Abstract:1. Heretofore it has been assumed that the manpower pool of the country was bottomless and induction screening was to a great extent designed to eliminate the "bad risks" and to minimize the incidence of breakdown. However, the experience of World War II suggests that the size and probable psychiatric composition of the total manpower pool are such that another large-scale mobilization will necessitate interest in marginal psychiatric groups. The evidence presented here favors the utilization of these groups in larger numbers than was the case in World War II, and a continuation of the trend away from reliance upon superficial induction screening and toward more effective utilization and prevention. 2. Since the major requirement of the armed forces is for logistic support, there is need for a more careful assessment of manpower requirements in terms of capacity to function at a wide array of particular jobs, rather than just in combat. The type of psychiatric examination that is possible at induction provides an insufficient basis for forecasting military performance and therefore cannot be relied upon to choose individuals for service; its value is confined to the elimination of only the more obviously inapt and the grossly ill. To have kept out of the Army in World War II all psychiatrically predisposed men would have cost an estimated 1,000,000 men who served without ever having been admitted to psychiatric care. 3. Those who required psychiatric care in the service, even if overtly neurotic at entry, appear to have paid their way as a group. 4. Although there is a high degree of correlation between the chance of breakdown and the degree of emotional impairment present prior to entry into service, this is also true of stress. In only 5% of the follow-up sample did breakdown occur without apparent stress, and in more than 80% of every personality group the major area of stress was a military one. 5. Groups devoid of significant psychiatric defect at entry contributed about 35% of all Army World War II admissions for all psychiatric diagnoses except psychosis, mental deficiency, and "for observation only, no disease found." In 1944 they contributed half of the admissions for psychoneurosis. 6. Within the period of modern psychiatry U. S. military operations have been preeminently offensive, overseas actions; in a defensive war at home it is possible that the psychiatric problem would be a smaller one. 7. Resistance to military stress generally, and to ground combat in particular, varies greatly with age, older men having much higher rates of admission for psychiatric Care. 8. The net effect of breakdown in service, as seen 5 years later at follow-up, is not as great as might be expected. There is relatively little change in those who were previously normal or overtly neurotic and a moderate worsening of the emotional health of those with personality disorders, neurotic traits, and suggestive neuroses. Except for those who seemed entirely normal at entry, combat seems to produce somewhat more disability than other forms of military stress. 9. Criteria for evaluating military performance seem badly needed.

Breaking Point: The Ironic Evolution of Psychiatry in World War II Reviewed

Military Traumatic Brain Injury: a Challenge Straddling Neurology and Psychiatry

SOME APPLICATIONS OF A FOLLOW-UP STUDY TO PSYCHIATRIC STANDARDS FOR MOBILIZATION

Training Military Psychiatrists to Adapt and Overcome: How COVID-19 Highlighted the Unique Flexibility of Military Psychiatry in Training and in the Fleet

Neuro psychiatry 1943: the role of documentary film in the dissemination of medical knowledge and promotion of the U.K. psychiatric profession

A Foundation for a “Cheerful Society”: The Korean War and the Rise of Psychiatry

On Being Sane in Insane Places

[Psychiatric textbooks from National Socialism and the censorial practice in the Soviet Occupation Zone and early GDR]

War Imprisonment and Clinical Narratives of Psychiatric Illness, Psychiatric Hospital Charité, Berlin, 1948-1956

The compulsory psychiatric regime in Hong Kong: Constitutional and ethical perspectives

Happy times, careers and happenstance in UK psychiatry: time, timeliness, timelessness, eternity and contemporality

The Psychiatric Profession: an Expertise Under Siege?

Wake-up call for British psychiatry

A Black and White History of Psychiatry in the United States

Review of mental healthcare provision by primary care physicians in the Department of Defense (DoD)

Harm Through Stigma: Commander Notification of Service Members' Mental Health

Exploring Options Including Class Action to Transform Military Mental Healthcare and End the Generational Cycle of Preventable Wartime Behavioral Health Crises

History of military psychology

Generational Wartime Behavioral Health Crises: Part One of a Preliminary Analysis

[As a Child of a Parent with Schizophrenia, as a Patient, and as a Psychiatrist: A Message to All JSPN Members]

'A disastrous blow': psychiatric risk, social indicators and medical authority in abortion reform in post-war Britain