Psychological intervention in Fangcang shelter hospitals for COVID-19 in China.
Ying Wang,Shiming Tang,Can Yang,Simeng Ma,Hanping Bai,Zhongxiang Cai,Hong Ma,Xudong Zhao,Gaohua Wang,Zhongchun Liu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/pcn.13149
2020-01-01
Psychiatry and Clinical Neurosciences
Abstract:thetic views and avoidant behaviors from medical staff while hospitalized. They also reported verbal abuse and the fear of contagion expressed by healthy people as well as avoidance from family, friends, colleagues, and neighbors after recovery. Furthermore, many perceived barriers in using services and employment. Emotional disturbances, such as anxiety, worries, and helplessness, were common. Survivors reported various forms of being insulted, shunned, marginalized, and rejected in different aspects of their lives, including work, familial relationships, schooling, and public services. Stigma was also prevalent in HCWs. In a study assessing 10 511 HCWs fighting against SARS, although most of them were appreciated by the society, a considerable proportion felt social stigmatization (49%) and exclusion by family members (31%). Moreover, 31% thought that people kept away from their family members because of their job. Stigma had direct and also indirect effects through stress on mental health in nurses fighting the Middle East respiratory syndrome (MERS); however, the impact of stigma on their mental health was worse compared to stress effects. Studies identified several factors contributing to stigma associated with infectious diseases, such as people’s knowledge; distribution of myths and stories by the mass and social media; and psychosocial variables, such as risk perception and fear of being infected. Outbreak-related stigma is largely based on community fear and the understanding that survivors are still contagious. Based on included studies, the consequences of health-related stigma were significant. First, stigmatization can considerably increase psychosomatic distress and disturbance. Second, stigmatization can negatively affect people with infection and those at risk of infection in seeking medical care. Infected individuals may remain undiagnosed, avoid testing and treatment efforts, and therefore jeopardize their physical and mental health, and may be more likely to infect others. This may also result in more trouble in controlling the disease for public health authorities. Third, HCWs and volunteers working in the field may also become stigmatized, leading to higher rates of distress, stress, and burnout. Finally, when people avoid groups or geographic areas related to infectious diseases, this can pose significant economic losses. Thus, stigma is more than a mere negative outcome of infectious diseases; it is both a factor that contributes to the epidemics and pandemics and a disease in itself. COVID-19 is a new disease with many unknown aspects and, naturally, people are afraid of the unknown. Fear of COVID-19 directly correlates with its rapid and invisible transmission, and its morbidity and mortality. This elevated level of fear can influence people’s rational thinking in reacting to COVID-19. Furthermore, a large amount of uncontrolled news is spreading through the media, which increases the risk of disseminating fake news more rapidly than the virus itself, causing anxiety, worries, and uncertainties that all contribute to negatives effects, such as stigma. The suggested approaches for mitigating stigma include psychological support and counseling of stigmatized patients and HCWs; developing community campaigns to convey informative messages and discouraging people from stigmatizing others; public education; ensuring that the media take accountability in news dissemination; acknowledging the presence of stigma in the COVID-19 era; and also endorsing our moral and social responsibility. Previous studies have provided clear evidence of the possibility of stigma as a result of outbreaks. Now, we are in the midst of this pandemic, and it appears that its consequences will remain for many years. In this situation, paying particular attention to the possible effects of COVID-19 causing stigma in susceptible people is vital. Anticipating disease-related stigma during the COVID-19 pandemic enables policy-makers and emergency coordinators to address it, thereby potentially restricting its adverse effects. The hidden burden caused by stigma as a result of COVID-19 can create severe consequences for patients, HCW, and public health measures. Considering the screening of stigma in all COVID-19 survivors and coordinated psychological interventions to overcome this crisis are essential.