Academic Stress Interventions in High Schools: A Systematic Literature Review

Tess Jagiello,Jessica Belcher,Aswathi Neelakandan,Kaylee Boyd,Viviana M. Wuthrich

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10578-024-01667-5

2024-03-04

Child Psychiatry & Human Development

Abstract:Abstract The experience of academic stress is common during high school and can have significant negative consequences for students’ educational achievement and wellbeing. High school students frequently report heightened levels of school-related distress, particularly as they approach high-stakes assessments. Programs designed to reduce or prevent academic stress are needed, and their delivery in school settings is ideal to improve treatment access. The current review aimed to examine the effectiveness of high school-based programs in reducing or preventing academic stress. A systematic search returned 31 eligible studies across 13 countries. Programs were categorised according to intervention type, format, and facilitator. Results showed that the methodological quality of most studies was poor, and many used an inactive control group. As predicted by theories of academic stress, the strongest evidence was for programs grounded in cognitive-behavioural therapy (CBT). There was evidence that both universal and targeted approaches can be beneficial. The unique implementation issues for these two formats are discussed. Most programs were delivered by psychologists and were generally effective, but almost all of these were CBT programs. A smaller proportion of programs delivered by teachers were effective. Therefore, future studies should evaluate the implementation success of programs to improve the rate of effective delivery by school staff. Overall, the field will benefit from more randomised controlled trials with comparisons to active control groups, larger sample sizes and longer-term follow-ups.

psychiatry,psychology, developmental

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the issue of the intervention effects on academic stress among high school students. Specifically, this systematic literature review aims to evaluate whether programs implemented in high school settings can effectively reduce or prevent students' academic stress. The research background indicates that high school students often face high levels of academic stress, especially before high-stakes exams, which not only affects their academic performance but may also have negative impacts on mental health, emotional state, sleep quality, self-confidence, motivation, and even physical health. Therefore, finding effective interventions to alleviate this stress is very important.

The main objectives of the paper include:
1. **Evaluating the effectiveness of existing intervention programs**: Through systematic literature search, determine which types of intervention programs are most effective in reducing or preventing academic stress.
2. **Analyzing the characteristics of different types of interventions**: Classify intervention programs by type (e.g., cognitive-behavioral therapy), format (e.g., universal and targeted), and implementers (e.g., psychologists and teachers), and assess their effectiveness.
3. **Exploring future research directions**: Identify the shortcomings in current research, such as low methodological quality and inactive control groups, and propose improvements to enhance the quality and effectiveness of future research.

Overall, the paper hopes to provide scientific evidence for schools to select effective academic stress intervention programs through a systematic literature review, thereby helping students better cope with academic stress during high school.