joys of discovery that physics has to offer. This dissertation research was founded on the desire of a teacher to make physics class exciting and motivating to his students. This work explores how various aspects of learning environments interact with student motivation. This work uses qualitative and quantitative methods to explore how students are motivated to engage in physics and how they feel about themselves while engaging in physics. The collection of four studies in this dissertation culminates in a sociocultural perspective on motivation and identity. This perspective uses two extremes of how students experience physics as a lens for understanding motivation: fear and self-preservation versus integrity and self-expression. Rather than viewing motivation as a property of the student, or viewing students as inherently interested or disinterested in physics, the theoretical perspective on motivation and identity helps examine features of the learning environments that determine how students experience themselves through physics class. This perspective highlights the importance of feeling a sense of belonging in the context of physics and the power that teachers have in shaping student motivations through the construction of their classroom learning environments. Findings demonstrate how different ways that students experience themselves in physics class impact their performance and interest in physics. This dissertation concludes with a set of design principles that can foster integration and integrity among students in physics learning environments.

How to survive a physics PhD

Ph.D. in physics as a hurdle race, and the "glass hurdles" for women

How to Be a Successful Graduate Student

Producing a successful PhD thesis

Surviving Early Career Research and Beyond in the Physics of Life: A concise user guide

Physics PhD student perspectives on the importance and difficulty of finding a research group

The academic career in physics as a "deal": Choosing physics within a gendered power structure and excellence as an extra hurdle for women

On making physics relevant to society in general and to scientists in particular: Closing the epistemic gap

What PhD students really want

Progression in self-efficacy, interest, identity, sense of belonging, perceived recognition and effectiveness of peer interaction of physics majors and comparison with non-majors and Ph.D. students

How to enjoy and thrive in graduate school

Modeling when and how physics PhD students search for a research group: the role of interests and prior research experiences in timely group integration

Becoming a Physicist: The Roles of Research, Mindsets, and Milestones in upper-division student perceptions

Attitude and Motivation towards Learning Physics

Beyond The Big Bang Theory: Revealing the everyday research lives of theoretical physics faculty

The graduate school guide: How to prepare for the qualifying exam and assemble a thesis/graduate committee

The relationship between gender and academic performance in undergraduate physics students: The role of physics identity, perceived recognition, and self-efficacy

Physics graduate student employment: what we can learn from professional social media

Five Frequently Fatal Freshman Physics Fantasies

Astro2020 APC White Paper: Enabling Terminal Master's Degrees as a Step Towards a Ph.D

The roots of physics students' motivations: Fear and Integrity