Management Effectiveness Evaluation of Three Models of Family Doctor Services

Chen Bi-hu
Abstract:Objective This study was designed to survey and analyze the advantages and weaknesses of three models of family doctor services in Xuhui District. Methods Random sampling survey was conducted in 10 neighborhood committees served by our Community Health Service Center to compare three selected models of family doctor services,including central clinic-based service( Model 1 as control),neighborhood committee-based service as per designated residential blocks in accordance with household registration system( Model 2),and service station-based family doctor service( Model 3). These three models were compared during the period from January to December 2011 in terms of health workforce cost,regional health service balance,and service effectiveness. Results The three models were complementary with unique advantages. However,given the same health workforce cost and serving the same population,Model 2 provided better outcome and more balanced regional health services,evidenced by satisfaction rate for basic medical service,awareness rate of neighborhood family doctor,control rate of hypertension and diabetes mellitus,proportion of the residents who have signed an service agreement,average annual percentage of the residents( who have signed an agreement with a family doctor) visiting his/her family doctor,and rate of successful outpatient appointment. Model 2 also gave better service balance among different neighborhood committees than the other two models in terms of proportion of the residents who have signed an agreement with a family doctor,management rate of hypertension and diabetes mellitus,and assessment rate of family doctor's health mnagement. Conclusion Neighborhood committee-based family doctor service as per designated residential blocks( Model 2) was better in terms of health service balance and effectiveness. It may be future direction of the family doctor services in our Community Health Service Center.
Medicine
What problem does this paper attempt to address?