A neural network approach to understanding implied volatility movements

Jay Cao,Jacky Chen,John Hull

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/14697688.2020.1750679

IF: 1.986

2020-05-14

Quantitative Finance

Abstract:The expected response of an index volatility surface to index movements is quite different in high and low volatility environments

economics,social sciences, mathematical methods,mathematics, interdisciplinary applications,business, finance

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Gated deep neural networks for implied volatility surfaces

Yongxin Yang,Yu Zheng,Bowei Chen

2019-04-29

Abstract:This paper presents a framework of developing neural networks to predict implied volatility surfaces. It can incorporate the related properties from existing mathematical models and empirical findings, including no static arbitrage, limiting boundaries, asymptotic slope and volatility smile. These properties are also satisfied empirically in our experiments with the option data on the S&P 500 index over 20 years. The developed neural network model outperforms the widely used surface stochastic volatility inspired (SSVI) model and other benchmarked neural network models on the mean average percentage error in both in-sample and out-of-sample datasets. This study has two major contributions. First, it contributes to the recent use of machine learning in finance, and an accurate deep learning implied volatility surface prediction model is obtained. Second, it provides the methodological guidance on how to seamlessly combine data-driven models with domain knowledge in the development of machine learning applications.

Economics,Mathematics,Business,Computer Science
A neural network enhanced volatility component model

Jia Zhai,Yi Cao,Xiaoquan Liu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/14697688.2019.1711148

IF: 1.986

2020-02-19

Quantitative Finance

Abstract:Volatility prediction, a central issue in financial econometrics, attracts increasing attention in the data science literature as advances in computational methods enable us to develop models with great forecasting precision. In this paper, we draw upon both strands of the literature and develop a novel two-component volatility model. The realized volatility is decomposed by a nonparametric filter into long- and short-run components, which are modeled by an artificial neural network and an ARMA process, respectively. We use intraday data on four major exchange rates and a Chinese stock index to construct daily realized volatility and perform out-of-sample evaluation of volatility forecasts generated by our model and well-established alternatives. Empirical results show that our model outperforms alternative models across all statistical metrics and over different forecasting horizons. Furthermore, volatility forecasts from our model offer economic gain to a mean-variance utility investor with higher portfolio returns and Sharpe ratio.

economics,social sciences, mathematical methods,mathematics, interdisciplinary applications,business, finance
Implied volatility surfaces: a comprehensive analysis using half a billion option prices

Maxim Ulrich,Lukas Zimmer,Constantin Merbecks

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11147-023-09195-5

2023-10-02

Review of Derivatives Research

Abstract:This study delves into the critical aspect of accurately estimating single stock volatility surfaces, a task indispensable for option pricing, risk management, and empirical asset pricing. Utilizing a comprehensive dataset consisting of half a billion daily price observations for options on 499 US individual stocks and the S&P 500, the research investigates the accuracy of diverse methods for constructing volatility surfaces. The comparative evaluation of the three-dimensional kernel smoother by OptionMetrics (IvyDB US file and data reference manual, version 5.2, Rev. 01/27/2022, Computer software manual, New York, 2022), the semi-parametric spline by Figlewski (in: Robert F. Engle (ed) Estimating the implied risk neutral density. Volatility and time series econometrics: Essays in honor, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2008), and a refined one-dimensional kernel smoother reveals the distinct superiority of the latter. This method consistently outperforms its counterparts across all moneyness, maturity, and liquidity categories, with markedly lower error metrics. The study further uncovers significant distortions in the extraction of Bakshi et al. (Rev Financ Stud 16:101–143, 2003) moments and skewness spanning induced by the noise-infused three-dimensional kernel smoother, which could potentially mislead derivative pricing and trading decisions. The findings offer valuable insights to traders, risk managers, investors, and researchers, suggesting a robust, one-size-fits-all method for crafting more accurate and less noisy volatility predictions. The research advances our understanding of option-implied information, its extraction, and broader implications for financial markets.

economics,business, finance
Deep Smoothing of the Implied Volatility Surface

Damien Ackerer,Natasa Tagasovska,Thibault Vatter

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1906.05065

2019-06-12

Pricing of Securities

Abstract:We present a neural network (NN) approach to fit and predict implied volatility surfaces (IVSs). Atypically to standard NN applications, financial industry practitioners use such models equally to replicate market prices and to value other financial instruments. In other words, low training losses are as important as generalization capabilities. Importantly, IVS models need to generate realistic arbitrage-free option prices, meaning that no portfolio can lead to risk-free profits. We propose an approach guaranteeing the absence of arbitrage opportunities by penalizing the loss using soft constraints. Furthermore, our method can be combined with standard IVS models in quantitative finance, thus providing a NN-based correction when such models fail at replicating observed market prices. This lets practitioners use our approach as a plug-in on top of classical methods. Empirical results show that this approach is particularly useful when only sparse or erroneous data are available. We also quantify the uncertainty of the model predictions in regions with few or no observations. We further explore how deeper NNs improve over shallower ones, as well as other properties of the network architecture. We benchmark our method against standard IVS models. By evaluating our method on both training sets, and testing sets, namely, we highlight both their capacity to reproduce observed prices and predict new ones.
Deep Learning Volatility

Blanka Horvath,Aitor Muguruza,Mehdi Tomas

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1901.09647

2019-08-23

Abstract:We present a neural network based calibration method that performs the calibration task within a few milliseconds for the full implied volatility surface. The framework is consistently applicable throughout a range of volatility models -including the rough volatility family- and a range of derivative contracts. The aim of neural networks in this work is an off-line approximation of complex pricing functions, which are difficult to represent or time-consuming to evaluate by other means. We highlight how this perspective opens new horizons for quantitative modelling: The calibration bottleneck posed by a slow pricing of derivative contracts is lifted. This brings several numerical pricers and model families (such as rough volatility models) within the scope of applicability in industry practice. The form in which information from available data is extracted and stored influences network performance: This approach is inspired by representing the implied volatility and option prices as a collection of pixels. In a number of applications we demonstrate the prowess of this modelling approach regarding accuracy, speed, robustness and generality and also its potentials towards model recognition.

Mathematical Finance
Deep Learning from Implied Volatility Surfaces

Bryan T. Kelly,Boris Kuznetsov,Semyon Malamud,Teng Andrea Xu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4531181

2023-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:We develop a novel methodology for extracting information from option implied volatility (IV) surfaces for the cross-section of stock returns, using image recognition techniques from machine learning (ML). The predictive information we identify is essentially uncorrelated with most of the existing option-implied characteristics, delivers a higher Sharpe ratio, and has a significant alpha relative to a battery of standard and option-implied factors. We show the virtue of ensemble complexity: Best results are achieved with a large ensemble of ML models, with the out-of-sample performance increasing in the ensemble size, saturating when the number of model parameters significantly exceeds the number of observations. We introduce principal linear features, an analog of principal components for ML and use them to show IV feature complexity: A low-rank rotation of the IV surface cannot explain the model performance. Our results are robust to short-sale constraints and transaction costs.
The VIX index under scrutiny of machine learning techniques and neural networks

Ali Hirsa,Joerg Osterrieder,Branka Hadji Misheva,Wenxin Cao,Yiwen Fu,Hanze Sun,Kin Wai Wong

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2102.02119

2021-02-03

Abstract:The CBOE Volatility Index, known by its ticker symbol VIX, is a popular measure of the market's expected volatility on the SP 500 Index, calculated and published by the Chicago Board Options Exchange (CBOE). It is also often referred to as the fear index or the fear gauge. The current VIX index value quotes the expected annualized change in the SP 500 index over the following 30 days, based on options-based theory and current options-market data. Despite its theoretical foundation in option price theory, CBOE's Volatility Index is prone to inadvertent and deliberate errors because it is weighted average of out-of-the-money calls and puts which could be illiquid. Many claims of market manipulation have been brought up against VIX in recent years. This paper discusses several approaches to replicate the VIX index as well as VIX futures by using a subset of relevant options as well as neural networks that are trained to automatically learn the underlying formula. Using subset selection approaches on top of the original CBOE methodology, as well as building machine learning and neural network models including Random Forests, Support Vector Machines, feed-forward neural networks, and long short-term memory (LSTM) models, we will show that a small number of options is sufficient to replicate the VIX index. Once we are able to actually replicate the VIX using a small number of SP options we will be able to exploit potential arbitrage opportunities between the VIX index and its underlying derivatives. The results are supposed to help investors to better understand the options market, and more importantly, to give guidance to the US regulators and CBOE that have been investigating those manipulation claims for several years.

General Finance,Trading and Market Microstructure
Pricing Options and Computing Implied Volatilities using Neural Networks

Shuaiqiang Liu,Cornelis W. Oosterlee,Sander M. Bohte,Cornelis Oosterlee,Sander Bohte

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/risks7010016

2019-02-09

Risks

Abstract:This paper proposes a data-driven approach, by means of an Artificial Neural Network (ANN), to value financial options and to calculate implied volatilities with the aim of accelerating the corresponding numerical methods. With ANNs being universal function approximators, this method trains an optimized ANN on a data set generated by a sophisticated financial model, and runs the trained ANN as an agent of the original solver in a fast and efficient way. We test this approach on three different types of solvers, including the analytic solution for the Black-Scholes equation, the COS method for the Heston stochastic volatility model and Brent’s iterative root-finding method for the calculation of implied volatilities. The numerical results show that the ANN solver can reduce the computing time significantly.
On Calibration Neural Networks for extracting implied information from American options

Shuaiqiang Liu,Álvaro Leitao,Anastasia Borovykh,Cornelis W. Oosterlee

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2001.11786

2020-01-31

Computational Finance

Abstract:Extracting implied information, like volatility and/or dividend, from observed option prices is a challenging task when dealing with American options, because of the computational costs needed to solve the corresponding mathematical problem many thousands of times. We will employ a data-driven machine learning approach to estimate the Black-Scholes implied volatility and the dividend yield for American options in a fast and robust way. To determine the implied volatility, the inverse function is approximated by an artificial neural network on the computational domain of interest, which decouples the offline (training) and online (prediction) phases and thus eliminates the need for an iterative process. For the implied dividend yield, we formulate the inverse problem as a calibration problem and determine simultaneously the implied volatility and dividend yield. For this, a generic and robust calibration framework, the Calibration Neural Network (CaNN), is introduced to estimate multiple parameters. It is shown that machine learning can be used as an efficient numerical technique to extract implied information from American options.
Option Volatility Investment Strategy: The Combination of Neural Network and Classical Volatility Prediction Model

Yuanyang Teng,Yicun Li,Xiaobo Wu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1155/2022/8952996

IF: 1.4

2022-04-07

Discrete Dynamics in Nature and Society

Abstract:This study focuses on the volatility prediction and option volatility investment. By investigating the traditional Volatility Prediction Model and machine learning algorithms, this study tries to merge these two aspects together. This work setup a bridge of previous financial studies and machine learning studies by proposing an algorithm integrating neural network and three traditional volatility models, called “Quantile based neural network and model integration combination algorithm.” The algorithm effectively lowers the volatility prediction error (measured by root of mean square error, shorted for RMSE: 0.319724) and beat the Wavenet (RMSE: 0.44) which is the benchmark and surpasses integrated model (RMSE: 0.348346) in test set. In terms of option investment strategy, this paper constructs a CSI 300 index option portfolio which hedges the underlying asset price risk and exposes the volatility risk. Then propose the “Option strategy of volatility prediction with dynamic thresholds.” With the new algorithm above, the strategy improves the return-risk ratio in test set (measured by Sharpe ratio: 1.99–2.07).

mathematics, interdisciplinary applications,multidisciplinary sciences
Do artificial neural networks provide improved volatility forecasts: Evidence from Asian markets

Mehmet Sahiner,David G. McMillan,Dimos Kambouroudis

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12197-023-09629-8

2023-05-16

Journal of Economics and Finance

Abstract:This paper enters the ongoing volatility forecasting debate by examining the ability of a wide range of Machine Learning methods (ML), and specifically Artificial Neural Network (ANN) models. The ANN models are compared against traditional econometric models for ten Asian markets using daily data for the time period from 12 September 1994 to 05 March 2018. The empirical results indicate that ML algorithms, across the range of countries, can better approximate dependencies compared to traditional benchmark models. Notably, the predictive performance of such deep learning models is superior perhaps due to its ability in capturing long-range dependencies. For example, the Neuro Fuzzy models of ANFIS and CANFIS, which outperform the EGARCH model, are more flexible in modelling both asymmetry and long memory properties. This offers new insights for Asian markets. In addition to standard statistics forecast metrics, we also consider risk management measures including the value-at-risk (VaR) average failure rate, the Kupiec LR test, the Christoffersen independence test, the expected shortfall (ES) and the dynamic quantile test. The study concludes that ML algorithms provide improving volatility forecasts in the stock markets of Asia and suggest that this may be a fruitful approach for risk management.
Market Sentiment Analysis Based on Image Processing With Put-Call Volatility Gap Surface

Yuanyuan Qi,Guoxiang Guo,Yang Wang,Jerome Yen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/tcss.2022.3224054

2022-01-01

IEEE Transactions on Computational Social Systems

Abstract:Analyzing the market sentiment and forecasting movements in asset prices is extremely important and has been attempted by researchers and market practitioners. Asset volatilities, regardless of historical ones or implied from the option prices, are crucial barometers of the market. And this research proposes a new approach that combines image processing and machine learning to capture the relationships between sentiment-related features and asset movement. The proposed research is based on the tick-level SPY options transactions, and the dataset contains around 1.5 million trading records. Specially, we obtained the gap between the call surface and the put surface as the second-level implied volatility surface (IVS). After adopting the traditional convolutional neural network (CNN) to compare the predictive effects among implied volatility (IV) call surface, IV put surface, and IV gap surface, the results indicate that the IV gap provides the most significant predictability. Besides, our project creatively proposes the interframe difference approach to optimized CNN and a recurrent CNN (RCNN) to fully utilize spatial and temporal features of the IV surface data. According to experiment results, the directional accuracy of prediction ranges from 67.20% to 72.05% for asset movement forecasting at the millisecond level.
FuNVol: A Multi-Asset Implied Volatility Market Simulator using Functional Principal Components and Neural SDEs

Vedant Choudhary,Sebastian Jaimungal,Maxime Bergeron

2023-12-27

Abstract:We introduce a new approach for generating sequences of implied volatility (IV) surfaces across multiple assets that is faithful to historical prices. We do so using a combination of functional data analysis and neural stochastic differential equations (SDEs) combined with a probability integral transform penalty to reduce model misspecification. We demonstrate that learning the joint dynamics of IV surfaces and prices produces market scenarios that are consistent with historical features and lie within the sub-manifold of surfaces that are essentially free of static arbitrage. Finally, we demonstrate that delta hedging using the simulated surfaces generates profit and loss (P&L) distributions that are consistent with realised P&Ls.

Computational Finance,Machine Learning,Statistical Finance
Implied volatility surface predictability: The case of commodity markets

Fearghal Kearney,Han Lin Shang,Lisa Sheenan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbankfin.2019.105657

2019-11-01

Abstract:<p>Recent literature seek to forecast implied volatility derived from equity, index, foreign exchange, and interest rate options using latent factor and parametric frameworks. Motivated by increased public attention borne out of the financialization of futures markets in the early 2000s, we investigate if these extant models can uncover predictable patterns in the implied volatility surfaces of the most actively traded commodity options between 2006 and 2016. Adopting a rolling out-of-sample forecasting framework that addresses the common multiple comparisons problem, we establish that, for energy and precious metals options, explicitly modeling the term structure of implied volatility using the Nelson-Siegel factors produces the most accurate forecasts.</p>

economics,business, finance
Operator Deep Smoothing for Implied Volatility

Lukas Gonon,Antoine Jacquier,Ruben Wiedemann

2024-10-09

Abstract:We devise a novel method for nowcasting implied volatility based on neural operators. Better known as implied volatility smoothing in the financial industry, nowcasting of implied volatility means constructing a smooth surface that is consistent with the prices presently observed on a given option market. Option price data arises highly dynamically in ever-changing spatial configurations, which poses a major limitation to foundational machine learning approaches using classical neural networks. While large models in language and image processing deliver breakthrough results on vast corpora of raw data, in financial engineering the generalization from big historical datasets has been hindered by the need for considerable data pre-processing. In particular, implied volatility smoothing has remained an instance-by-instance, hands-on process both for neural network-based and traditional parametric strategies. Our general operator deep smoothing approach, instead, directly maps observed data to smoothed surfaces. We adapt the graph neural operator architecture to do so with high accuracy on ten years of raw intraday S&P 500 options data, using a single model instance. The trained operator adheres to critical no-arbitrage constraints and is robust with respect to subsampling of inputs (occurring in practice in the context of outlier removal). We provide extensive historical benchmarks and showcase the generalization capability of our approach in a comparison with classical neural networks and SVI, an industry standard parametrization for implied volatility. The operator deep smoothing approach thus opens up the use of neural networks on large historical datasets in financial engineering.

Computational Finance
Beyond Surrogate Modeling: Learning the Local Volatility Via Shape Constraints

Marc Chataigner,Areski Cousin,Stéphane Crépey,Matthew Dixon,Djibril Gueye

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2212.09957

2022-12-20

Mathematical Finance

Abstract:We explore the abilities of two machine learning approaches for no-arbitrage interpolation of European vanilla option prices, which jointly yield the corresponding local volatility surface: a finite dimensional Gaussian process (GP) regression approach under no-arbitrage constraints based on prices, and a neural net (NN) approach with penalization of arbitrages based on implied volatilities. We demonstrate the performance of these approaches relative to the SSVI industry standard. The GP approach is proven arbitrage-free, whereas arbitrages are only penalized under the SSVI and NN approaches. The GP approach obtains the best out-of-sample calibration error and provides uncertainty quantification.The NN approach yields a smoother local volatility and a better backtesting performance, as its training criterion incorporates a local volatility regularization term.
An Improved Differential Approach to Computing Implied Volatility——Implied Volatility Surface Model

ZHANG Ai-ling,WU Chong-feng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3321/j.issn:1006-2467.2007.12.017

2007-01-01

Abstract:Former researchers only concentrated on strike price affected implied volatility when computing implied volatility and neglected the effect of expiration.To calculate volatility,this paper proposed an implied volatility surface model including expiration and strike price of options.The numerical calculation shows the implied volatility surface model has improved the estimated precision of volatility.At the same time,the model can give the characters of volatility sneer and term structure of volatility.Investors can apply it in derivative securities market.
FuNVol: multi-asset implied volatility market simulator using functional principal components and neural SDEs

Vedant Choudhary,Sebastian Jaimungal,Maxime Bergeron

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/14697688.2024.2396977

IF: 1.986

2024-09-28

Quantitative Finance

Abstract:We introduce a new approach for generating sequences of implied volatility (IV) surfaces across multiple assets that are faithful to historical prices. We do so using a combination of functional data analysis and neural stochastic differential equations (SDEs) combined with a probability integral transform penalty to reduce model misspecification. We demonstrate that learning the joint dynamics of IV surfaces and prices produces market scenarios that are consistent with historical features and lie within the sub-manifold of surfaces that are essentially free of static arbitrage. Finally, we demonstrate that delta hedging using the simulated surfaces generates profit and loss (P&L) distributions that are consistent with realized P&Ls.

economics,social sciences, mathematical methods,mathematics, interdisciplinary applications,business, finance
On short-time behavior of implied volatility in a market model with indexes

Huy N. Chau,Duy Nguyen,Thai Nguyen

2024-04-08

Abstract:This paper investigates short-term behaviors of implied volatility of derivatives written on indexes in equity markets when the index processes are constructed by using a ranking procedure. Even in simple market settings where stock prices follow geometric Brownian motion dynamics, the ranking mechanism can produce the observed term structure of at-the-money (ATM) implied volatility skew for equity indexes. Our proposed models showcase the ability to reconcile two seemingly contradictory features found in empirical data from equity markets: the long memory of volatilities and the power law of ATM skews. Furthermore, the models allow for the capture of a novel phenomenon termed the quasi-blow-up phenomenon.

Pricing of Securities
Using Machine Learning to Predict Realized Variance

Peter Carr,Liuren Wu,Zhibai Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1909.10035

2019-09-22

Mathematical Finance

Abstract:In this paper we formulate a regression problem to predict realized volatility by using option price data and enhance VIX-styled volatility indices' predictability and liquidity. We test algorithms including regularized regression and machine learning methods such as Feedforward Neural Networks (FNN) on S&P 500 Index and its option data. By conducting a time series validation we find that both Ridge regression and FNN can improve volatility indexing with higher prediction performance and fewer options required. The best approach found is to predict the difference between the realized volatility and the VIX-styled index's prediction rather than to predict the realized volatility directly, representing a successful combination of human learning and machine learning. We also discuss suitability of different regression algorithms for volatility indexing and applications of our findings.

A neural network approach to understanding implied volatility movements

Gated deep neural networks for implied volatility surfaces

A neural network enhanced volatility component model

Implied volatility surfaces: a comprehensive analysis using half a billion option prices

Deep Smoothing of the Implied Volatility Surface

Deep Learning Volatility

Deep Learning from Implied Volatility Surfaces

The VIX index under scrutiny of machine learning techniques and neural networks

Pricing Options and Computing Implied Volatilities using Neural Networks

On Calibration Neural Networks for extracting implied information from American options

Option Volatility Investment Strategy: The Combination of Neural Network and Classical Volatility Prediction Model

Do artificial neural networks provide improved volatility forecasts: Evidence from Asian markets

Market Sentiment Analysis Based on Image Processing With Put-Call Volatility Gap Surface

FuNVol: A Multi-Asset Implied Volatility Market Simulator using Functional Principal Components and Neural SDEs

Implied volatility surface predictability: The case of commodity markets

Operator Deep Smoothing for Implied Volatility

Beyond Surrogate Modeling: Learning the Local Volatility Via Shape Constraints

An Improved Differential Approach to Computing Implied Volatility——Implied Volatility Surface Model

FuNVol: multi-asset implied volatility market simulator using functional principal components and neural SDEs

On short-time behavior of implied volatility in a market model with indexes

Using Machine Learning to Predict Realized Variance