Work engagement of psychiatric nurses: a scoping review

Tsuyoshi Mukaihata,Yuichi Kato,Toshiyuki Swa,Hirokazu Fujimoto
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2023-081941
IF: 3.006
2024-04-30
BMJ Open
Abstract:Objectives Work engagement is an essential factor in improving employee performance. However, no reviews on the work engagement of psychiatric nurses have been conducted to date. This study aimed to examine the current status of research on the work engagement of psychiatric nurses and identify salient factors. Design A scoping review. Methods This review adhered to the established scoping review methodological guidelines and the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses for Scoping Reviews checklist. The inclusion criteria were based on nurses, work engagement and psychiatric settings without language or date restrictions. Regardless of the methodology or study design, research studies related to the work engagement of psychiatric nurses have been included. A systematic search was conducted in MEDLINE, CINAHL and PsycINFO from the inception of each database, with the search strategies being set by an information specialist. The deadline for the search was 15 February 2023. Results The study included 12 studies. All studies have been published since 2013. The study designs included cross-sectional (n=10), longitudinal (n=1) and intervention (n=1) studies. The impacts of work engagement were classified into (1) attitudes towards patients, (2) attitudes towards work, (3) mental health and (4) quality of care. Factors influencing work engagement were classified into (1) demographics, (2) workplace factors, (3) individual factors and (4) patient factors. Conclusion Work engagement of psychiatric nurses has lately gained attention, although data are limited because most studies used a cross-sectional design. Psychiatric nurses with higher work engagement showed positive outcomes. Workplace and individual factors can potentially improve their work engagement. The findings can assist nursing managers in enhancing psychiatric nurses' work engagement and, consequently, their performance.
medicine, general & internal
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper primarily explores the current status and influencing factors of work engagement (WE) among psychiatric nurses. Below is a summary of the main issues this study attempts to address: ### Research Background and Objectives - **Importance of Work Engagement**: Work engagement is crucial for improving employee performance. It is defined as a positive mental state characterized by vigor, dedication, and absorption. - **Challenges Faced by Psychiatric Nurses**: Psychiatric nurses face various stressors, such as patient aggression and heavy workloads. These unique occupational characteristics may lead to decreased job performance. ### Research Objectives - **Review Current Research Status**: Given the lack of comprehensive reviews on work engagement among psychiatric nurses, this paper aims to examine the existing research on this topic and identify relevant key factors. - **Specific Research Questions**: - How many and what types of studies have been conducted to explore work engagement among psychiatric nurses? - What factors have been found to influence work engagement among psychiatric nurses? ### Main Findings - **Research Trends**: Since 2013, research on work engagement among psychiatric nurses has increased, but most studies have used cross-sectional designs. - **Influencing Factors**: - **Workplace Factors**: Factors such as the nursing practice environment and management support are positively correlated with work engagement. Good interdisciplinary team collaboration is also very important. - **Individual Factors**: Personal traits such as emotional intelligence and resilience are generally associated with work engagement. - **Patient Factors**: Although less studied, certain patient attitudes may also affect the work experience of psychiatric nurses. ### Conclusions and Recommendations - **Research Conclusions**: Despite limited data, psychiatric nurses with higher work engagement show more positive outcomes. Workplace and individual factors can potentially improve their work engagement. - **Future Directions**: Researchers should further explore the impact of patient factors on work engagement among psychiatric nurses from multiple perspectives, including positive interaction experiences between patients and nurses. Additionally, enhancing individual capabilities (such as emotional intelligence and resilience) and combining them with favorable factors in the work environment may be key strategies for effectively improving work engagement among psychiatric nurses.