Abstract:Constraint programming (CP) has been recently in the spotlight after new CP-based procedures have been incorporated into state-of-the-art solvers, most notably the CP Optimizer from IBM. Classical CP solvers were only capable of guaranteeing the optimality of a solution, but they could not provide bounds for the integer feasible solutions found if interrupted prematurely due to, say, time limits. New versions, however, provide bounds and optimality guarantees, effectively making CP a viable alternative to more traditional mixed-integer programming (MIP) models and solvers. We capitalize on these developments and conduct a computational evaluation of MIP and CP models on 12 select scheduling problems. 1 We carefully chose these 12 problems to represent a wide variety of scheduling problems that occur in different service and manufacturing settings. We also consider basic and well-studied simplified problems. These scheduling settings range from pure sequencing (e.g., flow shop and open shop) or joint assignment-sequencing (e.g., distributed flow shop and hybrid flow shop) to pure assignment (i.e., parallel machine) scheduling problems. We present MIP and CP models for each variant of these problems and evaluate their performance over 17 relevant and standard benchmarks that we identified in the literature. The computational campaign encompasses almost 6,623 experiments and evaluates the MIP and CP models along five dimensions of problem characteristics, objective function, decision variables, input parameters, and quality of bounds. We establish the areas in which each one of these models performs well and recognize their conceivable reasons. The obtained results indicate that CP sets new limits concerning the maximum problem size that can be solved using off-the-shelf exact techniques. History: Accepted by Pascal Van Hentenryck, Area Editor for Computational Modeling: Methods & Analysis. Supplemental Material: The software that supports the findings of this study is available within the paper and its Supplemental Information ( https://pubsonline.informs.org/doi/suppl/10.1287/ijoc.2023.1287 ) as well as from the IJOC GitHub software repository ( https://github.com/INFORMSJoC/2021.0326 ) at ( http://dx.doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.7541223 ).

Linear Programming-Based Preprocessing Algorithm and Tightening Constraints for Multiperiod Blend Scheduling Problems

MINLP Algorithms Mixed with Constraint Programming

Modeling and Optimization Methods of Integrated Production Planning for Steel Plate Mill with Flexible Customization

Computational Enhancements of Continuous Production Scheduling MILPs Using Tightening Constraints

Alternative Formulations and Improvements with Valid Inequalities for the Refinery Production Scheduling Problem Involving Operational Transitions

Single-machine Makespan Minimization Scheduling with Nonlinear Shortening Processing Times

Optimization for integrated scheduling of intelligent handling equipment with bidirectional flows and limited buffers at automated container terminals

Mixed Integer linear programming and constraint programming models for the online printing shop scheduling problem

An MILP Formulation for Optimizing Detailed Schedules of a Multiproduct Pipeline Network

Efficient Lagrangian Decomposition Approach for Solving Refinery Production Scheduling Problems Involving Operational Transitions of Mode Switching

Optimizing detailed schedules of a multiproduct pipeline by a monolithic MILP formulation

A Mixed Integer Linear Programming Formulation for Subway Timetable Optimization Problems with Passenger Waiting and Energy Saving Objectives

A New Simple Effective Continuous-time Model for Scheduling of General Batch Plants.

Mixed-Integer Programming vs. Constraint Programming for Shop Scheduling Problems: New Results and Outlook

Optimization Based Scheduling for a Class of Production Systems with Integral Constraints

New formulation for scheduling flexible flow shop problems

Optimizing Scheduling of Refinery Operations Based on Piecewise Linear Models

Mixed-Integer Linear Programming Model for Gasoline Blending and Distribution Scheduling

Lagrangian Decomposition Approach for Solving Continuous-Time Scheduling Models of Refinery Production Problems

Scheduling under Linear Constraints.