Abstract:Nearly optimal solutions of linear programming models provide useful information when some of the relevant objectives and constraints are not explicitized in the models. This paper presents a three steps framework to study nearly optimal solutions of linear programming models developed for land use exploration. The first step is to define low dimensional vectors called ‘aspects’ to summarize the solutions. The second step is to generate a group of optimal and of nearly optimal solutions. Three methods are proposed for generating nearly optimal solutions. Method i proceeds by minimization of sums of decision variables that are non-zero in the optimal solution and in previously generated nearly optimal solutions. Method ii proceeds by maximization of sums of randomly selected decision variables. Method iii is targeted at searching nearly optimal solutions with very different values for the aspects. Finally, the third step of the framework is to present graphically the values of the aspects of the generated solutions. The framework is illustrated with a case study in which a linear programming model developed for land use exploration at the European level is presented. First, an optimal solution is calculated with the model by minimizing nitrogen loss with constraints on area, water use, product balances, and manure balances. Then, 52 nearly optimal solutions are generated by using methods i, ii, and iii with a deviation tolerance of 5% from the optimal value of nitrogen loss. Each solution is summarized by three different aspects that represent the allocations of the agricultural area among two regions, among five types of crop rotation, and among five production orientations respectively. Graphical presentation of these aspects and principal component analysis show that nearly optimal solutions can be very different from the optimal solution in terms of land use allocations. For example, the agricultural area allocated to the north of the European Community varies from 10.9 to 50.2×106 ha among the 52 generated nearly optimal solutions, whereas this area is equal to 26.5×106 ha in the optimal solution. The comparison of methods i, ii, and iii shows that the solutions generated with method iii are quite more contrasted than the solutions generated with methods i and ii. The case study presented in this paper illustrates how our methodological framework can be used to allow a stakeholder to select a satisfactory solution according to issues that cannot be quantified in a model.

Modelling Investment Optimization on Smallholder Farms through Multiple Criteria Decision Making and Goal Programming: A Case Study from Ethiopia

A Multi-objective Decision Model of Farmers' Crop Production

Modelling a nationwide crop planning problem using a multiple criteria decision making tool

Exploring trade-offs in agro-ecological landscapes: using a multi-objective land-use allocation model to support agroforestry research

Integrated modelling approaches for sustainable agri-economic growth and environmental improvement: Examples from Canada, Greece, and Ireland

A multi-objective mathematical model of a water management problem with environmental impacts: An application in an irrigation project

Optimization of Agricultural Resource Allocation among Crops: A Portfolio Model Analysis

Mixed integer linear programming models for optimal crop selection

A framework to study nearly optimal solutions of linear programming models developed for agricultural land use exploration

Multi-objective optimization and design of farming systems

Multi-objective economic-resource-production optimization of sustainable organic mixed farming systems with nutrient recycling

Group Decision Support for agriculture planning by a combination of Mathematical Model and Collaborative Tool

A multi-objective optimisation approach to water management

Multi-Objective Optimization of Integrated Crop–Livestock Systems: Exploring Resource Allocation Based on Emergy Evaluation

Sustainable Optimization of Agricultural Production

A Fuzzy-Stochastic Modeling Approach for Multiple Criteria Decision Analysis of Coupled Groundwater-Agricultural Systems

Planning sustainable development through a scenario-based stochastic goal programming model

An integrated model for planning and managing multi-regional mixed-crop farming schemes

A framework to use crop models for multi-objective constrained optimization of irrigation strategies

Managing agricultural water and land resources with tradeoff between economic, environmental, and social considerations: A multi-objective non-linear optimization model under uncertainty

Agricultural Investment Project Decisions Based on an Interactive Preference Disaggregation Model Considering Inconsistency