Exploring the limitations of mitochondrial dye as a genuine horizontal mitochondrial transfer surrogate

Chuanfang Chen,Haige Li,Jia Zhang,Shih-Chin Cheng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s42003-024-05964-6

IF: 6.548

2024-03-08

Communications Biology

Abstract:Rosamine-based mitochondrial dyes, such as Mitotracker Red, have commonly been employed to visualize mitochondrial localization within cells due to their preferential accumulation in organelles with membrane potential. Consequently, Mitotracker Red has often served as a surrogate indicator for tracking mitochondrial movement between neighboring cells. However, it is important to note that the presence of membrane potential in the cell membrane and other organelles may lead to the non-specific partial enrichment of Mitotracker Red in locations other than mitochondria. This study comprehensively investigates the reliability of mitochondrial dye as a marker for studying horizontal mitochondrial transfer (HMT). By meticulous replicating of previous experiments and comparing the efficiency of mitochondrial dye transfer with that of mito-targeted GFP, our findings confirm that HMT occurs at significantly lower efficiency than previously indicated by Mitotracker dye. Subsequent experiments involving mitochondria-deficient cells robustly demonstrates the non-specificity of mitochondrial dye as indicator for mitochondria. We advocate for a thorough reevaluation of existing literature in this field and propose exploration of alternative techniques to enhance the investigation of HMT. By addressing these pivotal aspects, we can advance our understanding of cellular dynamics and pave the way for future explorations in this captivating field.

biology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem this paper attempts to address is: **the reliability and specificity of mitochondrial dyes (such as Mitotracker Red) as markers for horizontal mitochondrial transfer (HMT)**.

Specifically, researchers have noted that although mitochondrial dyes primarily accumulate in mitochondria within cells, these dyes may also be attracted to other organelles or cell membranes with membrane potential, leading to non-specific enrichment. Therefore, using mitochondrial dyes to track HMT may overestimate the actual efficiency of mitochondrial transfer. To verify this, the authors conducted a systematic study through the following methods:

1. **Replicating previous experiments**: Reproduced experiments using Mitotracker Red to label mitochondria and observed its transfer between different cell types.
2. **Comparing the transfer efficiency of mitochondrial dyes with specific proteins**: Compared the transfer efficiency of Mitotracker Red with that of mitochondrial-specific proteins (such as mito-targeted GFP) and found that the transfer efficiency of the dye was significantly higher than that of the protein.
3. **Using cells lacking mitochondria**: Further validated the non-specific transfer of mitochondrial dyes through Parkin-induced mitophagy and using red blood cells (which naturally lack mitochondria).

The study results indicate that the transfer of mitochondrial dyes does not equate to true mitochondrial transfer, suggesting that existing HMT studies in the literature need to be re-evaluated and alternative techniques explored to improve the accuracy of HMT research.