Abstract:Neurobiological evidence in rodents indicates that threat extinction incorporates reward neurocircuitry. Consequently, incorporating reward associations with an extinction memory may be an effective strategy to persistently attenuate threat responses. Moreover, while there is considerable research on the short-term effects of extinction strategies in humans, the long-term effects of extinction are rarely considered. In a within-subjects fMRI study with both female and male participants, we compared counterconditioning (CC; a form of rewarded-extinction) to standard extinction at recent (24 h) and remote (approximately one month) retrieval tests. Relative to standard extinction, rewarded extinction diminished 24-h relapse of arousal and threat expectancy, and reduced activity in brain regions associated with the appraisal and expression of threat (e.g., thalamus, insula, periaqueductal gray). The retrieval of reward-associated extinction memory was accompanied by functional connectivity between the amygdala and the ventral striatum, whereas the retrieval of standard-extinction memories was associated with connectivity between the amygdala and ventromedial prefrontal cortex (vmPFC). One month later, the retrieval of both standard-extinction and rewarded-extinction was associated with amygdala-vmPFC connectivity. However, only rewarded extinction created a stable memory trace in the vmPFC, identified through overlapping multivariate patterns of fMRI activity from extinction to 24-h and one-month retrieval. These findings provide new evidence that reward may generate a more stable and enduring memory trace of attenuated threat in humans.SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT Prevalent treatments for pathologic fear and anxiety are based on the principles of Pavlovian extinction. Unfortunately, extinction forms weak memories that only temporarily inhibit the retrieval of threat associations. Thus, to increase the translational relevance of extinction research, it is critical to investigate whether extinction can be augmented to form a more enduring memory, especially after long intervals. Here, we used a multiday fMRI paradigm in humans to compare the short-term and long-term neurobehavioral effects of aversive-to-appetitive counterconditioning (CC), a form of augmented extinction. Our results provide novel evidence that including an appetitive stimulus during extinction can reduce short-term threat relapse and stabilize the memory trace of extinction in the ventromedial prefrontal cortex (vmPFC), for at least one month after learning.

Occasional Reinforced Extinction as a Method for Relapse Prevention: A Critical Systematic Review and Future Directions

Slower reacquisition after partial extinction in human contingency learning.

Leveraging occasional reinforced extinction via mental imagery of the unconditioned stimulus to optimize extinction learning

A systematic review of enhanced resurgence paradigms

Resurgence mitigation across extended extinction following four and eight cycles of on/off alternative reinforcement

Out with the bad, in with the good: A review on augmented extinction learning in humans

Conflict Dynamics of Post-Retrieval Extinction: A Comparative Analysis of Unconditional and Conditional Reminders Using Skin Conductance Responses and EEG

Harnessing reconsolidation to weaken fear and appetitive memories: A meta-analysis of post-retrieval extinction effects.

A Replication of a Nonsequential Renewal Model and a Failure to Attenuate Nonsequential Renewal with Extinction Cues

Reinforcer value moderates response magnitude and persistence during extinction: A randomized trial

Enhancing Fear Extinction: Pharmacological Approaches

Rewarded Extinction Increases Amygdalar Connectivity and Stabilizes Long-Term Memory Traces in the vmPFC

Rodent models of impaired fear extinction

Explaining the effectiveness of fear extinction through latent-cause inference

Increasing previous but not concurrent extinction attenuates the "extinction makes acquisition context specific" effect in human predictive learning.

Persistence during extinction: examining the effects of continuous and intermittent reinforcement on problem behavior

Contextual modulation of human associative learning following novelty-facilitated extinction, counterconditioning, and conventional extinction.

ConFER: A Neurally Constrained Computational Model of Context-Dependent Fear Extinction Recall and Relapse

Descriptive characteristics of extinction bursts: A record review

Extinction and beyond: an expanded framework for exposure and response prevention for obsessive-compulsive disorder

Effect of continuous and partial reinforcement on the acquisition and extinction of human conditioned fear.