Distinct positions of genetic and oral histories: Perspectives from India
Arjun Biddanda,Esha Bandyopadhyay,Constanza de la Fuente Castro,David Witonsky,Jose A. Urban Aragon,Nagarjuna Pasupuleti,Hannah M. Moots,Renée Fonseca,Suzanne Freilich,Jovan Stanisavic,Tabitha Willis,Anoushka Menon,Mohammed S. Mustak,Chinnappa Dilip Kodira,Anjaparavanda P. Naren,Mithun Sikdar,Niraj Rai,Maanasa Raghavan
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2022.07.06.498959
2024-01-05
Abstract:Over the past decade, genomic data has contributed to several insights on global human population histories. These studies have been met both with interest and critically, particularly by populations with oral histories that are records of their past and often reference their origins. While several studies have reported concordance between oral and genetic histories, there is potential for tension that may stem from genetic histories being prioritized or used to confirm community-based knowledge and ethnography, especially if they differ. To investigate the interplay between oral and genetic histories, we focused on the southwestern region of India and analyzed whole-genome sequence data from 158 individuals identifying as Bunt, Kodava, Nair, and Kapla. We supplemented limited anthropological records on these populations with oral history accounts from community members and historical literature, focusing on references to non-local origins such as the ancient Scythians in the case of Bunt, Kodava, and Nair, members of Alexander the Great’s army for the Kodava, and an African-related source for Kapla. We found these populations to be genetically most similar to other Indian populations, with the Kapla more similar to South Indian tribal populations that maximize a genetic ancestry related to Andaman Islanders. We did not find evidence of additional genetic sources in the study populations than those known to have contributed to many other present-day South Asian populations. Our results demonstrate that oral and genetic histories may not always provide consistent accounts of population origins and motivate further community-engaged, multi-disciplinary investigations of non-local origin stories in these communities.
Genetics