Abstract:In recent years, the debate has continued among researchers and instructors regarding the influence of Problem-Based Learning (PBL) on the effectiveness of instructional intervention for Critical Thinking (CT) in higher education. This study, conducting a meta-analysis by synthesizing 50 relevant empirical studies from 2000 to 2021 with 5,210 participants and 58 effect sizes, aims to present potential factors (i.e., sample size, sample type, instruction type, gender, maturity, instrument, nationality, discipline, treatment duration, and group size) that may influence the effectiveness of the cultivation of CT skills and disposition on the basis of PBL. No evident publication bias was found (Egger's bias = 1.21, p > 0.05). From the general perspective, the results demonstrate the high level of influence of PBL (Standardized Mean Difference [SMD] = 0.640, p < 0.001) on CT with heterogeneity (I2 = 82.9%) due to the adopted instruments, mixed methods, and target outcomes, and no difference was observed between influence on CT skills and disposition. Students' maturity, nationality, sample type, instruction type, and group size are influencing factors of overall CT. The effects of intervention for seniors, western students, randomized samples, online instruction, and groups with less than six members are better, whereas short-term intervention is ineffective. For CT skills, the treatments for juniors and groups with less than six members are ineffective, and sample type and instruction type are not influencing factors. However, the effect sizes of big sample sizes, seniors, other kinds of instruments, western students, Sciences as a discipline, more than ten members in a group, and long-term intervention are stronger. For CT disposition, sample type, instruction type, discipline, and intervention duration are influencing factors, in which randomized samples, online instruction, students in Medicine, and medium-term intervention exerted a stronger effect than the other factors. In conclusion, although PBL is overall effective for promoting the acquisition of CT (skills and disposition), additional studies are also required to explore the effectiveness and influencing factors in other contexts, such as various learning or teaching strategies, environments, and scaffoldings, and scenario-problem-based tasks instead of only curriculum-based ones. These factors should also be considered to promote CT skills and disposition among undergraduates.

Measuring Critical Thinking in Problem-Based Learning Discourse

Exploring Debaters and Audiences' Depth of Critical Thinking and Its Relationship with Their Participation in Debate Activities

Effects of problem-based learning instructional intervention on critical thinking in higher education: A meta-analysis

Computer-based performance approach for critical thinking assessment in children

Exploring the Effectiveness of Problem-Based Learning as a Constructivist Approach in Enhancing Critical Thinking Skills in High School Classes

Influence of critical thinking disposition on the learning efficiency of problem-based learning in undergraduate medical students

Assessing Students' Computational Thinking In A Learning By Modeling Environment

Situating Higher-Order, Critical, and Critical-Analytic Thinking in Problem- and Project-Based Learning Environments: A Systematic Review

Do we teach critical thinking? A mixed methods study of faculty and student perceptions of teaching and learning critical thinking at three professional schools

The Influence of PBL Teaching Mode on Critical Thinking Ability for Non-English Majors under Network Environment

Problem-based Interactive Physics E-Module in Physics Learning Through Blended PBL to Enhance Students' Critical Thinking Skills

Problem-Based Learning Materials in Upskilling Mathematics Critical Thinking Skills

A review of Project-Based Learning (PBL) and Computational Thinking (CT) in teaching and learning

Computational thinking with game design: An action research study with middle school students

Integrating the Problem-Based Learning Approach Into a Web-Based English Reading Course

Measuring Computational Thinking Teaching Efficacy Beliefs of Preservice Elementary Teachers

Enhancing Critical Thinking Skills through Decision-Based Learning

Concept map analysis in the assessment of speech-language pathology students' learning in a problem-based learning curriculum: a longitudinal study

Transcript-Based Lesson Analysis: The Analysis of Classroom Communication in Chemistry Implementing Case-Based and Project-Based Learning

Active teaching model to promote critical thinking.