Abstract:Timbre is a central quality of singing, yet remains a complex notion poorly understood in psychoacoustic studies. Previous studies note how no single acoustic variable or combinations of variables consistently predict timbre dimensions. Timbre varies on a continuum from darkest to lightest. These extremes are associated with laryngeal and vocal tract adjustments related to smaller and larger vocal tract area and variations in vocal fold vibratory characteristics. Perceptually, timbre assessment is influenced by spectral characteristics and formant frequency adjustments, though these dimensions are not independently perceived. Perceptual studies repeatedly demonstrate difficulties in correlating variations in timbre stimuli to specific measures. A recent study demonstrated how acoustic predictive salience of voice category and voice weight across pitches contribute to timbre assessments and concludes that timbre may be related to as-of-yet unknown factor(s). The purpose of this study was to test four different models for assessing timbre; one model focused on specific anatomy, one on listener intuition, one utilizing auditory anchors, and one using expert raters in a deconstructed timbre model with five specific dimensions. Methods: Four independent panels were conducted with separate cohorts of professional singing teachers. Forty-one assessors took part in the anatomically focused panel, 54 in the intuition-based panel, 30 in the anchored panel, and 12 in the expert listener panel. Stimuli taken from live performances of well-known singers were used for all panels, representing all genders, genres, and styles across a large pitch range. All stimuli are available as Supplementary Materials. Fleiss' kappa values, descriptive statistics, and significance tests are reported for all panel assessments. Results: Panels 1 through 4 varied in overall accuracy and agreement. The intuition-based model showed overall 45% average accuracy (SD ± 4%), k = 0.289 (<0.001) compared to overall 71% average accuracy (SD ± 3%), k = 0.368 (<0.001) of the anatomical focused panel. The auditory-anchored model showed overall 75% average accuracy (SD ± 8%), k = 0.54 (<0.001) compared with overall 83% average accuracy and agreement of k = 0.63 (<0.001) for panel 4. Results revealed that the highest accuracy and reliability were achieved in a deconstructed timbre model and that providing anchoring improved reliability but with no further increase in accuracy. Conclusion: Deconstructing timbre into specific parameters improved auditory perceptual accuracy and overall agreement. Assessing timbre along with other perceptual dimensions improves accuracy and reliability. Panel assessors' expert level of listening skills remain an important factor in obtaining reliable and accurate assessments of auditory stimuli for timbre dimensions. Anchoring improved reliability but with no further increase in accuracy. The study suggests that timbre assessment can be improved by approaching the percept through a prism of five specific dimensions each related to specific physiology and auditory-perceptual subcategories. Further tests are needed with framework-naïve listeners, nonmusically educated listeners, artificial intelligence comparisons, and synthetic stimuli to further test the reliability.

Select Acoustic and Perceptual Measures of Choral Formation

Evaluating acoustical qualities of four rooms using questionnaires

A Longitudinal Study of Intonation in an a cappella Singing Quintet

An Exploratory Study on Perceptual Spaces of the Singing Voice

Listener perception of changes in historically informed performance of solo baroque music due to room acoustics

Singing in different performance spaces: The effect of room acoustics on singers' perception

Secondary School Choral Conductors’ Self-Reported Beliefs and Behaviors Related to Fundamental Choral Elements and Rehearsal Approaches

Auditory perceptual assessment of voices: Examining perceptual ratings as a function of voice experience

Capturing differences in perception and aesthetic judgment of live or medially presented music: development of a self-report instrument

Can Genre Be "Heard" in Scale as Well as Song Tasks? An Exploratory Study of Female Singing in Western Lyric and Musical Theater Styles

Across-Channel Auditory Gap Detection

Undergraduate Choral Conducting Courses: Examining Students’ Practice Behaviors and Instructors’ Pedagogy

Multimodal Standardization of Voice among Four Multicultural Populations Formant Structures.

Perceptual (but not acoustic) features predict singing voice preferences

Relative salience of chord-type and chord-voicing changes: A two-oddball paradigm

Towards Improved Auditory-Perceptual Assessment of Timbres: Comparing Accuracy and Reliability of Four Deconstructed Timbre Assessment Models

What Determines the Perception of Segmentation in Contemporary Music?

Articulatory and acoustic differences between lyric and dramatic singing in Western classical music

Can Inexperienced Listeners Hear Who Is Singing? The Role of Motivation in Singer Discrimination Across Pitch

Speech formant changes due to repeated measurements, instruction, and simulated environments using both automated and manual feature extraction

Effects of Score Study on Novices’ Conducting and Rehearsing: A Preliminary Investigation