The effects of a quality improvement project to reduce caesarean sections in selected private hospitals in Brazil
Maria do Carmo Leal,Rosa Maria Soares Madeira Domingues,Thaís Cristina Oliveira Fonseca,Tatiana Henriques Leite,Ana Claudia Figueiró,Ana Paula Esteves Pereira,Mariza Miranda Theme-Filha,Bárbara Vasques da Silva Ayres,Oliver Scott,Rita de Cássia Sanchez,Paulo Borem,Maria Carolina de Maio Osti,Marcos Wengrover Rosa,Amanda S Andrade,Fernando Maia Peixoto Filho,Marcos Nakamura-Pereira,Jacqueline Alves Torres
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s12978-024-01851-9
2024-09-04
Abstract:Background: Brazil is one of the countries with the highest rates of caesarean sections (CS), reaching almost 90% of births in the private sector. A quality improvement project called "Adequate Childbirth Project (PPA)" was conceived to reduce CS in the private sector. This project consisted of four primary components: "Governance", "Participation of Women", "Reorganization of Care" and "Monitoring". This paper aims to evaluate: (1) which specific activities of the PPA had the largest effect on the probability of a woman having a vaginal delivery; (2) which primary component of the PPA had the largest effect on the probability of vaginal delivery and (3) which scenarios combining the implementation of different activities planned in the PPA had a higher effect on the probability of vaginal delivery. Methods: A sample of 12 private hospitals participating in the PPA was evaluated. We used a Bayesian Network (BN) to capture both non-linearities and complex cause-effect relations. The BN integrated knowledge from experts and data from women to estimate 26 model parameters. The PPA was evaluated in 2473 women belonging to groups 1-4 of the Robson classification, who were divided into two groups: those participating or not participating in the PPA. Results: The probability of a woman having a vaginal delivery was 37.7% higher in women participating in the PPA. The most important component of the project that led to an increase in the probability of vaginal delivery was "Reorganization of Care", leading to a 73% probability of vaginal delivery among women in labor. The activity that had the greatest effect on the type of delivery was access to best practices during labor, with a 72% probability of vaginal delivery. Considering the 12 scenarios combining the different activities of the PPA, the best scenarios included: a non-scheduled delivery, access to information about best practices, access to at least 4 best practices during labor and respect of the birth plan, with an 80% probability of vaginal delivery in the best combinations. Conclusion: PPA has been shown to be an effective quality improvement program, increasing the likelihood of vaginal delivery in private Brazilian hospitals.