Advancing Health Equity by Disaggregating Race, Ethnicity, and Social Data

Alejandro Plana,Bryan A. Smith,Marshall H. Chin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2024.35617

2024-09-27

JAMA Network Open

Abstract:One of us (A.P.) was born in the US with a Cuban-born father and a Mexican American mother and was acutely aware of the different social and economic success achieved by Latinx subpopulations. The Cuban migration in the 1950s and 1960s was predominantly a middle-class exodus and is likely why economic and health trajectories of older Cubans in the US have been more favorable than the courses of Latinx ethnic subpopulations with poorer and less educated immigrants. Caring for patients with heart failure on Chicago's south side, we also recognize the increased challenges of Black patients from the Englewood neighborhood (median income 2018-2022, 39 952). 1 Historically, our systems for analyzing ethnic and racial categories in the US have not recognized the heterogeneity of Latinx and Black populations. Similarly, the article by Cheng et al 2 demonstrates how an aggregate Asian ethnicity category makes important inequities in heart failure across ethnicities invisible. Specifically, Cheng et al found that Southeast Asian individuals have higher incidence and prevalence of heart failure compared with East Asian individuals. 2 Heart failure is a model chronic condition for improving health inequities with state of the art, multidisciplinary team–based care. As clinicians, we need to tailor our care to the medical and social needs of individual patients. Overall, cardiologists do a good job determining how patients' guideline-based care should be based upon their heart failure class and medical features. However, the health care system does a worse job addressing the social needs of patients and implementing care plans that successfully provide evidence-based care. How can we, as individuals and health care systems, address the social barriers to care experienced in the clinic such as miscommunication, mistrust, health literacy, and limited English proficiency? Also, how can we address the barriers patients face obtaining medications, following exercise guidelines, and improving dietary habits? The ethnicity category Southeast Asian encompass diverse ethnicities including Vietnamese, Cambodian, and Laotian. We describe Vietnamese history to illustrate why it is important to understand specific histories and lived experiences to tailor care, health systems, and policies to improve health equity. 3 Among Asian American individuals in the California Health Interview Survey, 4 Vietnamese individuals have worse health outcomes compared with Asian individuals overall for measures such as reporting fair or poor health (36.4% vs 17.8%), disability rates (30.1% vs 21.0%), and rates of heart disease (4.8% vs 4.4%). Vietnamese individuals reported higher rates of lacking a usual source of care than Asian individuals overall (18.4% vs 17.4%). 4 To tackle these health inequities, we must understand the context of the Vietnam War, waves of immigration, and resettlement policy. 5 The first wave of immigration occurred in 1975 before the fall of Saigon, favoring advantaged and privileged groups with ties to the US government. The second wave of immigration beginning in 1978 consisted of political refugees (ie, boat people) who frequently experienced extreme hardships and trauma at sea and in refugee camps before resettlement to the US. The third wave was family reunification efforts in the 1980s and 1990s. The Vietnam War forced people to migrate with little preparation and give up most of their possessions. Resettlement efforts were usually underresourced. Many Vietnamese immigrants obtained low-paying jobs below their training. Thus, compared with Asian individuals overall, Vietnamese individuals have high rates (21.3%) of being at or below 0% to 99% of the federal poverty level and fewer financial assets, both of which are associated with health inequities. 5 In addition, racial discrimination and limited English proficiency are associated with increased odds of poor self-reported health for Vietnamese people. 6 Thus, programs to care for and prevent heart failure must account for diversity of Vietnamese experiences; interventions to improve health equity should address trauma, discrimination, limited English proficiency, and insufficient economic resources. To identify risk factors and create solutions for health inequities among Latinx populations, it is also critical to disaggregate ethnicity and social data to understand lived experiences, such as immigration history. Following the Cuban revolution of 1959, approximately 250 000 mostly highly educated, middle class Cuban individuals emigrated to the US in the Golden Exile. 7 However, 650 000 less advantaged Cuban Americans emigrated between 1995 and 2015 following the fall of the Soviet Union. 7 These later emigrants were primarily unski -Abstract Truncated-

medicine, general & internal