Abstract:In real situations, people are often faced with the option of voluntary contribution to achieve a collective goal, for example, building a dam or a fence, in order to avoid an unfavorable loss. Those who do not donate, however, can free ride on others' sacrifices. As a result, cooperation is difficult to maintain, leading to an enduring collective-risk social dilemma. To address this issue, here we propose a simple yet effective theoretical model of threshold public goods game with collective risk and focus on the effect of risk on the emergence of social cooperation. To do this, we consider the population dynamics represented by replicator equation for two simplifying scenarios, respectively: one with fair sharers, who contribute the minimum average amount versus defectors and the other with altruists contributing more than average versus defectors. For both cases, we find that the dilemma is relieved in high-risk situations where cooperation is likely to persist and dominate defection in the population. Large initial endowment to individuals also encourages the risk-averse action, which means that, as compared to poor players (with small initial endowment), wealthy individuals (with large initial endowment) are more likely to cooperate in order to protect their private accounts. In addition, we show that small donation amount and small threshold (collective target) can encourage and sustain cooperation. Furthermore, for other parameters fixed, the impacts of group size act differently on the two scenarios because of distinct mechanisms: in the former case where the cost of cooperation depends on the group size, large size of group readily results in defection, while easily maintains cooperation in the latter case where the cost of cooperation is fixed irrespective of the group size. Our theoretical results of the replicator dynamics are in excellent agreement with the individual based simulation results.

An experimental comparison of contributions in collective prevention games and public goods games

Cooperation and Charity in Spatial Public Goods Game under Different Strategy Update Rules

Explaining Cooperative Behavior in Public Goods Games: How Preferences and Beliefs Affect Contribution Levels

Voluntary Cooperation for Mitigating Collective-Risk under Spatial Externalities

Emergence of Social Cooperation in Threshold Public Goods Games with Collective Risk.

Cooperation in public goods experiments with random and finite stopping rules

Beyond a binary theorizing of prosociality

Heterogeneous contributions can jeopardize cooperation in the Public Goods Game

Diversity of contribution promotes cooperation in public goods games

Are teams conditionally cooperative? Experimental evidence from a public goods game

Experimental Study of Private Voluntary Provision of Public Goods

Confusion cannot explain cooperative behavior in public goods games

Position uncertainty in a sequential public goods game: an experiment

Asymmetric effects of social and economic incentives on cooperation in real effort based public goods games

Herd Behaviour in Public Goods Games

Human cooperation in changing groups in a large-scale public goods game

Effects of individual and collective decision rule on cooperation in public goods game

Information Dynamics and Intelligent Cooperation in Networked Societies

Altruism Design in Networked Public Goods Games

Real-effort in the Multilevel Public Goods Game